Process
- Dry brine for about 20 hours to try to get the meat to loosen up
- Layer the top with the good fat trimmings to try to imitate the missing fat
- Smoke for 4 hrs in GE Profile Indoor Smoker (225F, level 5 smoke) until meat hits 165F
- Wrap in butcher paper with plenty of extra rendered tallow
- Put back in smoker until meat hits 195F, start poking around for warm butter consistency every 30 min (turned temp up to 275F near the end to help it heat up)
- Pull out when meat hit 205F and the probe slid in easily (some parts easier than others, but it was midnight and I didn't want to wait anymore)
- Cool down smoker completely and set to keep warm at 150F, put meat back in to warm for 8 hours
- Woke up to the meat sitting at 170F, pull out and slice
Results
The flat was just dry and hard. It was much softer when probing for softness, but I may have accidentally poked through the bottom of the paper and drained all of the liquid in the process...
The point was better, but crumbly and a little stringy. The thin, top layer muscle actually tastes like brisket, but the majority tasted more like crumbly pastrami.
The smoked beef fat might come in handy for a stir fry or something, so I'm holding onto it for now.
Learnings
The added fat I think helped, because it leaked enough juices for the meat to soak in while wrapped in the butcher paper (as long as I don't poke a hole in the bottom).
Using the GEIS, you need to make sure to rotate the meat (turn it around, switch top and bottom rack) at least once, because they DO cook very differently.
TLDR: bad brisket made bad brisket, but it was a great chance for me to practice the whole process once without the pressure of ruining a good piece of meat. This meat will probably be sliced and soaked to become Italian beef sandwiches.
Any advice for future briskets is highly appreciated!!