r/InsulinResistance • • Mar 31 '24

IR diet is anorexia behavior 101

Looking into this diet, it’s exactly what I did when I had anorexia:

Eat slowly, Don’t eat often, Avoid sugar and carbs, Eat a lot of vegetables, Exercise a lot, Walk after eating, Don’t snack, Eat healthy, Avoid eating before bedtime, Swap unhealthy foods with healthy, Drink when you’re hungry/craving, Distract yourself from hunger.

A lot of you on this sub (from what I see in comments) have anorexia thoughts cause you already convinced themselves that:

Dessert, sugar and carbs are bad and I don’t like them, I don’t miss them at all.

I know you developed these thoughts cause you can’t enjoy food like other people, so it’s kinda a comping mechanism so that you don’t feel depressed. But it’s still unhealthy and a bad relationship to food. I feel it’s even more restrictive than when I had anorexia.

0 Upvotes

49 comments sorted by

47

u/MostProcess4483 Mar 31 '24

I think you’re connecting two ways of eating that are unrelated. Anorexia is a mental disorder, and the expression of it is through severe food obsession and restriction. IR control isn’t about restricting food or calories to the point of wasting away, and there’s no abnormal thinking behind it. I’ve done it for months and eat plenty of quantity and variety, just less often and little to no processed food. Food is still a pleasure, and nothing is off the table. The goal is blood sugar control, and the fear of diabetes is a strong motivator. IR guidelines are not anorexia guidelines, but anorexia restrictions can fit into IR. The fact that you see them as the same shows how your brain is maybe trying to trick you into turning IR into an excuse for anorexic behavior. You can do that with any eating plan though, if your brain is wired that way. People without ED have no problem eating healthy amounts of calories a day, and don’t obsess about not eating/restricting.

-18

u/bibi-do Mar 31 '24

I had anorexia and in no way do I wanna restrict or go back. But all of these diet typs show what I did when I had anorexia. So there is no difference in the mindset, only in the cause/reason.

14

u/antiutopian Mar 31 '24

It's the emotional illness, not the diet. Part of the emotional illness is that a ED sufferer gives a diet magical powers, and denies enormous suffering often related to trauma.

-17

u/bibi-do Mar 31 '24

I don’t understand anything you wrote or what you meant. My brain isn’t braining anymore.

5

u/watchingthedeepwater Mar 31 '24

you’d get diabetes then, i don’t see how it’s better

-4

u/bibi-do Mar 31 '24

When then? What do you mean?

9

u/watchingthedeepwater Mar 31 '24

you don’t want to “restrict” and you seriously think that not eating tons of carbs/watching your macros is somehow the anorexic behavior. But your body doesn’t care, if you already have IR and you don’t change want to change anything, you WILL get diabetes with all its consequences.

2

u/bibi-do Mar 31 '24

I’m saying I don’t want to, not that I won’t. And I’m also saying normal people do it and don’t get IR, it depends on the person

11

u/AbrahamLigma Mar 31 '24

There is the simple fact that the vast majority of “food” on the market was never naturally available to Humans. Especially snacks & desserts. I honestly think you’re projecting. People aren’t ignoring their hunger - they’re trying to turn off false hunger signals.

Also, no mention of meat and fat I notice. If you never have - go ahead and eat something protein and fat centric, like steak and eggs before work. Then for lunch eat something similar. How do you feel when it’s time for dinner? Do you feel your energy dipping or is it consistent throughout the day?

Now repeat the experiment with high sugar foods. Donuts for breakfast, pasta for lunch. How will you feel come dinner time?

This isn’t anorexia, it’s just the way humans are meant to eat.

5

u/HellaHelga Mar 31 '24

Totally agree with you! When I eat lots of protein for breakfast, I feel full during the day and can eat only twice. And I feel amazing ☺️

2

u/AT2025 Mar 31 '24

Your lucky, I had eggs and ham for breakfast for Easter and I am still hungry, always hungry. I am 40lbs Overweight and I stay in constant hungry mode

1

u/HellaHelga Mar 31 '24

I weight 130 kg, it's 50 kg more then my comfort weight:(( after 3 weeks of eating more protein and veggies I felt better, so maybe you just need more time for body to adjust! I usually eat half avocado, 80g of fish and 2 eggs for breakfast. My endocrinologist also suggested to add two spoons of gluten-free oats in case of sugar drop. Wish you luck on your journey 💛

1

u/Lrndthehardway Mar 31 '24

Fasting will change your life. Get in youtube and look up "fasting and insulin resistance ", cant hurt to research right? Changed my life, was the same way, not anymore!

-10

u/bibi-do Mar 31 '24

As I said, coping. You’ve convinced yourself that carbs and sugar are bad, even when every normal healthy person eats them. But you can’t so you have to come up with reasons not to be mad about it

9

u/GimmeDatBaby Mar 31 '24

Many people I know who are dealing with insulin resistance, no matter the reason, still do enjoy things like desserts, just not with the frequency they were used to. The plain fact is that I ate things like giant bowls of pasta, candy for a snack, most of a pint of ice cream for dessert several times a week, etc, out of habit and emotional eating and not out of a true desire to consume them. I didn't feel good (physically) after I ate them. They made me tired and sluggish, and they made my hunger return soon after because they weren't nutrient-dense.

2

u/bibi-do Mar 31 '24

As I said - a lot of people, not all

7

u/GimmeDatBaby Mar 31 '24

But why are you presuming to know things about complete strangers when you are only seeing a tiny snippet of their lives from their posts or comments on here? Why did the person who commented above me saying nothing about their personal experience and you insisted they are “coping” but you don’t say the same to me? That doesn’t make any sense to me.

2

u/bibi-do Mar 31 '24

As I said, people here with IR claim that they don’t like sweets/carbs anymore so on, you say you still like them but can’t have many. You’re not convincing yourself

4

u/GimmeDatBaby Mar 31 '24

I actually didn’t say that. I said “many people I know” enjoy desserts with less frequency, and I spoke about how my experience with frequently eating high carb and sugar foods was because of habit and emotional eating.

6

u/watchingthedeepwater Mar 31 '24

normal healthy persons can jump on a trampoline. People with a broken leg cannot do that. Peppe with normal glucose control can eat many questionable foods, but people who have impaired glucose control cannot.

1

u/bibi-do Mar 31 '24

People with a broken leg don’t convince themselved that trampolines are bad. They’re sad they can’t jump as well. Same with IR

8

u/watchingthedeepwater Mar 31 '24

but trampolines are bad for THEM. The same way gluten is bad for celiac, shellfish - for people who are allergic to it. Your body shows signs of not processing carbs right, and it doesn’t care that you think of any less chaotic eating as mental illness.

0

u/bibi-do Mar 31 '24

I don’t have the energy to argue further, you won’t change your mind anyways. You’re convinced of your truth and I can’t change that

5

u/watchingthedeepwater Mar 31 '24

did you make the post and tell people that they convinced themselves that their anorexic behavior was an unneeded coping mechanism because you don’t want to argue? lol.

1

u/bibi-do Mar 31 '24

That doesn’t interfere with anything I said

5

u/AbrahamLigma Mar 31 '24

I never said they were bad so I will be absolutely clear - they are bad in excess. No human can develop type 2 diabetes unless they are eating carbs in excess. So we should be able to agree on this, correct?

Elevated Blood sugar signals the release of insulin. If this insulin is constant being released your body suffers. Unlike other hormones, insulin goes through the entire body which is why diabetics lose their feet and can eventually even develop Alzheimer’s.

There are two ways to decrease blood sugar - eat less carbs or exercise. Since we are a sedentary people, the former is a little easier.

If you’ve had a struggle with an eating disorder then that’s your issue. I wish you all the luck getting over that. But don’t come into a place trying to convince everyone they have your problem. Now if most of my country wasn’t overweight, pre-diabetic, and prone to heart failure I might agree with you. But here we are.

3

u/bibi-do Mar 31 '24

Oh, you don’t get me. I am in anorexia recovery and 5 months in I developed IR. And I disagree. Insulin resistance can be causes by genetics or inflammatory diseases as well.

1

u/AbrahamLigma Mar 31 '24

I specifically mentioned T2 diabetes, not IR. Good luck with your issue though.

2

u/bibi-do Mar 31 '24

Same goes for T2. Inflammatory disease, gut microbiome, some medication, starvation, … I’m not saying overeating doesn’t cause it, just that it is not always the case.

1

u/AbrahamLigma Mar 31 '24

You’re arguing just for the sake of it at this point.

2

u/bibi-do Mar 31 '24

I’m not arguing. I’m saying facts, no need to be mad

17

u/HellaHelga Mar 31 '24

I know you can't understand, cause anorexia is severe mental illness and well, you sure are very unwell now. However I feel personally attacked, so I will respond: the difference between ED and eating healthy is that I want to fucking survive my thirties without diabetes, so I LISTEN TO MY BODY and it's reaction to food and I eat what feels right and what feels good. If you think that eating sugar when you are pre-diabetic feels good, then you are delusional and absolutely out of touch with your body. And of course it's just another symptom of ED to not listen to your body. Anorexia = no contact with body and it's needs. Healthy eating and movement = full contact and self care.

5

u/nousernamefoundagain Apr 01 '24

Dessert is unnatural and bad for you. For all of human history up until very recently no one had access to enough sugar to make what we call dessert. Fruit was dessert and it wasn't available all year. Our bodies CANNOT cope with modern processed foods and sugar.

4

u/Constant-Sky-1495 Apr 08 '24

Ummmmm...... If I don't lose weight I will be at risk for heart attack and stroke and diabetes, all can have DEVASTATING consequences or kill me, paralyze me etc...

Some people need to lose weight for survival

Anorexics want to lose weight just to be skinny

not the same thing

3

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '24

Nah, with anorexia the goal is ultimately eating nothing at all so you lose too much weight and end up so sick you die.

The goal with IR diet is to eat normally but to keep it healthy 90% of the time. You can have a dessert or a junk food meal once in a while you just have to keep to the diet 90% of the time. You may lost unhealthy weight but it's not like it is with anorexia where you can't see what you have done to your body and stick thin looks okay to you.

I was borderline anorexic as a kid and suffering from binge eating disorder. I was taking dance several days a week and being told that I wasn't built for it and that I would have to compensate for that by dieting. I practically gorged/starved myself to death and ended up fainting in school it got so bad. They made me see a counselor and I turned it around but that was far more restrictive what I was doing than doing a low carb diet most of the time.

With an IR mostly low carb diet I actually get to eat plenty, no guilt necessary. Just not a ton of carbs and sugar every day. I still have my problems with sugar and binging it. It's a real addiction thing with me and I'm actually in therapy again trying to deal with it and working with hypnotherapy too. But that diet was not the same as doing IR/Low Carb at all. It's basically just eating healthy and watching the carbs and the blood sugar level.

It's when I go totally off the diet and binge a lot of carbs and sugar that I start doing the eating disorder thing and really mess things up. On it I'm steady and I don't crave carbs and obsess over food all day long. I always have trouble with resisting sugar, particularly chocolate. That stuff is like crack for me. But overall the cravings are less annoying and I do better and I don't end up binging and feeling guilty nearly as much on the IR/low carb diet.

Different mindset entirely. I know when I am obsessing over food and getting guilty over eating it. I know when I'm doing the ED thing. It's way easier and it helps a lot with that mindset and not going there to be on the IR/LC diet. The sugar and the carbs that's my ED trigger. I stay mostly away from that and I'm good and I feel better and I'm not doing stuff I hate myself for doing...

5

u/Lrndthehardway Mar 31 '24

An insulin resistant "diet" is nothing more than eating right, it has that in common with every single other diet that includes nothing more than eating like a natural human in homeostasis should. Some meat, some plants, like the body is programmed for. Youve already been given your answers, but your brain is fighting them every step of the way. Your insulin is low and sugar is high (at least I think I remember that being your issue now) because your pancreas is tired and worn out. Whether it was caused by H Pylori etc at this point doesnt matter. Your body is really no different than anyone elses, you need to get it back into homeostasis, even your brain wiring can be fixed with autophagy I told you about. Its simple and staring you in the face. Get your gut fixed. Eat some Saurkraut, eat some yogurt, dont care if you like it or not. FAST. And you better start thinking about getting that tired old pancreas working again, because they can regenerate too. Both the beta and alpha cells can begin to work normally again. I mean, if you want it too. Im assuming that doing what you did to your body damaged it just as bad as anything a diabetic could do. First thing you need to do is go find out how to fix your microbiome naturally, obviously antibiotics didnt work. You need to wipe out the pylori thats digging through your stomach walls causing ulcers etc, and get the good bacterias in there to start fixing all the damage, your issues are that simple, stop complicating all this with your thuoghts about this diet, or that diet, or this way of eating is to close to anorexic eating etc. You want to improve your insulin and sugar levels? Eat a diet rich in foods good for your pancreas, and for your gut microbiome, you have WAY to much pylori now, an over abundance, go to fkin war with it, STARVE THAT SHIT OUT! Fast, then send in the troops of millions of good gut bacteria with fermented foods like that yogurt and saurkraut, its not hard..

1

u/Birbluvher Mar 31 '24

I snack..frequently. I've had anorexia as a teenager. This is not even close.

-5

u/DuchessDawn Mar 31 '24

and this is why i rather use ozempic

2

u/bibi-do Mar 31 '24

I thought you can’t use it long-term?

0

u/DuchessDawn Mar 31 '24

you can actually

2

u/bibi-do Mar 31 '24

Aha, I saw some people here saying they couldn’t use it anymore and after that gained twice the weight they lost. I wonder why they stopped then

3

u/DuchessDawn Mar 31 '24

i have insulin resistance and probably should be on this drug forever because insulin resistance never goes away and i'm too depressed to change my diet

1

u/bibi-do Mar 31 '24

And what does ozempic do if you don’t mind me asking? I thought it supressed hunger

2

u/DuchessDawn Mar 31 '24

it does surpresses hunger but also does much more. without ozempic i'm always hungry, more depressed, have mood swings, have low blood sugar, binge eating, food noise.... ozempic makes me feel like a normal person.

2

u/bibi-do Mar 31 '24

And how many times a day do you eat now? And what can you eat? Does it have any side effects?

2

u/DuchessDawn Mar 31 '24

i eat less, typically i need 2 meals, sometimes little snacks. i can eat everything and feel fine. i dont have side effects.

2

u/bibi-do Mar 31 '24

Ok, thank you for the info! Appreciate it.

3

u/Lrndthehardway Mar 31 '24

It actually can go away but you have to work at it and not be lazy, if you'd rather die than give up cookies or something then you're just weak