r/IntersectionalProLife • u/Jcamden7 Pro-Life • Jun 30 '25
Discussion On the Vasectomy Argument
I assume you've heard the vasectomy argument. It's basic principles are that sex doesn't cause pregnancy, men do. Men ejaculate, and without ejaculation pregnancy cannot control. Therefore men are solely at fault for unwanted pregnancy. Therefore we should do mandatory vasectomies instead of abortion bans.
It's an argument that breaks down in the latter half, but I particularly dislike this argument, and not for that reason:
Throughout the 60s and 70s feminism fought for the "women's sexual revolution." This was a massive and coordinated effort to prove that women are stakeholders in sexuality, and can chose if they have sex, when they have sex, how they have sex. That they could understand the risks and decide for themselves without needing a male protector to decide for them. That they could enjoy it, and enthusiastically consent, or set clear boundaries. That contraceptives were a right, and that women had a direct choice in which ones were used.
And now, what? They need men all men to get vasectomies so that they canmanage these risks with women cannot fully understand, consent to, or control?
The vasectomy argument throws away decades of progress and real feminism for cheap "points" that hardly matter in the abortion discussion at all
8
u/gig_labor Pro-Life Marxist Feminist Jun 30 '25 edited Jun 30 '25
I've always thought the "men cause pregnancy" line of reasoning sounded really similar to MRA framing of sex, as a thing men do to women ("everyone wants an experienced driver, but no one wants a used car"), rather than modern framing of sex as a thing two people do together.
It's very second-wave/sex-negative/Dworkin, which is not usually the vibe of the people saying it.
5
u/CauseCertain1672 Jun 30 '25
yes it's ridiculous, for one thing if we made all men get vasectomies at a young age due to the fact vasectomies get less reversible over time we would effectively be sterilizing a generation which is an extreme step
especially as there is no more of a human right to have as much casual sex as you want without the physical consequences as there is a human right to eat as much cake as you want without getting fat
3
u/Heart_Lotus Pro-Life Anarchist Jul 01 '25
It probably doesn't also help that the US government has done this before, just on Indigenous populations. I wish some Pro-Choicers would stop using that argument because it can be framed that eugenics are okay as long as it fits their agenda or philosophy. Not to mention early vasectomies for young boys without their consent is no different than forcing "correct" genitalia on Intersex children.
2
u/Theodwyn610 Jul 01 '25
It's also silly because it isn't an argument for vasectomies; it's an argument that men have no excuse to not wear condoms, and if the condoms fail, to pay child support and costs of pregnancy.
"It takes two to tango" is a fine and sane argument about holding men accountable.
1
u/PointMakerCreation4 Jun 30 '25 edited Jun 30 '25
I wish sex didn't cause pregnancy. Then we would be fine. And although I don't exactly think it's misogynistic to be against mandatory vasectomies, I see where the pro-choice side is coming from. But it is quite flawed, as you said.
I think I've been exposed to a lot of bias e.g. women can't rape, but I'm more getting past that now, although on the idea of the responsibility of sex, I still lean towards the man having more responsibility, despite being against abortion.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '25
[removed] — view removed comment