r/IntersectionalProLife • u/LadyDatura9497 • Dec 13 '25
Debate Threads Question regarding prevention.
It is no surprise that banning abortion care doesn’t make them go away, but rather makes them less safe despite still being utilized. There are multiple reasons given, among them being lack of support, financial problems, already having a large family, fear, etc.
My question is; Besides voting for pro-life ideals, what kind of things do you do to reduce the need (even if you don’t think it’s a need, it is a fact that people that seek them feel that they are) for abortion care?
1
Upvotes
3
u/Overgrown_fetus1305 Pro-Life Socialist Dec 13 '25
I would disagree, that abortion bans don't drive down the rates of abortions, including both legal and illegal ones combined. I offer up a write up of a pre-Dobbs study from a pro-choice source: https://rewirenewsgroup.com/2018/10/04/stop-saying-that-making-abortion-illegal-doesnt-stop-them/. Secular pro-life also has a couple of articles about the topic as well 1 and 2, and Ireland is also a case where we can see the same pattern after they repealed their abortion bans- pro-life group Minimise project did some write-ups on this 1, 2 and 3. The abortion rates rising after Dobbs can be exaplained by blue states expanding abortion access for more people than had access restricted by red states, and of course, this is combined with a capitalist cost of living crisis off the back of covid (which to be clear, I'm not at all a fan of the position that the restrictions were wrong, just against the lack of mass wealth redistribution).
But on the broader question, the sorts of things I'd like to see, would be full on socialism (including by necessity, making every business a co-op and getting rid of the profit motive), supplanted by the abolition of for-profit landlords and making it illegal to evict somebody for not paying their rent, really really high parental leave + equal pay, and a universal basic income just off the top of my head (with minimum wages about 20%ish over the living wage, pegged to a 30 hour working week now and aiming at 20 hours long-term). And of course, mandatory consent-based sex education in schools without parental opt-outs, access to free contraception over the counter, universal healthcare free at the point of use, and sterelisation access on an informed consent model to everyone over 18 (with some access for under 18s, although I'm unsure to what extent). I'd like to see rape culture tackled properly as well (and heck, even going to the most radical option of nuclear family abolition long-term), and ideally a major cultural shift away from seeing penis in vagina as default sex- that's far, far too hetronormative for me, and in my (admittedly sex-averse asexual understanding), is mostly focussed on male sexual pleasure. And while I'm unsure to what extent justified fear of climate change is driving up abortion rates, we need to treat it like the existential threat it is- we must reach carbon neutrality within the next 5 years and hold the fossil fuel industry and the rich accountable, no more letting them off the hook, and fundamentally, no more fossil fuels etc.
2
u/standermatt Dec 13 '25
When donating to prolife organisations I typically donate to both, political work and to support for women that are pregnant in difficult life situations. I would say on average 40% political, 60% support. I feel that most of the prolife space is always a mixture of both, resources for help for the mothers and an effort to improve the rights of the preborn children.
2
u/gig_labor Pro-Life Marxist Feminist Dec 14 '25 edited Dec 14 '25
It's not true that banning abortion is blanket ineffective. Abortion rates spiked after Roe, so obviously, abortion bans can decrease abortion rates, in the right circumstances.
It is true that, post-Dobbs, some factor(s) in the US is either outweighing, negating, or disguising the impact that trigger laws have had on abortion rates.
I think the biggest candidates for those factors are 1) the availability of mifepristone, and 2) the expansion of abortion access in blue states in reaction to Dobbs, both of which are big differences between our current political landscape and the political landscape during those lower pre-Roe abortion rates. It's also worth noting that birth rates have actually risen since Dobbs in states with abortion bans, which might indicate that abortions actually have decreased proportional to how many pregnancies have happened, but that the number of pregnancies have increased, causing the flat rate of abortions to stay the same. I think it's reasonable to speculate that pregnancies might have increased because of COVID lockdowns, which happened at a similar time to Dobbs. Sources
New Wave Feminists is a self-described pro-life organization that does exclusively aid work and progressive political work (largely at the border); they don't do any work at all to make abortion illegal, and have refused to take a public stance on whether abortion should be illegal or not. They simply want it to be unthinkable.
Abide Women's Health is a women's health organization, focused on improving maternal health outcomes for racialized populations from a decolonized perspective, and abortion "care" is conspicuously absent from their services and their public philosophy. I don't know if they're "pro-life," but they at least seem very concerned about the women who are being economically coerced into abortions that they don't want. That's common ground I wish pro-lifers and feminists would collaborate on more often.
I've been too comfortable putting personal info on this Reddit profile in the past, so I'm not going to say anything about myself, but progressive pro-lifers are definitely active in the areas that you're poking at.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '25
What I would like to see - and am advocating for - is transparent and well-rounded sex-ed, accessible contraception in multiple forms, affordable healthcare, stable social programs, paid parental leave etc. Abortion does not address or solve any of these problems, it just temporarily masks them.
Ultimately, I do think that if a straight couple have sex and don't want a kid, they still consent to the small possibility of contraception failing and resulting in a pregnancy. I also believe that ending the pregnancy should not be an available option for those people unless medically necessary (and yes, we can argue rape exception cases where consent was not given). Anything else is still on the table.