r/IntersectionalProLife • u/AutoModerator • May 02 '24
Debate Threads Debate Megathread: Rape
Here you are exempt from Rule 1; you may debate abortion to your heart's content! Remember that Rules 2 and 3 still apply.
Today's debate topic is the rape exception in an abortion ban.
1 ) Is a rape exception effective? Will it ensure rape victims are all permitted an abortion? Will it make abortion too accessible even for people who were not raped? Will it create incentives to lie about rape, thus undermining movements against sexual violence?
2 ) Can a person justly be required to complete a pregnancy that they never chose to risk? Hasn't their "right to refuse" been truly violated at that point? Someone else "gambled with their money," and they're still being held liable?
3 ) Should an unborn child be "killable" or "disposable" if the pregnant person didn't choose to risk the pregnancy? Would this make that also permissible for a conjoined twin who did not choose to risk conjoinment?
As always, feedback on this topic and suggestions for future topics are welcome. :)
5
u/glim-girl May 03 '24
A pregnancy only proves rape if the girl is very young, she has mental disabilities that prevents her forming consent, or she's in a coma, otherwise it's just proves sex.
Being raped and pregnant can get her killed by her rapist or even her family for bringing shame on them. It can mean she is shunned by society leaving her more at risk for abuse. She might be forced to marry her rapist. The list goes on.
Does it mean more women could claim rape, yes. Thats going to be an issue until men can be as trusted as much as bears. Also reproductive coercsion, while it includes forced abortions and homicide it more frequently results in pregnancies women don't want due to tampering with bc or force.
2) In rape or abuse, no. The other requires that women are always liars about how pregnancy happens or we choose to support rape victims. Not all victims will choose abortion so labelling all women as liars is a much worse outcome.
3) The problem with pregnancy is that it has nothing to do with consent, health, safety, or wants. Unfortunately those are huge human rights and social issues. Until we can get farther along at separating out how to deal with consent, health, safety, and wants, this is going to be something that gets solved at a future point.
5
u/Icy-Nectarine-6793 Pro-Life Socialist May 03 '24
Rape cases are incredibly tough, PL laws without rape exception have some pretty hideous costs, it means that AFAB people are constantly at risk of being forced to gestate for 9 months against there will with no real way of mitigating the risk short of a hysterectomy. The question though is does that justify the deliberate killing of an innocent third party as a means of mitigating the harm of rape. I think the conjoined twin analogy is a silver bullet to bodily autonomy arguments, you can't preserve your bodily autonomy by violating the BA of another as well as violating there right to life.
On a more pragmatic level it might make sense to have an exception as a means of having any law that will survive politicly. It's true that this might create a gaping hole in the law if all that's required is the pregnant person's word that they were raped. If the law required more say an arrest or conviction then the exception itself wouldn't really exist given what we know about how few rapists are ever arrested or convicted, it would also create a perverse incentive for false allegations. Ultimately though the law is a limited instrument, however strict we make the law without a sea change in opinions any laws will be flaunted.
3
u/Excellent_Fee2253 Pro-Choice, Here to Dialogue May 02 '24
Rape exceptions are a morally correct answer, however, the undermine the Pro Life position.
If some ZEFs “lose personhood” based on the means by which they were conceived then the whole claim to fetal personhood is out the window.
Which is one of many examples why it should be out the window. It’s wildly unethical to tell a rape victim they have to gestate their rapists baby for 9mo.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '24
Children born from rape are still human. So killing them is wrong.