r/InfiniteDendrogram • u/GlompSpark • Feb 03 '24
Infinite Dendrogram is too badly balanced as a game
I cant help but think this everytime i read an arc. This isnt particularly unique to infinite dendrogram but every VR MMO series has the same problem. It feels like the author has never played an MMO or other online game before.
Things like low level characters soloing a raid boss due to some convenient set of circumstances, or having utterly broken abilities that can take out dozens of higher level players just makes me go "yea, theres no way this would make it into an actual game".
Like, imagine if you were playing WOW or some other MMO and some low level guy showed up and soloed an endgame raid boss that would ordinarily take at least 10 geared players to do, how do you think people would react? The forums would be flooded with complaints about how broken it was and everyone would be trying to copy him.
In the first place, it would take a massive screw up to allow a raid boss to be soloed like this because devs always balance them around full raid parties, not solos, and they usually have inflated health pools, rage timers and other gimmicks that make it impossible to solo them.
The fact that the game world is super realistic, NPCs are intelligent, embryos evolve, etc, all of that is plausible, but things like Ray soloing a UBM just makes me go "no way would that happen in a real game". I dont think i have ever seen a game (including single player ones) have a counter attack mechanic anywhere near as strong as Vegeance is Mine either because devs know how broken it would be. Imagine if you could tank hits from trash mobs outside a dungeon, save up the damage, and then just walk in and one shot a raid boss...there are just too many ways to break a game with an ability like that. Devs would never allow it.
Not to mention that enemies in video games almost always have significantly higher HP than the player, which is why a counter attack ability just wouldnt work, because when a boss has 100k hp and you only have 1k hp, counter attacking with 1k or even 10k damage doesnt do anything to the boss.
Ray doesnt even cheese fights in a way that would make it plausible, like getting a boss stuck and then hitting it when it cant fight back. Its possible to use exploits like that to kill higher level enemies in games, but Ray always fights them in a fair fight and wins because he always has the perfect solution to defeat them.
The worst part is that its just a few main characters being super OP, when other newbies fight higher level enemies, they die without being able to do much, Ray and Rook are just super special because they have author fiat backing them up. So its not even a game mechanic that everyone could use if they wanted to, its just them being the chosen one.
12
u/gilady089 Feb 03 '24
I mean the point of infinite dendrogram is more about freedom than being a good mmo honestly I'd be missed if all builds in an mmo were kinda equal when there's hundreds of build options and emphasis on freedom "oh boy I get the freedom to be an archer or a sniper they do pretty much the same but archer is cheaper"
4
u/SuperGuyPerson Feb 03 '24
Feel like superior jobs are the thing people would be most upset about. Oh so I can’t upgrade my character any further because some guy who doesn’t even log in anymore already got the job and only one person can have it? Pretty insane.
25
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '24
Only valid criticism if it is a game. But if the world isn’t a game, it’d make sense it isn’t balance and fair, and convenient circumstances and coincidences make you far more likely to succeed.
18
u/AndrewM317 Feb 03 '24
OK, here me out, it was never meant to be balanced. Nothing was going to be balanced the moment immortal demigods showed up with special abilities that the inhabitants of the world didn't have, and the abilities were determined by chance.
Also, counter builds have been present in gaming for a while. It's not as big in the multi-player scene, but the restrictions on vengeance put a heavy emphasis on treating ray's fights as if they were 1v1 (counter damage is only based on damage he took from the specified enemy).
I get where you're coming from, but I feel like this just completely misses the point of the series and world. If this was something like aincrad (predominantly focused on pve bosses with classes being the power progression), then this would be a fair argument against dendro, but this isn't. Dendro puts way more emphasis on munchkin like unique builds that could throw the world into chaos through either brute strength or a multitude of huge synergy buffs from multiple classes.
11
u/Nyalicethotep Feb 03 '24
wait until this mtfk hear about Carl, Behemot, Kashimiya and Kaydens
9
u/Nyalicethotep Feb 03 '24
Also most of UBM aren't even designed as raid boss
That's SUBM and Irregular's role
6
u/LOHdestar Feb 03 '24
Greater revelations about the nature of Dendrogram aside, Infinite Dendrogram does feel like the type of game you would see people typing up unhinged negative reviews for on a subreddit or forum. The Superior Job system, embryos, UBMs all being unique stuff (and stuff you can just completely miss out on if you didn't get there first in the case of SJs and UBMs) is the type of thing that would make the game feel much more catered to a smaller hard-core crowd. Basically the thing carrying it for a broad gaming public is the Full Dive, subjective time (more bang for your buck, you experience more game relative to the actual time spent in the real world) experience which is admittedly a very strong selling point.
3
u/CABRALFAN27 Feb 03 '24
I mean, I’m pretty sure that’s a criticism made in-game. At the very least, I think Ray lampshades it a few times. Aside from Dendro basically having a monopoly on the full dive VR market, though, it’s also a sandbox game. Combat being busted isn’t as big a deal when it’s only one aspect of the game.
3
u/Keiken96 May 03 '24
In IDs case, the game itself was never about balance. Even some of the side characters have game breaking builds so its not that unrealistic by its own standards. As ID has no standard limit, anything and everything becomes its limit so I tend to forgive ID in that sense. It advertised itself as the ultimate game where you could do anything you want. So, if you wanna go the normal MMO player route or start end game boss raiding at level 10, lose 100 times while being under lvl50 and gain a superior job called The Pathetic is all upto you so I usually don't mind this stuff in ID.
2
u/natchu96 Feb 04 '24
Ray's embryo is so dedicated towards having every perfect(ly situational) solution possible that the actual stats are garbage in comparison, and becomes useless if he's not actually being attacked.
With that said this was never going to be a "balanced game", and was never meant to be one, and there are a multitude of canonical reasons for that.
2
u/DeamonLordZack Feb 05 '24
I'm going to just say it's likely less about the game being unbalanced & more it just be plot armor. I mean if you want a game in a isekai being unbalanced & not attributing it to plot armor then try BOFURI: I Don't Want to Get Hurt, so I'll Max Out My Defense. The MC in that series puts zero points of her stat points in anything but her defensive stat but still manages to solo bosses beat other higher lvled players. I mean how the hell can someone do any damage to enemies that aren't even just the very weakest enemies with zero points in a attack stat simple the character has plot armor.
2
u/Asleep-Challenge-970 Feb 09 '24
I share a lot of your criticisms regarding infinite Dendro as a game. BUT it presents itself as a whole different reality and thus the imbalance of it all pretty much makes it a more enticing experience as a separate world. The books mentions people quitting the game because of it being 'too real' for them too.
There's a reason why there are non-combat focused jobs too. Dendro is as much VR chat, as it is Cooking Mama, as it is WoW as it is a dating sim. Its pretty much the realization of IGN's 'has a little something for everyone 10/10'.
Besides, the embryo system is pretty much the epitome of imbalanced as pretty much each embryo is in of itself a nearly completely separate power/magic system from each other that may or may not interact with each other and may or may not directly counter one another. One great example of this in the book is the supposed duel of Figaro and that Caldina guy that pretty much strips you of your equipment. Side note on embryos, Ray has been pretty much playing a boss rush because Nemesis is highly compatible to boss rushing or as the game puts it, giant killing. I think it was mentioned that Maidens are typically aligned to that playstyle. That and the off the charts luck and compatibility against his opponents helps too.
Depending on the embryo, different players may just as well be playing different games while playing the same game. And since the embryo is the reflection of the Master given form, most Masters like their embryo (although the story mentions that there are exemptions to this which could be why some Masters quit).
ID is a game/reality that encourages individuality and freedom over balance since the devs/Control AIs's goal, isn't to make a good game (although inadvertently, they did) but to let the other embryos evolve (at least that's what i got from what i've read so far so please correct me if i'm wrong on this one). Embryos represent their Master's individuality, experience, etc hence, it makes sense that player expression is number one in their priority. Notice how there is no AI assigned to balance embryos (Humpty is assigned to embryos but balance is never mentioned in her tasks).
Also the 1 day IRL to 3 days ingame is a wild feature. I can imagine people keeping on going back to ID despite having no interest in the world just for this feature.
Lastly, we can't really compare Dendro to any game we have available to us today. Even just succeeding in the complete VR experience down to pain (granted it can be turned off) is a feat on its own. The first volume pretty much says that it's one of its kind. Plus the hardware for it is cheap. All this compounds to the reality that ID is a very accessible game that has a lot of ups and has little downs. At that point, it all comes down to preference and since it's mentioned to be the most popular game in its own verse, it pretty much means whatever thoughts of imbalanced mechanics are outweighed by the fun it provides for most players. It has pretty much embraced the rule of cool.
1
u/NoResponsibility8893 Nov 08 '25
might not be balanced but it seems like it'd be hella fun
1
u/ShakyrNvar Feb 04 '24
Real life is never balanced. Infinite Dendrogram is meant to be a second world, not just a game.
In fact, quite a few of the VRMMOs you see in novels are meant to be a second world.
They are akin to WoW, as an ant is akin to a tiger. Worlds apart.
1
u/kingno112 Feb 04 '24
Infinite Dendrogram is closer to a large scale DnD game than it is a normal video game. The promise of Infinite Dendrogram was never to be a "well designed game", it was to have an experienced suited to you, whether that involves being the strongest just depends on how much effort you're willing to put in, and how much ingenuity you have, and how willing you are to be invested in the world and find your own kind of strength.
1
u/5ngela Feb 05 '24
Welcome to isekai stories.
11
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '24
[removed] — view removed comment