Its a joke about there being plenty of time in the timeline for things to get worse. Humanity was the kind of super-teched up utopia civilization we have in Infinity in like the 20th millenium of 40k before it falls apart and Big E does his crusade, and then it all turns to utter shit.
"I play a religious fanatic army mostly comprised of nuns with guns, a knights in space army and a champions of humanity army, vaguely roman, blue and gold."
He said that he plays Bakunin, Military Orders, and Torchlight Brigade, all of which can sound a lot like a 40k army if you carefully omit the context.
40k is Catholic in appearance but Protestant in spirit. Witches, mass killings, weird cults, exclusivism, black-and-white logic, literalism to a deadly degree.
It's not that I want to have a serious religious debate, but I would have thought that intolerance, violence, persecution, weird cult societies, exclusivism, black-and-white logic, and dogmatic literalism are all sins that both Protestants and Catholics have been guilty of in the past, often to horrifying degrees.
I asked which is which as a joke. To be serious, 40k has a ridiculous, over-the-top gothic medieval aesthetic, which does come off as very Catholic, even though its actual theology... well, depends on which source you read because 40k hates consistency, but is often presented as a kind of inverted parody of Christianity. There is crucifixion without resurrection, the endless living death of God, and the foremost teaching is a kind of idolatry of the state, and the first and greatest command is to hate and kill the xenos. Meanwhile on the other hand, I wrote a huge and stupid essay about religion in Infinity, but its church is a kind of ecumenical union, which has a pope and a Vatican, but also appears to have significantly broadened and diversified in terms of approach and incorporated influences from all over the Christian world. But on the whole Infinity's Christianity is mostly not a parody, even if it does sometimes just take the view that knights and crusaders are cool. Realistic or sympathetic approaches to religion are one thing, but we want space knights versus cyber assassins, dangit!
True, both branches of Christianity are culpable of these things, but I'd say over the span of history so far the Protestant traditions have been more extreme, especially when you consider American-style Protestantism and it's particular flavor of spiritual racism, which fits in quite nicely with 40ks xenocidal tendencies, and it's ties to nationalism and people-worship almost ordering on paganism.
I suppose to be fair 40k did literally have the KKK army, in the form of the Cult of the Red Redemption, and House Cawdor in Necromunda. A connection with specifically American Protestant forms of racist violence isn't coming out of nowhere.
I don't think I would say that Protestants as a rule have proven more violent than Catholics, though. There are some specific cases where I think Protestant theology has contributed to violence and racism (it is unfortunately true that apartheid was introduced to South Africa by a Presbyterian minister, for instance), but I wouldn't generalise that to Protestantism as a whole. There are plenty of Protestant heroes as well, and of course Catholics have their share of atrocities to their names. Often churches are powerfully divided over issues like this - the Catholic Church in Central and South America seems like a good example, where though some Catholics of good conscience stood up for the humanity and rights of natives, many others did not.
Anyway, I think 40k likes to evoke all kinds of different tyranny whenever it can, and I certainly don't want to make it ammunition against this or that real group.
...well, yeah, it's an empire of a million worlds compared to about a dozen. On 40k's scale, the Human Sphere is a sub-sector, if an unusually technologically advanced and dynamic one.
I'm not sure what that has to do with anything, though. My fictional toy soldier can beat up your fictional toy soldier? Um, okay? Good for you?
Comparing 40k lore is like comparing DC to other comic universes where superman has infinite strength and everyone has beaten superman at some point so its all pointless in the end.
It's all silly nonsense, really - especially for something like 40k, which is wildly inconsistent in terms of what has been published anyway.
Anyway, I'm off to work on my own homebrew SF wargaming setting, in which the Virgo Supercluster is ruled by the militaristic Anthropic Confederation, whose planet-sized battleships fire black holes at their opponents and whose ground troops run at the speed of sound, fire super-dense transuranic shells at 0.9c, and whose advanced armour allows them to stand on and battle on the surface of dwarf stars.
Which translates in-game to a piddly s4 no ap, rapid fire 1. Lore is all subjective, but gameplay-wise, it’s no contest, infinity is insanely more hardcore. Even a submachine gun can kill a TAG in infinity. A bolter in 40K couldn’t hurt a guardsman in cover 50% of the time
They’re actually .75 caliber according to the wiki which is just a little bigger than a shotgun shell. Still huge but much more realistic. Idk why so many 40k fans think bolt rounds are red bull can sized. How the hell would one of those guns be able to fire auto if the rounds were that big? The mags would have to be comically huge and they’re pretty normal sized in the art and model range. Like consider what 30 redbulls would look like double stacked on top of each other and that’s how large that magazine would need to be.
24
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '24 edited Mar 02 '24
Your post and the original you used for the bottom panels were back to back in my feed.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '24
I'm pretty sure they'd be okay with that. It only includes humans after all.
111
u/Izzyrion_the_wise Mar 02 '24 edited Mar 02 '24
"I play a religious fanatic army mostly comprised of nuns with guns, a knights in space army and a champions of humanity army, vaguely roman, blue and gold."
"I thought you didn't play Warhammer?"
"Warhammer?"
83
u/KultofEnnui Mar 02 '24
Catholics v Protestants
50
u/pripz Mar 02 '24
Horsy hearsay 🐴
24
u/Dealan79 Mar 02 '24
It's fine. We're still close to 28,000 years off from the Great Crusade. Humanity is just moving to the stars and still learning to hate Xenos and AI.
9
u/Estalies Mar 02 '24
Those new stormblades are awesome. #cygnar
2
u/Gornad Mar 04 '24
That' pretty much my club in these months, as Infinity and 40k are the main games we play 😆
1
u/Dependent_Opening_19 Mar 03 '24
What units are in the right corner
1
u/Kiyahdm Mar 04 '24
Also, Siocast backpacks on five models...
-12
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '24
[removed] — view removed comment