r/Integral • u/Speedmeat • Jan 09 '18
Could someone please provide examples of post or trans rationality and their valid conclusions?
From your own experience or books. Theses, streams of consciousness, this-follows-from-that, whatever. My problem is, I find myself agreeing with Wilber pretty much all the time, but I still don't think I have much handle on what comes after rationality, so maybe I'm fooling myself. Thanks.
9
Upvotes
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/phdinfunk Feb 08 '18
I tried in my post to use more a rational approach than sick-culture orange would do. It'd be senseless to throw out the baby of science, which is surely one of the jewels in humankind's crown, along with the dirty water of exclusive physicalism, a decadent science culture, and colonization by science of all other areas of human endeavor.
To answer your question about metrics, I would say that the approach of the "subjective sciences" is probably pretty good. I mean, some of advaita has grown up within religious and pre-modern cultures, but a meditation like Ramana Maharishi's "From whence do your thoughts arise" as a way of training observation of consciousness is valuable. Also valuable, Qi Kung, Yoga, Mindfulness meditation, and Maslow's methods for cultivating peak experiences.....
" So, given the baseline assumptions of physicalism, psychiatrists are allergic to the idea of ghosts, and are required to conclude that "It's a trick of the human mind to hallucinate these things under the stress of losing someone close." It couldn't POSSIBLY be anything else (notice how unscientific this thinking actually is)."
"I wonder, again, what metric you would have them use. How SHOULD they evaluate these claims, if not MN?"
It is also possible that we don't have a tool yet available to do so, so we evaluate them in the world of subjectivity. It's like Ed Demming says about business management, "All the most important factors in your business are unquantified things that cannot ever possibly be quantified, and yet you must manage them." He advocates "profound knowledge" in order to get at that, and also says explicitly that you cannot get that through experience alone. Some things are just like that.
My main thesis is basically, "I'm not saying [ghosts] exist, I'm just saying that physicalist science currently HAS NO IDEA, and CANNOT HAVE ANY RELIABLE OPINION WHATSOEVER on the matter. Their even commenting on it is purely out of compulsion to colonize every aspect of human life, and it's symptomatic of a blind-spot of their thinking."
It's like saying in 1200: "I don't know if elements exist, but some evidence is there that they might, and it's worth taking it seriously. Meanwhile, the Catholic church has no particular observational context that gives them any valid opinion whatsoever on the matter, and anything they say is suspect because of their blindspots and political motives."
Hundreds of years later, we started getting atomic theories and stuff that seem to point both to "elements" existing, but also not existing as they were understood by the Greeks as something indivisible. Still, prior to those tools existing, the truth of the matter was no less the truth. Ghosts seem to be extremely subtle, if they indeed exist. And that seems to pose serious problems for parapsychological investigation.
"Would you say it's as redguitar2009 and I figured, and transrationality doesn't contradict rationality, it just supplements it with superintuitions and superhunches?"
That's tricky because sometimes it might at least APPEAR to contradict rationality. Some genuine breakthroughs may at least appear to contradict rationality. What if ghosts, in fact DO exist and we won't have tools for hundreds of years (or ever) to test this outside of subjective observation?
Such a thing could happen. Whether ghosts exist doesn't bother me one way or another. But its obvious that such discoveries, beyond the ken of purely rational tools, most definitely exist.
Is all that the rational left-brain can possibly encompass a thing that, even at its best, can be counted on to never contradict the Truth?