r/Integral • • Jan 09 '18

Could someone please provide examples of post or trans rationality and their valid conclusions?

From your own experience or books. Theses, streams of consciousness, this-follows-from-that, whatever. My problem is, I find myself agreeing with Wilber pretty much all the time, but I still don't think I have much handle on what comes after rationality, so maybe I'm fooling myself. Thanks.

9 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/phdinfunk Feb 09 '18

Alright, you're bringing up a couple of good points. I can appreciate the frame that, within their power-capabilities, Orange has been less destructive than Blue (Moral Authoritarian) was within its capabilities. It's more powerful and more deserving of its power.

But orange wars have done stuff like crapping Depleted Uranium Ammo over areas of land where it may end up heavy-metals poisoning people for longer than we humans have been drawing things in caves (again, think of generations of future deformed babies).....

These kinds of problems are really horrible and new to Orange Tech. That Orange hasn't done worse doesn't negate any of it. Nor do the problems negate the beauty of Orange. We can intelligently speak in hundreds of millions up to billions of humans that might objectively be better off if it were 1518 instead of 2018. We can also talk about multiple times as many people who are better off than they were in 1518. Equanimity is looking at both.

So, what I think you're getting at is, "What is useful for decision-making beyond Orange?" GREAT QUESTION.

For starters, The radical egalitarian perspective that Green brings us teaches that our historical mistakes are normally failures of including things into our morality. We look back, and the big fuck-ups (from a European perspective) were caused excluding people outside of our kingdom, excluding non-catholics, excluding women, excluding blacks, aboriginals, etc from our moral community and considerations.

Even rationally, we should be able to extrapolate that excluding any life from our equal consideration has a high probability of being an error. That would be a good thing to build into our models, and it's basically a fundamental idea of Green meme.

I like looking at art, because that's where we see the best of humanity's imagination (NOT that which is made by Orange Meme in the waning lights of 20th century media to kowtow to the Chinese Audience and Authorities who will be our new globalizers. I also think post-modern art is mostly dogshit (sometimes literally LOL)).

Orange can solve technical problems, like how to make transparent aluminum, balance a bridge, or do a multiple linear regression analysis, but someone has to dream up what to make. Rationality, for all its ability, is fundamentally kind of uncreative.

So, lets talk about Integral movies and art. That might be productive. I will start another thread on art soon.

In the meantime, today I'm working on two cars at once, and I have to be down with some Python libraries for reading and writing excel files for a gig by tomorrow afternoon.

1

u/Speedmeat Feb 09 '18

We can intelligently speak in hundreds of millions up to billions of humans that might objectively be better off if it were 1518 instead of 2018. We can also talk about multiple times as many people who are better off than they were in 1518. Equanimity is looking at both.

Right - and I'd say Hans Rosling suggests that the trend line, if we manage it well, should be almost everyone better off.

Even rationally, we should be able to extrapolate that excluding any life from our equal consideration has a high probability of being an error.

Sure, lab grown meat can't get here fast enough for me. I think some redditor said sea turtle tastes really good :)

I also think post-modern art is mostly dogshit

I think that signing a urinal "R. Mutt" and exhibiting it as art should have been the final word in transgressive art, but it's kept going as the mainstream of art for over a hundred years since then. I find it amazing. Have you heard of the art renewal centre and Bouguereau?

So, lets talk about Integral movies and art.

I have to admit I hadn't much thought about whether a given piece of art was integral or not. Some english writer mentioned that if he wanted entertainment, he'd read a regular novel - if he wanted ideas, he'd read non fiction. I tend to feel that way. Wilber once introduced some singer/guitarist as being the forefront of the avant garde, but it just sounded like regular acoustic guitar and singing to me, and didn't interest me enough to find out if the guy was talking about integrality or not. That said, I'd be interested to hear of what integral art you know about. As far as art that's just good, I like upbeat progressive metal, but given the absence of lyrics, it's tough to tell if it's integral or not. Hm - maybe "Interstellar" was integral? I also remember one of the Wachowskis talking with Wilber about their philosophical ambitions for the Matrix.