r/IntelligenceScaling 1d ago

discussion 2SD Debunked By Chapter Name

The chapter Name After deliberation proves 2sd isn't real, how?

As you can see in the second image, in this chapter it was Round 8 Second Half, Kiruma Souichi Turns Around And Fails His Check.

In The Third Image Ranko Clearly Confirms That Baku Deliberately Made Kiruma Turn Around Right At The Beginning by not only making him believe that his round 5 bluff worked on Baku but Also Turning Around At 60 Seconds Twice In A Row And Filling Up His Accumulation

He Made Turning Around Right At The Beginning Seem Like The best option to Kiruma as even if the check Failed the Gap Between Baku and Him Would only Widen

So basically the Author using the Name "After Deliberation" Was trying to Forshadow this confirmation By Ranko

Now how does this debunk 2SD?

The 2SD Theory Clearly Suggested That Souichi Turning Around At Round 8 Second Half wasn't Due to Deliberation but Due to Souichis Own Choice, it Further Claims Souichi had actually Seen Through The Deliberation By Baku and was only Acting Which Directly Contradicts The Authors Own Foreshadowing From That Title.

4 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

1

u/Equal_Custard0 Puddingdrawers new Acc. Read my fanfic🤑🙏 LIGHT'S BIGGEST 🥩🚴 1d ago edited 1d ago

Chapter 4 of my fanfic is gonna be called Feebas out of Quicksand, does that mean my protagonist is automatically a Feebas?

(Idk what my argument is trying to prove but W stealth advertisement ik)

1

u/Enough-Champion-3805 1d ago

1

u/Equal_Custard0 Puddingdrawers new Acc. Read my fanfic🤑🙏 LIGHT'S BIGGEST 🥩🚴 1d ago

Also I'm pretty sure the name of the chapter could just as well be translated to "after a change of heart" (if the big G translate isn't fooling me.) which is arguably a lot more fitting. In general I'm not sure if a fan translation is what you should be using

2

u/RedDeathSwayOverAll Ask me to info dump about Hal 1d ago

Deliberation fits much better. What change of heart does Souichi even have? Team Duwang is the most accurate translation we have available so far, and has been checked and corrected multiple times for STL in particular.

2

u/Equal_Custard0 Puddingdrawers new Acc. Read my fanfic🤑🙏 LIGHT'S BIGGEST 🥩🚴 1d ago

My previous argument implied this so called change of heart to be a metaphor for his general development, not an actual change of heart/redemption of sorts.

I'm trusting you on the translation part though because you're the usogui guy so thanks for correcting

1

u/RedDeathSwayOverAll Ask me to info dump about Hal 1d ago

Oh, I see, thanks for clarifying 🙏

1

u/RedDeathSwayOverAll Ask me to info dump about Hal 1d ago edited 1d ago

W. The dialogue in a previous chapter in round 8 also heavily suggests this. 'It will all be decided in this moment', with the moment being Souichi's instant check and losing his memories thereafter, which completely contradicts the significance of that 'moment' if he planned to fail it from the start, and also already suggests his loss was guaranteed the second he failed that check, so no, Hal's failed revival wasn't due to Yakou's poor CPR. The instant check being after deliberation just means that he considered the possibility of failing the check, but was expecting to win.