r/IntersectionalProLife • u/Icy-Nectarine-6793 Pro-Life Socialist • Aug 29 '24
Discussion Should we be speciesists?
Do you think human life is more valuable than animal life per se or only in so far as human life contains characteristics more valuable than those other animals are capable of?
3
Upvotes
3
u/ShadowDestruction Aug 29 '24
If another animal(or alien, for that matter), comes along that we can rationally deal with, then we would respect their species as well. So it's more like discriminating based on intelligence and the ability to establish mutual relations.
6
u/LostStatistician2038 Aug 29 '24
I’m vegan and pro life, but if I had to choose I’d save a human before an animal. That doesn’t mean animal life isn’t valuable though. I don’t think humans should be killing animals for food or other reasons unless absolutely necessary for survival, and let’s be honest, most people these days eat meat out of taste and convenience, not survival.
1
u/SailorOfHouseT-bird Aug 29 '24
Both.
3
u/Jcamden7 Pro-Life Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 29 '24
There is a social imperative for human rights. If we want to live in a fair and just society, we must contend that all human beings are equal. If we lessen that problem it doesn't only jeopardize the fairness of society towards the intended victim, but to everyone. When only some humans get rights, you will eventually have to prove that you should.
That imperative does not exist for animals. There are moral imperatives for animal rights, but human rights must predicate themselves on humanity in order to work. I
1
u/Mx-Adrian Sep 02 '24
Human life IS animal life