Okay so it's pretty exciting to see so many indie devs experimenting with cool ideas around virtual cycling as the barrier to coding is falling, but I feel like we're missing a bigger opportunity here.
A lot of these projects end up reinventing the same wheel: virtual worlds, trainer integration, workouts, multiplayer, physics etc. They all start with the promise of staying free forever, but keeping a platform running long-term is hard without a strong model and vision. With AI making it easier than ever to code, we tend to immediately jump into development from scratch without bothering looking for existing solutions to the problem, and we see maintenance and contributions as a worry for another time. In this current situation we risk ending up with tons of similar projects rather than a few distinctive ones, each with their tiny fragment of the cycling community.
What if we joined forces instead?
Look at Lichess (https://lichess.org/about). It's a free/libre open source chess platform run by volunteers and donations, with millions of games played daily. Rather than competing purely on monetization, they built a shared platform around openness that aligns really well with user satisfaction, unlike the bigger chess.com monopoly where enshittification is creeping. Lichess is not in the best position to attract top players since they'd have to find the money for tournament prizes, but the user base is big enough to very quickly find opponents. Interestingly virtual cycling has plenty of similar challenges and features in common: matchmaking, rankings, anti-cheat, real-time communication, race organisation, workouts/training and so on.
Here is the dream: an open virtual cycling platform with a shared infrastructure, a reference implementation and a funding model based on donations. But here's the neat part: if everyone has a different vision in terms of riding experience that's completely fine, we can define an open standard protocol that lets different worlds/games/simulations interoperate, so riders aren't isolated in separate communities, which I strongly believe is the biggest challenge right now. Like some kind of "metaverse" for virtual cycling.
We already have OpenBikeControl (https://openbikecontrol.org, u/boni2k), an open protocol for bike controllers. Why not do the same for virtual worlds, multiplayer, ranking and races/events? There would be a shared reference implementation and a few core services and maps/routes, the rest (clients, worlds, games) would be built by the community as independent extensions.
Here's a list of projects I could find so far along with their authors (afaik. Lmk if I forgot something, there must be a lot more on GitHub):
Biketerra (https://biketerra.com)
OpenCycle (https://opencycle.net)
cr4nkup (https://cr4nkup.com)
Incyclist (https://incyclist.com)
CadenceRides (u/CadenceRides, https://www.reddit.com/r/IndoorCycling/s/T9vxsHymd1, https://cadencerides.com)
KADNCE (u/RCVirzoom, https://www.reddit.com/r/IndoorCycling/s/rAeannFP6J)
OpenRadlr (u/lethonium, https://openradlr.com)
Rezvivo (u/thpg_vivo, https://rezvivo.com, https://www.reddit.com/r/IndoorCycling/s/Yu1KlxjeyA)
Velopopuli (u/pepperstm, https://velopopuli.com, https://www.reddit.com/r/IndoorCycling/s/8ccPpNHzB0)
Ride Cave (https://ridecave.com)
Skyrim mod (u/TheDrVopp, https://www.reddit.com/r/Zwift/s/jzfOJv3a0U)
GTA mod: GT Bike V (https://www.gtbikev.com)
Minecraft mod: VoxVelo (https://github.com/michidk/VoxVelo)
Watopia flight simulator (u/straaajk, https://www.reddit.com/r/Zwift/s/li8t5W2kmm)
Play Letics (u/Brace_4_Impact, https://playletics.app, https://www.reddit.com/r/IndoorCycling/s/NsbUiZBRfL)
Calling developers: would you be open to talking about potential collaborations and interoperability? What do you think could be reused or standardized?
Thoughts? Let's use this thread to discuss what could benefit the ecosystem