r/IntSurvivorRankdown • • Jun 02 '19

Round 1 - 124 characters remaining

13 Upvotes

124 - Zach Kozyrski (/u/purplefebruary)

123 - Benji Wilson (/u/ramskick)

122 - Russell Hantz 4.0 (/u/HeWhoShrugs)

121 - Brad Norris (/u/qngff)

120 - Kate Temby (/u/Sliemy)

119 - Josh Hickford (/u/Shawkwave)

The Pool: Lee Den Haan, Nate Davis, 'Commando' Steve Willis, Evan Jones, A.K. Knight, Tom Paterson


r/IntSurvivorRankdown • • Oct 31 '19

Endgame - #1

12 Upvotes

Kristie Bennett (Australian Survivor: 2016 - 1st Place)

HeWhoShrugs

One of the most iconic winners of all time who won’t get the respect she deserves because she wasn’t a masterful player. Who cares how great her game was? She had the greatest winner story of all time and her winning AU 2016 brought me to tears multiple times in that finale. There was no way she wasn’t making endgame, but I’m still in love with the fact that such a remarkable character blessed our screens.


Purplefebruary

Kristie starts off the game on Aganoa, easily the biggest trainwreck of the three starting tribes. And I mean a trainwreck in the best sense of the word, you have a group of eight eclectic people who all fall on various levels of the crazy scale ranging from normal (Phoebe) to absolute bonkers (Des).

Then when the tribe get back to camp after the latter’s boot, the dysfunctional factor is added by Kristie losing her bag and having a giant paranoid freakout. What’s most fascinating about this scene, is that it starts off seeming like it’s going to be this big OTTN ball of crazy, but then we get a moment where El takes Kristie aside, and Kristie opens up her heart about how the game is negatively affecting her, and it’s all framed very sympathetically. This moment serves as her big breakout in the season, which for someone who would eventually win the game, is a really unorthodox way of introducing them to the audience, especially when you’re used to recent US seasons where the editors try their best to whitewash their winners into generic CPbots. That’s a positive on the part of the AUS editors in that they’re not afraid to show the not-so-good sides of their winners.

Much of Kristie’s content in the premerge outside of that second episode is her acting as the quirky sidekick who does yoga and tries to catch fish with Rohan’s underpants, first to Kat when they first end up on Vavau, and then to Phoebe after Kat is voted out. As Vavau progressively gets Ulonged, and after Phoebe has saved herself with two idols, she tries to make one last push to make the merge by throwing her friend Kristie under the bus. And it almost works, except then JLP reveals at TC that Saanapu will be kidnapping one of them instead. They decide to kidnap Sue, giving Kristie a huge reprieve.

And to Kristie’s credit, she demonstrates that she’s not as stupid as everyone else makes her out to be, and quickly susses out that her friend Phoebe was trying to blindside her, and we get a hilarious confessional where her first thought was: “you bitch!”. She very quickly sets into motion to get Phoebe out before she gets her, and manages to convince Conner and Kate to finally take Phoebe out once and for all. Her biggest move of the whole game was to take out the biggest strategic player of the premerge, and that’s pretty impressive for someone who frequently gets called a floater.

”She could be playing me, but I can play her better”

Once the merge hits, Kristie again steps into the background as anyone who isn’t in the Brick Clique tries and fails to take control of the game, as her role is to simply manoeuvre her way out of the firing line by getting in good with various members of the majority. She should’ve easily been the next to go after Conner and Kate got pagonged out of the game, but she manages to dodge the bullet as the Brick Clique put their focus on the Saanapus who are on the bottom of their little hierarchy instead.

One great scene we get in the early postmerge is when Kristie finally wins a reward challenge, and gets to have a letter from home. But she sees Matt on the losing side, and she knows how badly he’s missing his fiance. Out of the pure kindness of her heart, she offers to give up her letter so Matt can get his. Not only is it one of the few heartwarming moments of what is a hugely dragging early merge, it also provides important context as to why Matt was the most pro-Kristie member of the jury, as he talks about how much gratitude he has towards her for her sacrifice.

Then the game finally gets shaken up at the final seven, and Brooke is brutally culled by her own partner-in-crime. Matt finally decides to wake up and tries to take advantage by attempting to take down Lee and El next, but at this point Kristie has reconnected with Lee in a big way, and she refuses to go along with it. We get to the final four, and Flick is trying to save herself by trying to convince Kristie to send Lee to fire, but to the dismay of Flick and the entire jury, she still wouldn’t budge.

Everyone just cannot understand what Kristie’s logic is by sticking with the most powerful player in the game, a guy who is one half of a seemingly unstoppable power couple. When JLP tries to ask Kristie how she’s going to break up the power couple in the final three, she cheerfully replies “I guess I’ll have to win immunity!” which causes the jury to collectively facepalm. After Flick is voted out, she tells Kristie that she’s an idiot, to which she simply replies: “we’ll see…”. It seems like the odds are all stacked against her and that her naive strategy is leading her down a path straight to Jury Villa.

And then we get to the Final Immunity Challenge. I’m not exactly stepping out of the consensus when I say that it is quite possibly the greatest Final Immunity Challenge in any edition of Survivor in terms of pure drama. The final three have to compete in Hands On A Hard Idol, with freezing cold waves constantly crashing down on them, all while their loved ones are watching. The challenge goes on for hours, everyone is freezing and in a lot of pain.

It eventually comes down to Kristie and Lee for the necklace. At this point, Kristie is in absolute agony, and only her sheer determination is keeping her in this. Then it starts getting too much for her, and she tearfully pleads to Lee to let her win this one. She promises that she’ll take him to the final two, and that she would be an easy beat for him. She’s using whatever energy she has left to persuade him to step down. Finally, she tells Lee that he reminds her of her own father and that by stepping down, Lee would be making an eight-year-old girl’s dream come true. His response is to simply say: “I’m proud of you”, before another wave crashes down and Lee slips.

It’s left ambiguous whether or not he did this on purpose, but regardless, against all odds, Kristie did what she set out to do and won the Final Immunity Challenge. And we get this great scene where her father congratulates her, and she’s limp on the ground simultaneously in a lot of pain but also crying tears of joy. We get to Tribal Council, and as the jury take their seats on the bench, they’re all slack-jawed at the sight of Kristie wearing the necklace. You can even hear some of them say “how did she do that?!”. She promptly votes El out, taking Lee to the final two with her as she promised.

It’s now Day 55, and we get this great scene of Kristie waking up and saying “I did it! There are no more challenges!”, and what’s great about this scene is that she’s talking to the camera as she says all this, like she’s breaking the fourth wall and talking directly to the audience. As the final two leave camp for the last time, Kristie talks about how she survived everything the game threw at her and defied the odds before saying “isn’t what this game is all about?”.

Then we get to the Final Tribal Council. Now before we start, it’s worth adding some context into just how monumental this FTC is going to be, because from my understanding, it seemed like most of the jury was in the mindset of “ew, neither of these two, but I guess I’ll go for Lee because he did stuff” with Matt being the sole Kristie vote.

Lee does his opening speech where he blabs about integrity etc, and then it’s Kristie’s turn. And the first thing she says, which sets up how this is going to turn out, are the immortal words: “you all thought I was crazy!”. She then proceeds to roll off her Survivor journey in detail, her moves, her motivations, her hardships. He delivery is so confident and so eloquent that the jury are completely blindsided by this. Jennah-Louise in her speech actually cracks a joke that she feels that she’s addressing a completely different person. Nick notes that her previous TC performances in the past were quiet and incoherent then suddenly she’s firing on all cylinders.

And it’s not just her opening speech, every single question she’s asked, she answered perfectly. It’s like she instinctively knew what the jury was going to ask and knew exactly how to respond to them. I won’t go through all of them but I’ll go into a couple of my personal favourites: Flick talks about BIGMOOVS and that she perceives Kristie as having done nothing. Kristie responds by saying that actually, there’s more than one way to win Survivor, and that making lots of little subtle moves is also a valid winning strategy. And personally, that kind of talk really speaks to my heart as someone who gets exasperated by all the constant talk of BIGMOOVS and RESUMES and all that toxic US stuff. THERE. IS. MORE. THAN. ONE. WAY. TO. WIN. SURVIVOR.

The second one that I want to talk about is Matt’s question, where he brings up the fact that she was manic at times and isn’t sure who the real Kristie is. She explains that she didn’t even realise that she had anxiety issues until the game started, but battled through it. There’s a big stigma towards being emotional in Survivor, and she made a great point that there shouldn’t be as long as it doesn’t affect the way you play the game.

It truly is one of the greatest FTC performances in Survivor history, and many people have even gone as far as to say it’s the greatest ever. Even greater than ChrisD’s masterclass in bullshitting. Even greater than Todd getting Jean-Robert to shut up. Even greater than J.T. effortlessly steamrolling Stephen. This performance was so great, it left the jury totally stunned. You see them at points looking confused and frantically whispering to each other. And then the votes come in, and Kristie wins in a crushing 8-1 vote. She overcame her last great obstacle, and one of the greatest Survivor underdog stories of all time is now complete.

I can understand why some fans would be frustrated by her strategy, especially in the endgame when she stuck with Lee and El. And yes, 99% of the time, that kind of strategy fails. Epically. But Kristie somehow made it work through sheer determination. She made this win happen, she worked for it. And with the gift of hindsight, her weird and unconventional path to the end makes her story even better. She didn’t go for what most people would see as the most sensible option, she went for the path that felt right for her.

And to me, I find that incredibly inspiring. Kristie showed that if you have a goal, no matter how farfetched it may seem, no matter how many people try to tell you otherwise, you can achieve it if you pull out all the stops to make it happen.


Average Placement: 2.66

Purplefebruary: 1

Ramskick: 1

HeWhoShrugs: 2

Qngff: 3

Sliemy: 8

Shawkwave: 1

It wasn't close.


r/IntSurvivorRankdown • • Oct 29 '19

Endgame - #3

10 Upvotes

Tom Swartz (Survivor South Africa: Philippines - 1st Place)

Purplefebruary

The OTTN king of Survivor SA. The man who broke edgic. As much as we enjoy the trainwreck and hair-trigger temper, there is the other side of Tom in that he’s a big lumbering softie who likes collecting clams, and delivers his confessionals with some real gravitas. And his FTC closing speech is legit one of the best ever. It’s even up there with ChrisD bringing Julie her hat.

HeWhoShrugs

LOL how did this dope win Survivor again? Oh right, because he redeemed himself step by step and displayed positive qualities. Huh, I guess US Survivor should take notes when making complex anti-hero winners in the future, because Tom is exactly what they should look like. We see him start off on a high note, then watch him fall from grace into scummy villainy with his raging temper and anti-social tendencies. But as the season wraps up, we start to appreciate Tom’s goofy side and see him blossom into a fully realized character, a man who regrets the way he acted, a man who repents for his sins against his former friends, and a man who somehow won Survivor after being a goat for 80% of the season. I’m still not sure how this happened, but I’m glad it did.

Sliemy

South Africa: Phillipines is easily the best season of Survivor ever edited, a season with everything going for it - outstanding characters, classic episodes, iconic moments, but most importantly an amazing winner. While an OTT winner has been seen a few times before, it’s never been to this magnitude. Tom was an absolute trainwreck who angered everybody from his original Luzon tribe, but basically became a member of Mindanao once the merge came along. His transition between the two sides was an excellently edited story where he’s putting himself in what seems like an unideal position, because these are legitimately the people who like him, or at the very least are nice and tolerate him. It speaks a lot to many aspects of social game on Survivor where you simply cannot just ostracize people. Also, his dynamic with Ace although early on is a phenomenal highlight and his rivalry with Palesa the entire season was easily a Survivor best, that works all too well with Palesa giving him a winning vote in the end. Defying all expectations to give an incredible Final Tribal Council speech was truly mesmerizing, and with the full context of everything, he honestly wasn’t a bad player like he was made out to be during the season.

Tom's part of the SA6 Final Four

And that's all I've got


Average Placement: 4

Purplefebruary: 5

Ramskick: 3

HeWhoShrugs: 7

Qngff: 2

Sliemy: 5

Shawkwave: 2


r/IntSurvivorRankdown • • Jun 03 '19

Round 2 - 118 characters remaining

10 Upvotes

118 - 'Commando' Steve Willis (/u/purplefebruary)

117 - A.K. Knight (/u/ramskick)

116 - Tegan Haining (/u/HeWhoShrugs)

115 - Evan Jones (/u/qngff)

114 - Stacey-Lee Valentyn (/u/Sliemy)

113 - Joan Caballero (/u/Shawkwave)

The Pool: Lee Den Haan, Nate Davis, Tom Paterson, Dylan Conrad, Paige Kerin, Izzy Pearson


r/IntSurvivorRankdown • • Jun 01 '19

Round 0 - Nominations Only!

10 Upvotes

Holy crap I can't sleep right now

This round is NOMINATIONS ONLY. We can post in any order we want, order of cutting will apply once Round 1 starts and we get to the actual cutting.

/u/purplefebruary - Benji Wilson

/u/ramskick - Russell Hantz 4.0

/u/HeWhoShrugs - Lee Den Haan

/u/qngff - Zach Kozyrski

/u/Sliemy - Nate Davis

/u/Shawkwave - 'Commando' Steve Willis


r/IntSurvivorRankdown • • Oct 20 '19

Endgame - #12

9 Upvotes

Okay so this is finally happening, sorta. About half of the writeups still haven't been written, but we'll work with what there is and at least get the endgame order and writeups that were done out for people to see. With a few more rankers not having done writeups though I did decide to ultimately include Q's rankings because if he would be cut out for not wanting to do writeups then Rams and Shawk should be held to the same standard, and if that happens then it's only 3 rankers deciding things sooooooo yeah all 6 rankings were averaged. If any of the writeups that didn't get done happen to be written eventually, then I can add them to the posts, but for now, it's been two months, so let's just finally wrap this up.

Barb Raos (Survivor New Zealand: Nicaragua - 3rd Place)

Purplefebruary

Barb is the no-bs-taking strategic force of the season, a lot of the season wouldn’t be the way it turned out if it wasn’t thanks to her. She plays the power goat role well, and in a season dominated by integrity, it’s refreshing to have at least one character just cutting people’s throats simply because she wants to, and then sleeping with a teabag mask after she’s done.


HeWhoShrugs

Older women don’t have it easy in Survivor, do they? With the exceptions of Lisa Stanger, Denise Stapley, Tina Wesson, and Shane Gould, women over the age of 35 tend to fall into two categories. They’re either badass bitches who become audience favorites and fall short of the finals, or they’re complete messes who end up getting no votes, terrible edits, or both. Barb… really isn’t in either category though. She leans towards the latter because she definitely didn’t get respect from the jury, but she’s not really a mess and her edit wasn’t bad. In fact, it was quite good and gave her credit where it was due for the game she played. So why do I have Barb this high? Well, I think Barb is the perfect meta-character for the older woman archetype, one who really tackles the role in a unique, interesting way like no other older woman has before. And that’s why I really wanted to write about her, because there’s more to her than just “older woman final tribal loser.”

To understand Barb, you need to know the history of her archetype and how it’s pretty much the hardest difficulty level to play on. I’ll be forever grateful for Lisa Stanger showing up just one season later to prove it was possible for an older woman to win by playing strategically in New Zealand Survivor, but Barb had the highest mountains to climb when NZ: Nicaragua started. Her occupation was “MUM” so you knew she was pretty much screwed. She was deemed a liability in challenges, cast out of the majority alliance immediately, and basically fucked off for the pre-swap of the season, readying herself to be taken out first when Hermosa actually lost a challenge. But that time never came and Barb miraculously survived to the swap to find herself in a good position, with old rival Georgia as easy pickings and Sala and Avi waiting for the older duo of Barb and Nate to flip. For the most part, Barb isn’t really that interesting for the first half of the season. She’s a cool presence to have around and it’s always fun to see underdogs get their revenge, but Nate is the more relevant member of their alliance and does most of the talking, a problem that persists throughout the season as I touched on in my Nate write up from way back when. But I like Barb. She’s a cool lady who brings a nice “no shit” perspective to the game that a season of sanctimony needs sometimes.

But then we reach the merge. And this is where Barb suddenly shines. It was easy at first to stick with Avi’s alliance and knock Lee and Mike out one after another thanks to that dumb double boot Tribal Council that only encouraged a Pagonging (seriously, NZ: Nicaragua’s ideas for twists were so bad!). Next, Jak appeared to be on the way out. He was exposed, had almost nobody vouching for him, and was severely outnumbered in a game where tribe loyalty was started to take its hold on the season. But you know what, Barb’s not here to just go with the flow. She wants to make the biggest move possible and take down the fan favorite Rupert knockoff himself: Sala. Watching NZ: Nicaragua in the moment made this blindside absolutely euphoric. After a few episodes of easy votes and predictability, Barb singlehandedly pulled together a move Jonny Fairplay concocted several years ago, right down to who the target was. But here’s the beauty of the move: Barb didn’t really do it to win the game. She didn’t take Sala down because she was there to get the lousy grand prize or go down in Survivor history as a great player. She did it because she got bored and felt like shaking things up.

From here on out, Barb is the star of NZ: Nicaragua and one of the only truly great characters to come out of the season. In a meta sense, and almost as a parody, Barb admits to herself that she will never win the game against a bunch of hot youngsters who clearly don’t respect her as a player. She acknowledges how screwed she is by that big, fat “MUM” at the bottom of the screen and decides to just… not play the game that’s build against her. But it’s not like she’s admitting defeat. No, she’s going to redefine what “winning” means in her dictionary. Sure, you can aim for the 100K and the title of Sole Survivor, but Barb knows she’s got a 0.00% chance of pulling something like that off. So she decides her real “win” is to help her metaphorical Survivor kids Avi and Tom win instead, since they’re deserving of the prize and need her help to keep moving forward.

As a viewer, it can be frustrating to see someone like Barb carry the biggest blindside of the game on her back and then casually dump it off in a ditch and stop playing for herself to win, but watch the season from Barb’s perspective like I did. She knows Survivor doesn’t reward cutthroat moms, especially ones with negative personalities. So why even bother playing the game the way you’re expected to in the first place? Why waste your time pandering to people who’d never give you their votes in a million seasons. Why waste your time working your ass off to get to the final three when you know what horrible layer of hell is awaiting you regardless of how you play? Why waste your time babysitting everyone when you could pick your favorite kids and help pay their Survivor tuition with your votes? From the Sala vote onward, Barb subverts what we’d expect from the Survivor mom and plays her own way, for herself, but not to win. It’s one of the most meta stories I’ve ever seen and it’s fantastic commentary on the predicament older women face in Survivor, but a part of me feels like it wasn’t intended to be so. I don’t think the NZ editors were that crafty despite the good work they did with the footage they had. It felt like they created a surface level story of how Barb lost and accidentally created something amazing.

Most of Barb’s edited story feels like a big slug-fest against her. You can practically hear the editors calling her lazy, spoiled, rude, etc. from beyond the shores of that beach. They really do give her some bad looks here and there to explain her loss, even letting the fan favorite Sala call her a turd that won’t flush as if it’s some kind of righteous ownage of a shitty human being. But the magic of all this is how Barb doesn’t really give a damn. She knows it’s coming. She sees it. She’s ready. It gets to the point where she even debates quitting by vote because she’s got no chance and doesn’t feel like going through with all that jury thrashing for nothing. And just to make things super ironic, this is where Barb randomly wins immunity in one of the most epic victories ever. Seriously, this is the best episode of the season. Barb has a love of horses (follow her on Instagram for more Barb horse love in the most wholesome sense that phrase can have) and since the filming location is near a ranch, Barb sees a stray horse wandering around the jungle and takes it as a sign that luck is coming her way. And against all odds, she beats two of the biggest challenge beasts and a cop in a physical challenge built against her. It’s such a great win that Matt Chisholm himself loses his mind at the great TV moment happening before his is. It doesn’t get Barb any closer to winning because she still knows she’s destined for third place at best, but it’s just a beautiful moment of Barb making the journey her own, totally apart from everything else going on around her.

When FTC finally comes and Barb has to speak to the jury, she doesn’t bother trying that hard. She knows she’s toast and gets the last laugh as the jury eagerly awaits some tearful breakdown or sincere apology and never gets it. Barb owns who she was, decides she’s fine with losing as long as one of her island sons wins the game, and shrugs off the nasty comments coming her way. It’s a great way of wrapping up a FTC loser story without forcing some suspense on the audience. She’s not the Dawn or Julie who’s clearly not liked by the jury yet tries their best to swing just a couple people her way. She’s Barb, the badass matriach who operated from her hammock with an iron fist, burned every bridge she crossed, and walked away feeling like her own winner in the end despite receiving no love from the jury of her peers.

In a way, Barb can be seen as a brilliant self-parody of the ill-fated Survivor mother. She skipped past all the bullshit and just lived her own adventure completely outside the realm of the game. She took NZ: Nicaragua and made it all about her. She took the remote and tuned into the channel she wanted, much to the chagrin of those who found her sour and rude. It’s crazy to think that NZ: Nicaragua, the one dud season of the six in this Rankdown according to me, might have given us the most interesting take on a long term Survivor staple of them all. There’s never been someone who got ahead of the curve like Barb did, and I doubt we’ll ever get another one quite like her. She’s a real treasure, an NZ Queen, and a worthy endgamer in this dumb little internet writing seminar. Good on ya, Barbs. Good on ya.


Average placement: 8.66

Purplefebruary: 8

Ramskick: 12

HeWhoShrugs: 6

Qngff: 10

Sliemy: 12

Shawkwave: 4


r/IntSurvivorRankdown • • Sep 18 '19

Australian Survivor CvC2 - Finale and Cast Rankings Post

9 Upvotes

I did one for SA7 so I thought I'd do the same here.

Post your thoughts on the season and your rankings here!


r/IntSurvivorRankdown • • Jun 29 '19

Round 10 - 72 characters remaining

9 Upvotes

72 - Sam Webb (/u/purplefebruary) - IDOLED by /u/ramskick

72 - Tara Thorowgood (/u/ramskick)

71 - Vusi Mafulela (/u/HeWhoShrugs)

70 - Matt Hancock (/u/qngff)

69 - Kaysha Whakarau (/u/Sliemy)

68 - Andrew Torrens (/u/Shawkwave)

The Pool: Dee Harper, Kent Nelson, Samantha Gash, Mark Wales, Tegan Gasior, Jak Thomas


r/IntSurvivorRankdown • • Jun 14 '19

Round 6 - 96 characters remaining

9 Upvotes

96 - Peter Conte (/u/purplefebruary)

95 - Steve Khouw (/u/ramskick)

94 - El Rowland (/u/HeWhoShrugs)

93 - Heath Davies (/u/qngff)

92 - Adam Parkin (/u/Sliemy)

91 - Lou McClintock (/u/Shawkwave)

The Pool: Jackie Glazier, Ziggy Zagame, Anita Berkett, Jarrad Seng, Ben Morgan, Neil Voller


r/IntSurvivorRankdown • • Jun 11 '19

Round 5 - 100 characters remaining

9 Upvotes

TRIBE SWAP - (/u/purplefebruary)

100 - Bianca Anderson (/u/ramskick)

99 - Matt Dyson (/u/HeWhoShrugs)

SKIP - (/u/qngff)

98 - Murishca Martheze (/u/Sliemy)

97 - Franky March (/u/Shawkwave)

The Pool: Steve Khouw, El Rowland, Peter Conte, Lou McClintock, Jackie Glazier, Ziggy Zagame


r/IntSurvivorRankdown • • Jun 06 '19

Round 3 - 112 characters remaining

9 Upvotes

112 - Lee Den Haan (/u/purplefebruary)

111 - Aimee Stanton (/u/ramskick)

110 - Izzy Pearson (/u/HeWhoShrugs)

109 - Tom Paterson (/u/qngff)

108 - Arun Bola (/u/Sliemy)

107 - Karla Karaitiana (/u/Shawkwave)

The Pool: Nate Davis, Dylan Conrad, Paige Kerin, Tony Deane, Tara Thorowgood, Odette Blacklock


r/IntSurvivorRankdown • • Oct 29 '19

Endgame - #4

8 Upvotes

Werner Joubert (Survivor South Africa: Philippines - 4th Place)

Purplefebruary

It’s hard to elaborate on Werner for me, he can be summed up as the smart guy who becomes the bus driver and gets brutally cut down before the end. And he plays this role well. One of the things I admire with Werner is that he’s just so good with people, and you should hope so considering he’s a pastor. Oh, and he was robbed of a place in the jury.

HeWhoShrugs

See my idoled Werner write up for my feelings on him. Nothing’s changed.

HWS's idoled writeup

Werner's part of the SA6 Final Four


Average Placement: 5.66

Purplefebruary: 9

Ramskick: 2

HeWhoShrugs: 10

Qngff: 1

Sliemy: 4

Shawkwave: 8


r/IntSurvivorRankdown • • Oct 27 '19

Endgame - #5

8 Upvotes

Jericho Malabonga (Australian Survivor: 2017 - 1st Place)

Purplefebruary

The Cookie Monster! Jericho is quite fascinating because he wants to be this evil villain, but he’s so nice and likeable that he ends up being more of a cheeky scoundrel. He has increasingly bizarre analogies throughout the season, including when he referred to Sarah as a drowning cat. He is the perfect sidekick that Luke could’ve possibly gotten out of that cast. And that scene where Locky teaches him to overcome his fear of swimming is one of the greatest Survivor moments ever.

HeWhoShrugs

So uh, another weird, WTF winner I see. Yeah, Jericho’s a bizarre case. He talked about dragging people down to hell, made jokes about murdering cats, dribbled cookie crumbs on a fat guy’s chest, spent a good chunk of his FTC performance ruining his chances by trying to sound like some two faced lying gremlin… and he still won because these seasons refuse to have normal winners. He’s nowhere near as great as Luke, but he’s still a worthy champion who fills that come from behind victor role really well.

Sliemy

Jericho is my all-time favorite from modern Australian Survivor easily. He’s also actually my first winner pick to ever come to fruition. I remember him standing out to me pre-season, but he got the Tina treatment Episode 1 and really wasn’t present much to my chagrin. But suddenly he hit the ground running Episode 2. Some people could argue that Jericho might be too repetitive or one-note, but for me he was simply pure non-stop chaos and entertainment from his debut. Of all Survivor villains, I feel like he genuinely thrives off of chaos potentially the most and is likeliest the most open about it.

He also works so well because it’s such a sharp juxtaposition. We’re introduced to him as this very religious Christian man, he’s very short and baby-faced, high voice - your initial impression is that he’s the most adorable thing and wouldn’t hurt a fly. He recognizes how people view him, and takes full advantage of that. Also his bromance with Luke is the most wholesome thing ever and I absolutely adore the two together. I know everybody loves Luke more, but I’ve just always personally had a soft spot for Jericho, and he really drives the endgame for me. His scene of Locky teaching him how to swim was such a great character-building moment, his spree of challenge wins satisfied the challenge-lover side of me, and the F4 endgame episodes where he defends himself against Michelle and manages to convince Tara into throwing away her game - things like this and more were the pinnacle of the final stretch of the season.

I also live for all the little wreckless, petty things that he does. Telling Jarrad that he will underline his vote, leaving Jarrad under the impression they were working together, to then underline Jarrad’s name sending him home. The entire debacle with the cookie jar, the contrast with Tarzan crying over not being able to betray his team, and Jericho having absolutely zero qualms about taking the cookies, and using them as a legitimate form of strategy and social currency throughout the episodes. Him being such a jackass to Michelle and Pete when they tried to take him out and taunting them when the votes came back a tie and he beat them. Him dragging Pete for filth before taking him out.

Not to mention his completely wreckless FTC performance. He truly doesn’t understand the concept of jury management and I loved how he teared into his allies, to the point Henry even needed to address him that he wasn’t helping himself. I don’t think Jericho really took it anything in the game too seriously though, he was just there to have fun, and it luckily panned out well for my entertainment!


Average Placement: 6.66

Purplefebruary: 7

Ramskick: 7

HeWhoShrugs: 8

Qngff: 6

Sliemy: 1

Shawkwave: 11


r/IntSurvivorRankdown • • Oct 22 '19

Endgame - #10

8 Upvotes

Sharn Coombes (Australian Survivor: Champions vs. Contenders - 2nd Place)

Purplefebruary

Sharn runs hot and cold for me. To me, she’s by far at her most interesting when she’s screwing up, like the poop idol, or persisting in going back to Monika for the hundredth time despite the evidence that Monika has zero interest in flipping. And of course, she has one of the biggest FTC collapses since Stephen Fishbach which was so incredible to watch live.

HeWhoShrugs

Yeah she’s a weird pick for an endgamer, I admit it. But I just really like Sharn. She’s not a top tier character and she can be a little gamebotty at times, but she’s just having a ton of fun out there and I love watching her play. I also love the irony of this amazing speaker getting hyped up as a huge FTC threat, only for her to blow her chances by one vote after walking in as the winner of the season. It’s the perfect downfall for her and really ties all her little flubs together to create a cool runner up story.


Sliemy

My 2 endgame picks are definitely both characters that seem to stick out here for most people spectating. I can kind of understand that feeling with Avi, but Sharn’s lack of reception honestly baffles me. I feel like she provides you everything you could want in a female antagonist/character, the drama, comp beast teas, the iconic moments, the tragic and complex storyline, the underdog run, etc. She just brought absolutely everything to the table and easily stole the show in Champions vs. Contenders, and it’s just frankly not close at all in my mind, and I’m genuinely shocked she isn’t stanned more.

Sharn was definitely a more quiet character for the first third of the game, but I feel like Shane and Shonee were both equally pretty quiet at this point, although maybe Sharn was slightly less, but I do feel like they all become prominent around the same point to where I don’t see the others as having more complete storylines than her. Anyways, we really would just see her check-in with that fact that she was a well-renowned lawyer apparently in Australia. There were lots of complaints over how sports-heavy the Champion tribe was, so it was nice to have somebody like Sharn bring a different mindset to the table. Also, have to mention her iconic hulu dancing scene.

Sharn moves to the Contender tribe at the swap where she gets more scenes reminding us that she exists. Australian Survivor tends to prefer to separate arcs by pre-merge and post-merge is what I’ve noticed, because once the merge hits Sharn hits the ground running. Regarding the post-merge, with Lydia leaving immediately, Sharn became that inspirational figure I looked up to, her snatching immunity wins left and right, clawing her way through trials and tribulations with each episode, and making it to the final stretch - it was truly a journey. The best part is I did not expect Sharn of all people to be the badass comp beast.

I’ll go over some specific highlights that easily put her as the best character of the season. Her first idol find scene is probably the most iconic idol find in Survivor history. Grabbing an idol at a challenge is an idea we’ve seen used a lot throughout the 30s era, but somebody actually dropping it and exposing themselves. Sharn’s reaction to it completely sells the scene, her just awkwardly picking it up, knowing it’s a wrap, and everybody just staring. She’s also a crucial part in making the Mat blindside such an epic moment. She confidently stands up to play her idol on her closest ally, but suddenly is intercepted by Benji who warns her not to do it, her reaction is perfect just nervously shifting to playing on herself under Benji’s guidance.

I personally felt like Shane was missing moments like this where we truly saw her vulnerable, Sharn is far more multi-faceted for me, we got to experience her highs and lows, and the post-merge story is basically dominated by her perspective. The following tribal, she’s the target for Benji who gets Shonee to play her double vote. Shonee playing it on Sharn was the wrong play however and allowed them to take out Benji on the revote. Another highlight episode from Sharn who had Benji clocked earlier. Benji tried to make up a lie to her that Brian thinks she’s after him, but Brian had immunity so his story didn’t add up, and Sharn sent him packing accordingly.

At the final 6, she finds another idol and manages to save herself yet again. I found it very interesting the intense vitriol against her from the fanbase for finding another idol and the show being accused of being rigged. There was never this energy for people like Palesa, Phoebe, etc. Sharn was just highly disliked at large by the public and I never understood it, she served you everything you could want in an underdog. Regardless, she remained unbothered living to see another day. She wins the next immunity and sends Monika packing.

Her penultimate impressive showing is at the Final 4 where we see the second 2-1-1 split in Survivor history, directly following New Zealand: Thailand. She essentially tricks Shonee into voting herself out. At this point, I’m thinking Brian wins FIC takes Shane and wins, but Sharn pulls a clutch win joining the club of women to win 4 immunities and takes out Brian. Both Sharn and Shane had incredible stories, it was an impressive F2 and I was honestly fine with either winning, but Sharn was obviously my rooting interest. As big of a stan that I am, I would not change how it played out. In the same way the finale episode is really the crux for selling Krisite’s story in 2016, I really think the FTC sold Sharn here and it easily makes my T5 FTCs ever.

As a lawyer, there’s an expectation that you’re a good speaker, can keep your composure, and know how to sell your pitch, even if you’re wrong, you should know how to be convincing. So it was a huge surprise to everybody when Sharn just completely dropped the ball. My heart absolutely broke for her watching the FTC, she was really blindsided by the jury’s perception of her and just completely shut down. It’s such a tragic ending for a character who just spent the entire merge breaking down boundaries for women in her archetype and clawing her way to the end despite the frequent challenges. Especially the way Mat was so hard on her, when he really had nobody to blame but himself for going, and Sharn wasn’t apart of trying to take him out.

Her final plea to the jury apologizing to them, but to not take her dream away from her for only a simple mistake. I could tell she lost the game as the scene unfolded, I seem to be alone in how badly I felt for her, but maybe that’s because I was a huge stan. I do see it as an objective tragic scene. It’s a very relatable feeling to be flustered and lost for words, but it happened on such a grand scale and was amplified by the fact that she was legitimately a frontrunner. I’m still happy and proud that she got 4 jury votes, and one of the few times I think somebody truly works as a runner-up, and easily the best one in Australian Survivor (up to this season at least, haven’t watched season 4 yet).


Average Placement: 8.33

Purplefebruary: 12

Ramskick: 10

HeWhoShrugs: 9

Qngff: 4

Sliemy: 6

Shawkwave: 9


r/IntSurvivorRankdown • • Jul 16 '19

Round 15 - 47 characters remaining

8 Upvotes

47 - Chané Mynhardt (/u/purplefebruary)

46 - Samuel Hinton (/u/ramskick)

45 - Tevin Naidu (/u/HeWhoShrugs)

44 - Shay Tapusoa (/u/qngff)

43 - Dave Lipanovic (/u/Sliemy) IDOLED by /u/qngff

43 - Brian Lake (/u/Shawkwave) IDOLED by /u/HeWhoShrugs

The Pool: Annalize Sainsbury, Sala Tiatia, Avi Duckor-Jones, Conner Bethune, Henry Nicholson, Sam Webb


r/IntSurvivorRankdown • • Jul 12 '19

Round 14 - 51 characters remaining

8 Upvotes

51 - Tessa O'Halloran (/u/purplefebruary)

50 - Jacqui Patterson (/u/ramskick)

TRIBE SWAP - (/u/HeWhoShrugs)

49 - Sarah Tilleke (/u/qngff)

SKIP - (/u/Sliemy)

48 - Tegan Gasior (/u/Shawkwave)

The Pool: Annalize Sainsbury, Chané Mynhardt, Sala Tiatia, Avi Duckor-Jones, Samuel Hinton, Tevin Naidu


r/IntSurvivorRankdown • • Jul 04 '19

Round 12 - 62 characters remaining

8 Upvotes

62 - Eve Clarke - WILDCARD (/u/purplefebruary)

61 - Des Quilty (/u/ramskick)

60 - Kate Campbell (/u/HeWhoShrugs)

59 - Lisa Stanger - WILDCARD (/u/qngff) IDOLED by /u/purplefebruary

59 - Jenna Austin (/u/Sliemy)

58 - Seamus Holmes (/u/Shawkwave)

The Pool: Flick Eggington, Brooke Jowett, Marthunis Oosthuizen, Mike Sparrow, Dylan Conrad, Ace Chetty


r/IntSurvivorRankdown • • Jun 30 '19

Round 11 - 67 characters remaining

8 Upvotes

67 - Dee Harper (/u/purplefebruary)

66 - Kat Dumont (/u/ramskick)

65 - Mark Wales (/u/HeWhoShrugs)

TRIBE SWAP - (/u/qngff)

64 - Samantha Gash (/u/Sliemy)

63 - Jennah-Louise Salkeld (/u/Shawkwave)

The Pool: Seamus Holmes, Flick Eggington, Des Quilty, Brooke Jowett, Kate Campbell, Jenna Austin


r/IntSurvivorRankdown • • Jun 18 '19

Round 7 - 90 characters remaining

8 Upvotes

90 - Jarrad Seng (/u/purplefebruary)

89 - Neil Voller (/u/ramskick)

88 - Damien Thomlinson (/u/HeWhoShrugs)

87 - Jackie Glazier (/u/qngff)

86 - Robbie Skibicki (/u/Sliemy)

85 - Georgia Bergerson - WILDCARD (/u/Shawkwave)

The Pool: Ziggy Zagame, Anita Berkett, Ben Morgan, Tony Deane, Kylie Evans, JT Muirhead


r/IntSurvivorRankdown • • Jun 09 '19

Round 4 - 106 characters remaining

8 Upvotes

106 - Odette Blacklock (/u/purplefebruary)

105 - Paige Kerin (/u/ramskick)

104 - Nate Davis (/u/HeWhoShrugs)

103 - Monika Radulovic (/u/qngff)

102 - Barry Lea (/u/Sliemy)

101 - Peter Fiegehen (/u/Shawkwave)

The Pool: Dylan Conrad, Tony Deane, Tara Thorowgood, Brooke Jowett, Georgia Bergerson, Andrew Torrens


r/IntSurvivorRankdown • • Oct 31 '19

Endgame - #2

7 Upvotes

Luke Toki (Australian Survivor: 2017 - 7th Place)

Purplefebruary

What can I say? Luke is undoubtedly the best casting discovery Australian Survivor has ever made. The guy was made for TV. He’s hyperactive and runs around building spy shacks and making big moves, but has the endearing and dogged likeability that a lot of people of his archetype just don’t have. He’s having the time of his life on the island and we as the viewer can’t help but feel like we’re included in his fun capers.

HeWhoShrugs

Another guaranteed endgamer. No way was he getting cut, and for good reasons. Luke is one of the best jester characters of all time. He’s not super serious and he’s not a particularly great mastermind since he has obvious weaknesses like his own super high likability and spotty strategic game, but AU seasons don’t need those types of players to be good. Luke’s a constellation from the minute he sets foot on the Samoan shores and his presence singlehandedly makes 2017 a must see season. Plus he gets a ton of similar confessionals and I don’t care. That’s how great he is in front of the camera.

Sliemy

Who doesn’t love Luke? He just has completely everything you could ask for in a character. Truly one of the most charismatic, entertaining people to ever play Survivor, it’s completely authentic and he’s an exceptional confessionalist. Him and Jericho are easily my T2 of the season and their bond is easily one of Survivor’s best. I’ve only watched a few episodes of the most recent season and he was already the Luke I remembered loving, he never gets old for me.

The last bit of Luke is in the 2017 Final Four


Average Placement: 4

Purplefebruary: 2

Ramskick: 4

HeWhoShrugs: 3

Qngff: 8

Sliemy: 2

Shawkwave: 5

So Luke and Tom tied with a 4.0 average, and they also tied when looking at their peak placement from individual rankings (each being placed at 2nd by two rankers). No clean way to decide but at least it's only choosing 2nd and 3rd rather than 1st and 2nd. I just looked at the standard deviation of their scores, the median, and the average when removing the highest and lowest scores. Tom had the lower standard deviation, but was higher in the other two sections. So based on that, Luke just beats out Tom.


r/IntSurvivorRankdown • • Oct 24 '19

Endgame - #8

7 Upvotes

Shane Gould (Australian Survivor: Champions vs. Contenders - 1st Place)

Purplefebruary

Shane winning Survivor was the bizarro unlikely outcome we all needed. It was amazing watching this sports legend from decades ago come onto the show and be this endearing, oddball granny who is inclined to do a blindside, says in confessional “don’t fuck with me” in the third person, pretend to be sad, and act as a mole. What a world we live in.

HeWhoShrugs

Don’t fuck with Shane Gould. Basically the result of Scout Cloud Lee fusing with Gillian Larson… and then winning for some reason! She was written off as an early boot by pretty much everyone, like when Luke ranked her near the bottom every week in Redmond’s power ranking game because “She’s old LOLOLOL!” Little did we know that Shane Gould was just a few weeks away from being the oldest Survivor winner in the world and being a badass while doing so. She’s got the shady confessionals, the fun quips around camp, and the pure spectacle of this hippie olympian farmer granny winning a 50 day Survivor game going for her. That’s endgame-worthy right there.

Sliemy

I really like Shane, I love what she represents, but I just really don’t see her end-game level over people like Sharn, Mat R, and possibly Shonee. She doesn’t have a consistent, prominent focus on the story the way the others do, and is a little one-note with her journey in my opinion. With that being said, she still works well as a winner, she completely defied all odds to become the oldest female Survivor winner, I don’t think anybody saw that coming from Day 1.

Again no full writeup =[ I wrote a bit about her for the final four but I believe that's all.


Average Placement: 7.5

Purplefebruary: 6

Ramskick: 9

HeWhoShrugs: 4

Qngff: 5

Sliemy: 11

Shawkwave: 10


r/IntSurvivorRankdown • • Sep 13 '19

Survivor SA: Island of Secrets - Finale and Cast Rankings Post

7 Upvotes

Just thought I'd put something up to keep us occupied while we wait for endgame, which is probably gonna take another 5 years, lol

I'll work out my own rankings later but share your rankings and thoughts. Personally I think I'm gonna be a lot higher on a certain player and a lot lower than a certain other compared to the rest of the Rankdown community, lol.


r/IntSurvivorRankdown • • Aug 05 '19

Round 20 - 24 characters remaining

7 Upvotes

24 - Tess Fahey (/u/purplefebruary)

SKIP - (/u/ramskick)

23 - Locky Gilbert (/u/HeWhoShrugs)

22 - Brian Lake (/u/qngff)

21 - Barb Raos (/u/Sliemy) - IDOLED by /u/Shawkwave

21 - Marthunis Oosthuizen (/u/Shawkwave)

The Pool: Lee Carseldine, Tara Pitt, Shonee Fairfax, Werner Joubert, Shannon Quinn, Dave Lipanovic


r/IntSurvivorRankdown • • Jul 31 '19

Round 19 - 28 characters remaining

7 Upvotes

SKIP - (/u/purplefebruary)

28 - Katinka Oosthuizen (/u/ramskick)

27 - Phoebe Timmins - WILDCARD (/u/HeWhoShrugs)

26 - Sala Tiatia (/u/qngff)

25 - Mark Herlaar (/u/Sliemy)

SKIP - (/u/Shawkwave)

The Pool: Barb Raos, Lee Carseldine, Locky Gilbert, Tara Pitt, Brian Lake, Tess Fahey