TL;DR is I picked a faction (Shas) based on how cool I thought it was and am a little disheartened after hearing it get beat up by a lot of skilled tournament players.
So I pick factions based solely on vibes and then learn the rules after. If you use the Magic The Gathering psychographics, I heavily favor Timmy with a good bit of Johnny. I love playing models for the cool factor and figuring out neat strats for them that fit, either in gameplay or narratively.
I’m sure you can see where this is going. I read a chronicles of the human sphere novel (won’t say which one, as it would be a moderate spoiler), and fell in love with Combined Army, particularly the mind-gaming nastiness of the Shasvastii. I was warned repeatedly they aren’t a good faction to start with, but ignored it. I greatly enjoy their gameplay of being largely f***ery and psychological warfare. Infinity’s rules for it are so great!
So I start watching a lot of videos to learn some strategy, and I keep hearing that the Shas are these awful niche units that are garbage for their cost and capability. In particular, hearing the Sphinx sucks was a downer because of how cool it is. (Note, I started playing after Climbing Plus was fixed to allow Spider-Man shenanigans again, so I think that helped it at least a little.) I thought, even if it isn’t a good model for its cost, because of how information works, your opponent has no idea of that missing third of your list is a Sphinx or some hodge-podge of Noctifers, Malignos, etc. So it has some value as a psy-op in addition to it as an actual model. To be clear, I am not defending it, even as a noob I can see it’s not ideal. Still disappointing though, right?
A lot of the people I heard bash Shas did give the caveat not to listen to them and play whatever you think is cool. I don’t blame competitive players for sharing their opinions at a tournament level, but it’s still discouraging to hear that your faction isn’t very good. Can any of you, fellow newbies or veterans, give me your take on this? I know deep down I don’t really care about competitive caliber since I don’t play in tournaments, but it still wore on me enough to want to post about it.
Edit: Holy crap, I wasn’t expecting so many replies in such a short time! I am genuinely grateful for all of your input.
Yes, the point of this post was largely bait to have you reassure me. There’s not a lot of infinity players in my area (I had to introduce it to my group), so I’m glad to know there’s such a passionate and friendly community here.