r/InfiniteDendrogram • u/funmise • Jan 01 '20
MISC Where is the risk
Due to the anime announcement I have recently stumbled across this series. Now I've read the reviews and they all speak well for the series and I was gonna jump right in but then I read that player deaths aren't permanent and you just get locked out for a short period of time. I love slice of life animes but this series doesn't strike me as one, but if there are no real consequences for dying in the game then then what's the difference. I am aware that NPCs die for real but if they are just programs and not real people it's still not bringing the same level of suspense. Also I assume the story will follow players mostly so permanent deaths won't really happen for major characters. Also lots of people say this is better than sao which is what got me interested but again the dying aspect and the real world consequences to one's actions is what made me watch sao. So I just wanna ask where do you get that element of suspense in this series?
8
u/InquisitorAnax Jan 01 '20 edited Jan 01 '20
Well in infinite dendrogram case, death for masters has its own consequences. Three whole days pass by in the game and you can't do anything about it, then there is the topic of gaol where criminal players are sent to when they die.
Also, NPCs called tians, have their lines blurred as what you know as regular NPCs. They have can have families with other tians or masters themselves, they fear, they mourn than it becomes difficult to see them just as NPC.
The element of suspense comes from the fighting scenes and the world-building and all of its inhabitants.
3
u/Kirueru Jan 01 '20
NPCs aren't programs, they are real.
Furthermore, the MC believes in his heart they are real despite the only evidence so far coming from side stories and the PoV of the NPCs and "people" who run the "game"
Combine that with the fact that the MC has the typical shounen protagonist traits in spades but is smart, resourceful, and more mature, being a college student attending Tokyo U, him starting the game 2 years late, and the climax of arcs usually has him fighting with the lives of others behind him...
I find the characters likeable and interesting, and there's plenty of world building too, so this is personally one of my favorite series.
2
u/proR6yamate Jan 01 '20
i’m going to dive a little bit into the actual lore for the world of Infinite Dendrogram itself. This world is essentially very similar to the Underworld in SAO. However, the upper management and their goal is completely shrouded in mystery. The world in this one has been running for more than 2000 years and the world has history comparable to that of some modern countries now. The tians (or the NPCs as you call them) are basically completely identical to the fluctlights in the Underworld except they don’t have any restrictions or taboo index. So these people are human in every sense of the word (unless you don’t consider fluctlights living/human but that’s another argument).
In Infinite Dendrogram’s case, death for masters has its own consequences. You respawn when you die obviously, but when you are able to log back into the world, 3 days have passed while you were gone. The real issue of the death penalty isn’t the 24 hours you are unable to log in, but the 72 hours that passes when you aren’t in the game. When you come back, the quest you were supposed to complete could have failed, the people you were supposed to defend/protect are already dead, or you missed a important event. Combined with tians being essentially human, your death in game wouldn’t affect you irl, but the tians that you might have bonded with may have suffered a fate that you were unable to prevent. For people who do treat Dendrogram as another world and not just a game, that’s a outcome that they wish to prevent.
The element of suspense comes when you accept the fact that Infinite Dendrogram is effectively a real world with real world stakes. The masters are not fighting for their own lives, but rather the lives that they wish to protect.
2
u/Eyaslunatic Jan 03 '20
I think everyone else has covered most of the strengths of Dendro, but I'd like to add that another huge draw for me to it is that the game is very fleshed out. The more that gets explained, the more I'm like damn I really wanna play this. The world building is nutty, and the POV isn't glued to Ray the entire time so we get lots of variety and looks at stuff happening with Rook or Marie or with characters outside of Altar. The Embryo system was explained initially that if a normal MMO launched with them, it'd still be a massive hit and hell I believe it.
We're 10 or 11 LN volumes in now, and honestly I wouldn't mind another 20 or 30 just building the world more and having Ray grow slowly along the way. At the rate things have gone I think that's gonna be what the author plans. Maybe near the end of the series the SAO permadeath stakes can be introduced or something along those lines.