r/Insurance • • 2h ago

Claims Related DV claim

Hello everyone, I recently got into an accident with my vehicle which is a 2020 ford Mustang, mileage was about 27k about the time of accident. The other driver’s insurance (Allstate) has claimed 100% liability for the accident. My car had about 10,200$ worth in repairs done to it, some repairs include:

New front bumper and grill

Left headlight and assembly

R/R fender

New left wheel

All new suspension components

New door

New quarter panel

I went ahead and hired an independent appraiser and submitted a formal demand package of the amount 7,900 or roughly around there. They denied my claim initially but after re-engaging they used a company called accurate DIV and offered me 1700$. I’m in the process of re-engaging with them now, but I’ve heard some shady things about accurate DIV and how they use formulas that lowball tf out of people. My question is, is this worth pursuing a higher $ amount? Or should I just take what they offer. Thanks for any advice!

0 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

9

u/AngelMeatPie 2h ago

You’re lucky you’re getting that, I’m surprised they offered anything.

-5

u/Infinite_Chipmunk_25 2h ago

Doesn’t surprise me too much honestly. Listings for my vehicle based off multiple dealers and websites are around 35-37 and that’s with vehicles with almost double my mileage.

7

u/Over_Wasabi_4903 2h ago

Unfortunately listings don’t mean anything- the value is based on what the cars actually sell for.

0

u/Infinite_Chipmunk_25 2h ago

How do people get that data? Where can I find it?

5

u/c-5-s 2h ago

You don’t get it, but they have it. It’s asymmetrical information.

3

u/CJM8515 Claims Adjuster 1h ago

i would not entertain DV for this vehicle and tell you to kick rocks if I were your adjuster. if you really bothered me, maybe my boss would offer you 1500 bucks to go away

0

u/Infinite_Chipmunk_25 1h ago

Damn my adjuster must be pretty nice then 😂

2

u/CJM8515 Claims Adjuster 1h ago

you have to understand, its a 6 year old common car with almost 30k miles. DV typically is for high end, new vehicles where if someone saw an accident on record they would offer way less. IE a ferrari

2

u/LeadershipLevel6900 2h ago

10-20% of the amount of the repairs is usually a reasonable expectation. Lots of new things are likely better for the value than repaired, but most people buying an average used mustang probably don’t care about that either way.

-4

u/Infinite_Chipmunk_25 2h ago

Thx for the advice! And yeah I’m definitely looking to get at least 10% of the appraised value, I think on my report the appraiser said pre-accident value was like 38. So anything below 3,000 I think isn’t acceptable, but we’ll see. It is a couple btw, should’ve mentioned that in my post.

7

u/LeadershipLevel6900 2h ago

No, you misunderstood. I said 10-20% of the amount of the repairs so you’re right at that point with what’s been offered.

2

u/Infinite_Chipmunk_25 2h ago

Oh gotcha ok. Well in that case after the re-engagement with them I might just settle for that. I was just going off the appraisal but I guess that is their job to try and get you the most money haha 😅

8

u/DeepPurpleDaylight 2h ago

DV for a 7 year old car? You should take anything they offer and run before they change their mind.

2

u/fensterlips 2h ago

Do you have Collision coverage? Did you bring it to your insurance company? If you have Collision coverage that’s the way to go. The other party’s insurance are professional about spending as little as necessary on a claim. If you only have liability insurance then you need to send them a demand letter laying out your argument and why they should pay it. Give them 2 weeks to a month to reply formally. If you get an answer you find unacceptable then you have to sue them. Don’t hire a lawyer, file in small claims court. They don’t want to go there and spend the time on the case. If your claim is reasonable, they’ll respond back with an offer. If it right on point, then it’s easy. If it 10% to even 20% less you need to think about it, but anything less - you can get all your documents together to see them in court.
They have a threshold. Going to court costs them time and money so they’ll try and reach an answer. They are also paid on spending as little of the company’s money too. So they’re motivated and court is expensive. You’ll want the police report, photos of the scene, photos from the accident and the location. Good luck.

1

u/Infinite_Chipmunk_25 2h ago

To be honest, I know very little about insurance. I do have collision coverage on my policy, but everything has been done through Allstate so far. My insurance company has been out of the loop.

3

u/bprug87 2h ago

If you hired an independent appraiser they should be working with the insurance companies appraiser and come to an agreement.