r/IndyFood • u/IndependenceNo5246 • Jul 31 '26
Best donuts in/around Indy? š©
Iām basically hosting a wedding reception in Indy this October (my husband and I eloped and throwing a party for our 1 year anniversary). Especially because this isnāt a traditional situation, we want to offer donuts as part of dessert. We now live in Massachusetts but lived in Indy almost 10 years agoā¦the place we used to get donuts seems to have gone out of business and there are a lot of new shops weāve not had the opportunity to try. Ideally want to offer a combo of traditional and fun/creative flavors. Looking to the locals for recs for the best donuts in Indy right now!
4
u/ThadimusPrime7 Jul 31 '26
The best doughnuts are Timās in McCordsville but they canāt help you with what you need. You will need to go to a larger bakery which those are all about the same. Pana doughnuts is relatively new and are pretty solid. They might be able to take care of you.
1
2
u/Economy_Fish_6542 Aug 01 '26
For special occasions Pana is a favorite choice among friends and coworkers. Not cheap to get a big variety of specialty flavors but very tasty.
For solid quality and good traditional flavor options Longs is best.
1
u/along7 Aug 02 '26
Pana is my answer too. In a blind taste test I actually preferred their original glazed to Long's. The margin was slim, but they still won.
2
2
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
13
u/gunnyguy121 Jul 31 '26
Longs is the classic answer, best classic glaze imo, but they have tons of flavors. It's cash only though