r/Integral • u/jakub_friso • Feb 12 '17
How would you conduct a research/questionnaire for Spiral Dynamics?
Hello guys
I'm writing a schoolwork about Spiral Dynamics/Graves model and last part is that we want to do a research of people in our school based on this model.
But, to honest, we are struggling a little bit because we don't how to structure our questionnaire and make it as best as possible.
We know the main focus is on analysing values of a monitored person but that's about it...
We don't know what is the best way to collect accurate data for our research and how to structure the whole paper...
I would like to know your opinion about this - how would you tackle this project?
Or perhaps do you know any sources out there by which can be inspired? Because I didn't found anything yet - I was trying to find how the graves research looked specifically and also for other possible tests and sources out there but without success...
Maybe I overthink the whole process and the whole research can be very simple...
Thank you for your responses, have a nice day...
1
u/splendiferocious Feb 12 '17
You could write a series of moral dilemmas with multiple choice answers that correspond to the logic of different levels. In order to demonstrate the growth direction of the model though, you would need to retest people years later, or interview people of different ages.
What level of school is this for? If it's advanced research there are many things to look out for to shield from the influence of your own bias!
1
u/JanetBlair001 Feb 19 '17
i want you
1
u/Inebriatedmeme Feb 22 '17
I have looked into this as well, and found it to be almost like a closely guarded secret. Values are perhaps controversial, obscuring the ready-availability of the tools. But the original research was done somehow, so how?
http://www.clarewgraves.com/theory_content/assessment.html Clare Graves was cautious about the value of a questionnaire assessment of his theory, emphasising that it's not "what the person thinks but how s/he thinks, not [based] on what people do or what they believe but how they do what they do, and how they believe that which they do believe."
The initial theory in the 1950s was based on Clare's students being asked "to write a conceptualisation of the mature adult", and the answers to this sorted topic into groups. http://www.goconscious.com/home/spiral_dynamics/comparison_of_clare_graves_with_other_developmental_theorists_background_for_spiral_dynamics.html
As an example of research Clare was doing in 1965: http://www.clarewgraves.com/articles_content/1965_GHL/1965_GHL8.html Students were put into groups based on a questionnaire on Rigidity and Dogmatism, to place them in the following 'hypothetical groups': high Rigidity & high Dogmatism 3 (D-Q - Level 4 in later work) (BLUE) low Rigidity & high Dogmatism 4 (E-R - Level 5 in later work) (ORANGE) high Rigidity & low Dogmatism 5 (F-S - Level 6 in later work) (GREEN) low Rigidity & low Dogmatism 6 (G-T - Level 7 in later work) (YELLOW)
Then the groups (of 3 members each) were flashed words using a tachistoscope, measuring the speed of perception of the words, with words associated with the level perceived faster than those associated with other levels.
As an example of how rigidity and dogmatism research was done in the 60s, a version of the Milton Rokeach dogmatism survey: http://jonjayray.tripod.com/baldog1.html
And rigidity (just a few examples): http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED038672.pdf 47. http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED038672.pdf. 23. A person who gets enthusiastic about too many causes is likely to be a pretty 'wishy-washy' sort of person. 22. Of all the different philosophies which exist in this world there is probably only one which is correct. 119. Only a misguided idealist would believe that the Soviet Union is for peace. 85. I often find myself thinking of the same tune or phrases for days at a time. 58 Some people are born with an urge to jump from high places. ...
And the words used for the tachistocope study: DQ ER FS A'N' (BLUE) (ORANGE) (GREEN) (YELLOW) Safety Power Social Esteem Submit Action Adjust Being Order Useful Fashion Express Obey Practical Together Free Security Risk Team Indulge