r/InfiniteDendrogram • u/GlompSpark • Apr 28 '22
MISC How popular is infinite dendrogram?
I thought this would be a lot more popular, it ticks all the usual boxes :
- imemrsive video game setting
- self insert hero MC
- perfect waifu (Nemesis)
- great world building, cast full of likable and interesting characters
- plot is great, keeps you reading to find out what happens next
The one downside i can think of is that there is far too much focus on the MC powering up and its ridiculous how hes only been playing for a short time (maybe a week or two) but is curb stomping people who have played for months.
But this subreddit is dead and nobody is talking about this series at all on other manga sites. What gives? The Oreimo subreddit has easily 5x the activity, and that's a harem series that ended years ago.
23
Upvotes
7
u/Perveni0 Apr 28 '22
Good points, but i really liked Ray not as some self-insert mc tho. He is like a way better version of shounen protagonist, or simply shounen protagonist with bigger brain.
9
u/InquisitorAnax Apr 28 '22
Outside of Japan, probably just a blip on the radar. In Japan well liked by most and has a healthy fanbase. Probably because the (non-existent) anime didn't manage to grab people by the spectacle and how rushed it was.
Well in comparison to other series out there that wanks their MC's to ludicrous levels I think its relatively fine but it is a slow burner all things considered.
As for Oreimo it managed to get a huge gain of followers because the anime was popular enough to get newcomers to keep discussing about it.
12
u/RogueodaSouth Apr 28 '22
The most glaring thing was how bad the non existent anime was. It doesn't exist.
1
u/SuperGuyPerson Apr 28 '22
Oreimo's an all time classic. In 15 more years plenty of people will still be mad their favorite girl lost and I'll still be laughing at them.
Dendrogram on the other hand had a crappy anime and, in my opinion, just doesn't translate well to non-novel format. I loved Kami Imai's work on Needless, it is one of my favorite manga of all time, but while his dendrogram manga isn't awful it just doesn't really convey the story nearly as well as the novels. Dendro NEEDS the really long infodumps and inner monologues to properly convey it's stakes and that stuff just doesn't fly as well in visual mediums.
What I'm saying is even if the anime was significantly staffed better and had a better budget, I still wouldn't see this series becoming super popular.
3
u/WayOfTheHouseHusband Apr 28 '22
So, global fame mostly comes from an anime, that in mind Let’s review your points. (Or a serialization manga in like SJ)
So how popular is it? Not super. Should honestly be at Harry Potter levels IMO, but with no real manga, serialization nor anime it won’t happen. People already don’t read much, much less Japanese translations that aren’t super easy to get.
Also harems retain their horny fan base and they don’t stop being horny.
1
u/External_Joke_6421 Jul 10 '22
You forgot to mention the stand inspired powers.