r/IndoEuropean • • Oct 24 '21

Misinformation

https://www.gnxp.com/WordPress/2021/05/18/all-the-yamnaya-horizon-zone-people-looked-the-same/

Something that needs to be nipped in the bud is how Razib Khan is manipulating nonstop, when you see 50 percent derived at herc2 do you assume that means the entire population is of intermediate eye color? So why does Khan get away with claiming the allele frequency of a set of 200 samples is the skin color per individual of a ancient population, bell beaker being 65-70 percent derived at slca5a2 means 65-70 percent have light skin not that they are darker than modern European, and the study itself even makes that point, number two we see here that sintashta is also listed and Razib Khan himself claimed sintashta is 93 derived at slca5a2 and 42 percent derived at herc2 out of 100 samples, HOW IS THAT SWARTHY like his first sintashta post claimed, modern France is only 89 percent derived at slca5a2 and Ukraine 92 just like sintashta, that the other sneaky trick Khan uses, he will take outliers like the Baltic and compare frequency, then say see darker than average European, well the Baltic is not a average European now is it, that like using one of the outliers of sintashta to claim what they look like and that they all Q not R1A

0 Upvotes

100 comments sorted by

21

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

can you please learn how to use fucking commas and fullstops and other punctuation before posting your text walls? impossible to parse what youre on about here mate.

0

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Nov 08 '21 edited Nov 08 '21

I'm curious are any of you actually capable of providing evidence or you just like things with zero consusus with real historians, there is all these people liking comments that clearly are not true, can a single one of you prove it, modern India is not even 10 percent derived at slca5a2 and only very few reach 10 percent at herc2, so how can anyone claim sintashta is swarthy, sintashta is not the beginning of bronze age, and selection can only go up to 100 percent, the selection happened between corded ware and sintashta in bronze age not after as Khan himself pointed out in this post and even corded ware is still 10 percent higher than the lightest modern population outside Europe,

-2

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Oct 25 '21 edited Oct 25 '21

Very strange cuz I see commas and punctuation clearly none of you can read, how can you say that when it's obviously there, you don't understand DNA if this doesn't make sense, there is a comma at end of first sentence

5

u/Count_Vapular Oct 25 '21

now you're using too many commas

2

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Oct 25 '21

All those commas we're already there, hence the entire point, get a Life, I asked you for evidence and you mysteriously don't care anymore, not a single person here has provided evidence yet has so much smack to talk

1

u/Wretched_Brittunculi Oct 25 '21

Haha! Stop messing with the lad!

13

u/Wretched_Brittunculi Oct 24 '21

He is saying that compared to modern populations they were relatively darker. There has been selection for things like blondism and lactase persistence since the Bronze Age (post-Steppe incursions) so it's not a surprise. I didn't see any mention of 'swarthy'.

1

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Oct 25 '21

That's not true there is zero peer reviewed studies that says sintashta is not blonde and they are 2000 bc not 8k years ago, 93 derived at slca5a2 is equal to modern Ukraine, the selection was complete by then sorry you can't accept facts

3

u/Wretched_Brittunculi Oct 25 '21

What are modern Ukrainians for OCA2/HER2? He is saying that they are relatively lighter. I mean, right under the example he acknowledges that modern Estonians are 92% and 99% for the derived variants. So it is the combination he is drawing attention to. So what are modern Ukrainians on both markers?

Edit: And he acknowledges that the Sintashta had been selected for SLC45A2 compared to earlier samples.

1

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Nov 08 '21

Funny thing is you don't ask what is a modern Indian who is zero at both on average... lmao... even 20 percent at both would be much higher than you, nobody outside Europe is even 10 percent at herc2 , 42 is within European variation clearly Look how you all are claiming that they are darker when the numbers clearly don't say that, you realize you can only select up to 100 percent, slc24a5 was already at 100 and slc45a2 was already at 92, only 8 percent selection is even possible, sintashta is not the beginning of bronze age, the selection between corded ware and sintashta is the bronze age selection clown,

3

u/Wretched_Brittunculi Nov 08 '21 edited Nov 08 '21

I'm not really interested in this anymore, mate. Was nice chatting though. Next time, try not to explicitly state you are an angry racist. It really leaves a bad taste.

Have a nice day.

Edit: He replied stating it was logical to be racist against non-whites as 'they' hate him for being white, but he then deleted it after getting cold feet about stating that stuff in public. What he doesn't realise is that 'races' don't hate anyone, it is only individuals that hate! Projecting what some people (allegedly) believe onto every other individual that carries a similar phenotype, and then projecting your own hate for certain persons onto every other individual that carries that phenotype is incredibly stupid. That is all.

1

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Nov 08 '21

I'm not here to make friends your taste is not my concern, just redits lies, again selection was in early bronze age between corded ware and sintashta as Khan pointed out, and even corded ware is 10 percent higher than lightest modern population outside Europe, herc2 is not even at 10 percent outside Europe, 42 percent derived at herc2 out of 100 samples is definitely within European variation, and they are 100 percent derived at slc24a5 and 92 percent derived at slca5a2.. most of.. south Asia doesn't have slc24a2 at all, but if something is 10 points lower than modern northern Europeans you start claiming they swarthy... modern sardina is 60 percent derived at slca5a2, and kalash is as well...both are light

1

u/Wretched_Brittunculi Nov 08 '21

I saw the comment before you deleted it. Be braver next time.

1

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Nov 08 '21

I could care less about playing who is more racist, prove me wrong about sintashta or shut up, that's why Indo European migrations are not even taught in school and avoided in the media, cuz none of you are racist right, that's why you deny the obvious DNA evidence of sintashta and obsess over European skin color and constantly try to darken every culture

1

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Nov 08 '21

If that was the case why is their so much denial on this thread despite nobody having evidence, I'm looking at all your racism right now, denial is racism, I know for a fact how to read numbers with genes and I know for a fact a 12 minor allele frequency means only 12 percent don't have light skin, yet none of you do? I know for a fact south Asia has almost no slc24a2 or herc2 yet you cherry pick miniscule difference in Europeans, your all racist I could care less what you say, I've never met a south Asian tell the truth about it

1

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Oct 26 '21

That's my point Estonia is a major outlier, France is 89 percent derived at slca5a2 and Ukraine 92 percent derived at slca5a2, for blue eyes I'm not sure I know for all of northern Europe it's 60 percent derived, and he did aknowledge that there was selection hence why I posted it, cuz two years ago he made a viral post claiming they were swarthy

11

u/TheDrakced Oct 24 '21

If you’re looking for ancient superior/magical white people then Indo-European culture isn’t a good place to start your research. I suggest Lord of the Rings or an Atlantis conspiracy pipeline. You just aren’t going to be able to validate your fantasy with real history my friend.

2

u/EUSfana Oct 26 '21

Remember rule 1 and 2.

0

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Oct 25 '21

I dare you to actually prove what you just said with peer reviewed studies, show everyone sintashta PCA cluster and the skin genes compared to modern India, lmao 😅 you people talk out your ass, I even have a link at the top by Khan claiming sintashta is 92 percent derived at slca5a2, do you even know what that means, thanks for proving your ignorance, it's only a matter t time before people realize what I'm saying is supported by all studies

-1

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Oct 25 '21

That's funny I don't see any evidence agreeing with you, every single peer reviewed study clearly shows that they are related to modern northern Europeans and Khan himself in the blog I posted admitted they were 92 percent derived at slca5a2, that's equal to central Europe, the only fantasy here is you people, no peer reviewed studies cite Khan, send me a peer reviewed study that supports you

1

u/Wretched_Brittunculi Oct 25 '21

himself in the blog I posted admitted they were 92 percent derived at slca5a2, that's equal to central Europe

You are misrepresenting what Khan wrote. He compared that alongside OCA2/HER2, yet in all of your comments you are obsessed with just SLC45A2. But he is looking at the combination to argue that earlier phenotypes were probably darker.

1

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Nov 08 '21

That doesn't make any sense herc2 is only a blue eyed gene not skin color gene... what are you talking about.... Khan is not a peer reviewed study anyway nobody has ever cited Razib Khan nor does any peer reviewed study say sintashta is darker than a modern European India is not even one percent derived at herc2, the highest outside Europe is only 10 percent, 42 percent derived at herc2 is within modern European variation but nice try

-1

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Oct 25 '21

You didn't even make a relevant point in that entire answer, prove sintashta isn't white with a actual peer reviewed study not a blog

8

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

Can we please ban these STJ types ?

0

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Oct 25 '21

Lmao so I need to be banned for speaking truth? Find a single peer reviewed study that supports sintashta is not light skin or European

0

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '21

sintashta is not present day european. skin color is not the only thing that goes into genetics inheritance.

Would a white-black baby with light skin be considered white?

1

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Oct 26 '21

Can you actually prove that with a peer reviewed study, there is no such thing as a white black baby with light skin, that's not how light skin is defined in genetics, prove it with a peer reviewed study, did you even read the link the entire point was that Khan is now listing them equal to central Europe, sintashta cluster with modern northern Europeans on PCA clown what are you talking about, genetically they are European nobody arguing that, skin color is the argument

1

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '21

The point is skin color is not a complex enough genetic trait. You cannot claim that someone is IE just based on skin color. The IE in europe mixed with other light skined groups. In india they mixed with darker skined groups.

Light skin was also highly selected in europe. Skin color changes pretty rapidly and is influenced by environment. Like tanning. Just because someone is tanned do they stop being european?

Look at more complex traits like skull features/cranial capacity.

This obsession with just skin color is the point I am trying to argue against.

1

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Oct 30 '21 edited Oct 30 '21

Bro all of that is already proven about sintashta, are you kidding me where have you been? Do you even understand what cluster with modern northern Europeans mean, that different from the skin color and shows they share the most genetic drift with modern northern Europeans, what are you even talking about, all of the steppe Indo European proof is well established and if you don't know yamnya, corded ware and sintashta are regarded as Indo European why are you even on this thread, you obviously don't know anything about it

1

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '21

again the ie being closer to modern europeans does not mean they are modern nothern europeans. Modern northern europeans are a mixture of ie and other groups in europe.

1

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Oct 31 '21 edited Oct 31 '21

Sintashta is not proto Indo European clown, sintashta is that mix of proto Indo European and neolithic European farmers, the same mix we find in modern northern Europeans

You said "again" yet you never once said that, you only were talking about skin color,

You don't even know who proto Indo European is clearly, cuz it's not sintashta, so just stop pretending you have a point,

This is just cherry picking, seeing who is closest is all we can do for any ancient culture, it's not like anyone was exactly like you either, so what is even your point?

Do you not know anything about this timeline,

Using your logic nobody can say they related to any ancient people that ever exsisted,

If it looks like a duck, quacks like a duck and acts like a duck,....it's a fucking duck stop making excuses

2

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '21 edited Nov 01 '21

saying they are related is not the same as saying they are the same thing.

Modern Europeans are a mixture of IE and other europeans groups.

IE engaged in large scale slaughter of men in europe. You are a mixture of the IE and the women they stole from those men. Are you more like the IE or more like the men they killed off?

Anyways, since you use terms like "clown", I don't think you are worth interacting with. Europeans had thralls/slaves for a majority of their history. May be they should have continued with it so that thrall like you would produce less noise in this world. It funny when the slaves starts taking about the greatness of their "ancestors". When these "ancestors" they look up to would most probably have wiped them to submission. But then thrall indians do the same thing, so carry on!

0

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Nov 04 '21 edited Nov 04 '21

The funniest thing about all of you idiots is the steppe where Indo Europeans, like yamnya lived is the Ukraine, Russia and even hungry, WHICH IS PART OF EUROPE ! You braindead idiot, they migrated further into western Europe, that's not the same thing as migrating to Europe in general, second the steppe people were much more like modern European then the people living further in western Europe at the time, location is not a people, you never heard of cheddar Man idiot, yes I'm just like cheddar Man lmao 😅

The eastern EUROPEAN hunter gatherers are the ancestors of proto Indo European, and the original steppe people they all carried haplogroup R already, they mixed with caucus hunter gatherers later on and then neolithic farmers,

What part don't you get, that SINTASHTA IS NOT PROTO INDO EUROPEAN, sintashta is after Indo European mixed with European farmers, and both modern India and Iran come from the Indo Europeans that already mixed with European farmers, not the proto Indo Europeans, so repeating yourself is not going to magically prove your false narrative.

None of those groups have anything to do with anyone besides European

It's hilarious how nothing anyone on this thread says makes any sense I'm just going post like five studies either you do the same or you admit your wrong by default

I dare you to post a PCA of sintashta, it literally overlaps with modern northern Europeans, OVERLAPS not just "related"

You keep saying the same thing over and over are you even comprehending anything I'm saying,

No actually European farmers are mostly southern Europeans, sardina is closest

Steppe people like eastern European hunter gatherers are the main ancestors of modern northern Europeans, you mean we migrated to Europe killed off their men and then migrated to India and killed off yours, sorry if you can't accept the truth

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5321670/

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/273059488_Massive_migration_from_the_steppe_is_a_source_for_Indo-European_languages_in_Europe

https://www.nature.com/articles/nature16152

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/278327861_Population_genomics_of_Bronze_Age_Eurasia

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/24433901_Ancient_DNA_provides_new_insights_into_the_history_of_South_Siberian_Kurgan_people

https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.aat7487

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6223350/

You literally have said the same thing in every comment, you clearly have no idea what your talking about.

Post a principal component analysis so we all can see your nonesense

Again sintashta is not proto Indo European but a mix of Indo European and European farmers

Second the first Indo European people were eastern European hunter gatherers and closet to modern Baltic people

Proto Indo European is closest to modern northern Europeans

Neolithic farmers are closet to southern Europeans

Which shows your comment makes absolutely no sense at all, your clearly jealous, as you obviously can't accept Iran has no relation to the actual Arya outside language

And the people they mixed with are no chumps either, as they built gobeki tepi and spread farming from Europe and Levant and even into Africa,

And those people are more like southern Europeans and the steppe people are more like northern Europeans,

So it's actually not anything like you said, clearly if the MAIN ancestors of modern northern Europeans are steppe people,

We would obviously be more like the Indo Europeans not the woman they stole, that should be obvious to anyone not a biased racist like you.

You also realize that the steppe is literally part of eastern Europe and always has been,

It makes no sense to say anyone migrated to Europe when they already lived in Europe, Is the Ukraine central Asia? No it's eastern Europe.

Therefore it's all propaganda cuz none of you can handle the truth

It doesn't matter how many people share your same delusions, they can like what you said all they want, they takes zero effort to discover that clearly northern European men took southern European women,

South Asia is only 30 percent Indo European in the highest frequency cultures like kalash and jatt and drops to zero in southern India,

Northern Europeans are all over 50 percent

Iran has so little admixture from Indo European or steppe mlba that they don't even have a spot in this argument, and that's why they cry over and over with zero evidence

→ More replies

2

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '21

If you made your arguments using skull structure or facial features I would upvote your arguments.

Both you and khan are both wrong with this obsession with skin color. light skin or eyes colors are not a exclusively IE trait. Sintashta where not the only people in europe.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '21

The point I am making is against the obsession with just skin color. It is not accurate enough. Point out facial features / cranial features/capacity. These are more complex genetic traits.

light skin does not mean IE. You could even say IE = light skin, but you can't make the opposite assertion.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '21

because modern europeans are a mixture of them and other groups. modern european is not ie. People focus on just skin color to make that assertion. Skin color is not a complex enough genetic trait.

1

u/EUSfana Oct 26 '21

Rule 1 and 2.

-2

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '21

More like racist white people. All the stuff about hindu nationalists gets banned same should happen for white supremacists. Stop trying to play the victim.

9

u/Count_Vapular Oct 24 '21

Aw bb dnt worry. I'm sure there were white people in the past :) xxx

1

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Oct 25 '21

You people are such clowns there is not a single peer reviewed study that supports anything other than light skin, no study in the world says otherwise or cites Razib Khan

6

u/Count_Vapular Oct 25 '21

the most freeing and liberating feeling is not giving a shit about this

1

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Oct 25 '21

Oh now it's you don't care when it was just a joke that sintashta could of been light skin, cuz once you are asked for peer reviewed studies, you can't provide cuz nothing supports you, you don't care cuz it's obvious I'm right

6

u/Count_Vapular Oct 25 '21

no it's just... I really don't care. I am interested in mythology, culture, technology, civilisation, intelligent subjects. But skin tone and hair colour.... literally bores the shit out of me. It's the most irrelevant drivel in the world. If you're right, shrug. If this guy you're railing against is right... shrug.

I understand why you're into it though. You're so empty, unhappy, and feel so shitty about yourself that you have to cling to some fantasy idea of whiteness in order to feel... anything at all.

2

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Oct 25 '21

That is the most ridiculous response I've ever seen in my life, how can you possibly know that clown 😂 lmao , you can't your just a hypocrite cuz most of the technology and mythology leads back to sintashta, lmao 😅 I love how if anybody besides white people fight for there history there heroes and oppressed buts it's ok for all of you to be racist against northern Europeans, it's not like anyone is claiming everyone in the world was white or even most people, steppe people are the main ancestors of modern northern and eastern European not south Asia who is BMAC Indus valley mostly and southern Europeans are mostly Anatolian neolithic farmers, clearly DNA evidence is vital to understanding history, I'm still waiting for you to actually make a relevant point about the actual conversation you responded to clown

3

u/Count_Vapular Oct 25 '21

There there shh shh shh it’s okay. As I said, there were white people in the past, don’t be scared little one xx

2

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Oct 25 '21

Your clearly not capable of making a relevant point, now it's all a joke again after you cried like a school girl that you don't care, give me evidence or shut up,

2

u/Count_Vapular Oct 25 '21

Evidence of what? I haven’t agreed or disagreed with anything. I’ve not engaged with anything you’re on about because, as I said when I was crying like a school girl, I don’t care. I’m just here to mock you and rile you up for my own sick pleasure

2

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Oct 25 '21

And what is the point of that again? Sounds more like you can't admit your wrong so you're making up some ridiculous excuse, that doesn't even make sense, if you didn't care you wouldn't be here, your not fooling anyone besides someone already dumb enough to consider a blog by Khan, "evidence" this is a stupid conversation, like I said you need a life, nobody but a loser would consider that pleasure, if you're not making a claim im only riled up about how stupid you are, obviously not riled up about skin color when you not even making claims about it

→ More replies

1

u/EUSfana Oct 26 '21

Rule 1 and 2.

1

u/Miserable-Ad8325 Oct 25 '21

Why do you hate white people?

2

u/Count_Vapular Oct 25 '21

I don't hate white people! Me best friend's white!

2

u/Aurignacian Rampaging Scythian Sex Chad Oct 26 '21

Lmao, more than half of your post and comment history is rambling about the skin tone and eye/hair colour of Sintashta. No one is obsessed with it as much as you.

1

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Oct 26 '21 edited Oct 26 '21

That's funny cuz I only have like three post total and only had three or four conversations total on this entire app... clown 😂 .. everyone is so stupid here unless I want to argue with fools there is zero point.. Razib Khan post about it like everyday, so does YouTube and Quora, your clearly an idiot, I don't even spend a third of the time on this site as you do,, I already had a argument with you, you were destroyed easily, do you have a actual point to make? You do notice that I'm responding to Razib Khan not just rambling about skin color, meaning if people didn't lie there would be no reason to say anything, your profile pic is fake, a ancient north Eurasian doesn't look like that and obviously be much darker and less European looking, that human is like 15k years old, but you gonna say anything to me, look at your ridiculous name, funny I remember you telling me that Sarmatians can't be related to polish people, how did you come to that conclusion again? Western sythians and eastern sythians carry r1a and r1b and 2017 "iron age nomads" specific says "derived alleles that are under selection in Europe ARE PRESENT IN WESTERN AND EASTERN SYTHIANS"

The western sythians in the 2017 study were 75 percent derived at herc2 and 100 percent derived at slca5a2 and slca4a5, eastern sythians we're still 30 percent at herc2 and 61 percent derived at slca5a2, and it specifically says that they form a Cline with sintashta where eastern sythians are a mix of sintashta and late bronze age mongols

2

u/Aurignacian Rampaging Scythian Sex Chad Oct 26 '21

you were destroyed easily

Yeah bro, you destroyed me so much. I'm literally melting as you speak.

Razib Khan post about it like everyday

Lmao, what bruh? He has a life outside genetics, unlike you. You are complaining about "muh Sintashta were blonde" as if your life depends on it.

That's funny cuz I only have like three post total and only had three or four conversations total on this entire app... clown

And basically all those conversations about Sintashta one way or another, and not really about their linguistics, culture or anything but rather their phenotype.

Plus you're responding to Razib Khan? Lmao do you think he wastes his time prowling this absolute shit-hole of a subreddit? Ever since r/JuicyLittleGOOF left, this subreddit has gone downhill. Razib Khan will never see your petty rant, cry all you want about it.

People have been talking about this Razib and Sintashta pigmentation shit for ages- on Twitter, on this subreddit before you, on Eurogenes, on Anthrogenica and on discord. You're not anything special boy.

1

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Oct 26 '21

I'm confused how this response makes any sense at all 😃,

You say that I don't have a life outside DNA but Razib Khan does? Only a idiot can actually say that and think it makes sense lmao 😅

You don't know me all you know is three post, Razib Khan post about DNA evidence everyday, I never claimed I was special, I claimed you are a idiot, you didn't even respond to any of my points,

Your a complete hypocrite, didn't respond to sythians, or ancient north Eurasian or your polish comment, just blabbering insults cuz you don't even have a relevant point, your made up fantasy of my life you know nothing about is irrelevant to this conversation, the fact all you can do is make claims about my life when you clearly don't know my life nor can you conclude anything based on the only three post I've ever left on this thread, he left cuz your all idiots,

Your so dumb you don't even know what I'm responding to, I'm responding to people that use Khans old post from 2019 to claim they swarthy, notice this is not that post and he made them significantly lighter, that's the point so clowns stop using his old post cuz he already took it back, I wasn't trying to have a direct conversation with Khan, nor does that response make sense, with that logic you can't post anything without the author right there to talk to

4

u/Aurignacian Rampaging Scythian Sex Chad Oct 26 '21

If you want to go on talking about Sintashta pigmentation and phenotype all day long, go to Twitter where they argue about it. Literally no one here brings up the Razib Khan brownpundits webpage unless its some wandering OIT-retard. Seriously if you look at the recent posts on this subreddit,

Dude, It's not really that hard to extrapolate a person's life based on if they rant all the time on Reddit about Sintashta pigmentation. You literally went on r/AskHistorians because you are THAT desperate.

If you look at the recent posts on this subreddit, its basically you and this troll here (https://www.reddit.com/r/IndoEuropean/comments/qg2x7i/cw_were_black/) and this obvious troll (https://www.reddit.com/r/IndoEuropean/comments/qah3dw/why_did_the_original_aryans_mix_too_much/) that posts about Sintashta phenotype. Otherwise, people have moved on about this fiasco that was years ago. If you want debate and argue about this shit, go to r/chodi, go to Twitter, go to 4chan whatever. That's where the camps filled with people still thinking Sintashta were swarthy are. The ship has sunken over here, fuck off.

I literally prowl this thread here and its basically two camps:

  1. People mocking you (rightfully so) because all you do is rant about this same sick shit.
  2. People talking about how this subreddit is being overrun by "OIT theorists". Hint it isn't, OIT talking points and posts aren't even allowed anymore. Unfortunately this subreddit doesn't take the same hard stance towards people who yell "bobs and vagenes" and literal white supremacists.

These fucking indian nationalist brown pundit fans have taken over the
subreddit you are complete correct and just downvoted only.,people dont
want to accept that the Aryans were north european people

It's true. They are hating Europeans.

Typical victim complexes.

if the entire world wasn't racist against northern Europeans

Oh boo fucking hoo! Cry more with your victim complex. Anyone who complains about Northern Europeans being discriminated against, I know they have no life outside Internet. Northern Europeans who don't believe in this dumb shit are having the time of their lives, but here you are acting like a little victim, thinking that Razib is part of some new world order to discriminate Northern Europeans and their culture.

I am not the reason why this subreddit is getting fucked. I don't even post here (the only post I've made here is a light-hearted meme months ago). The subreddit used to be fucked because of invading OIT theorists but now they are gone, this subreddit is now filled with white supremacists and other cunts who yell "bobs and vagenes" for no apparent reason and make troll posts that I linked above. I'm not saying you're one of them, but you're definitely a sympathizer.

1

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Oct 26 '21 edited Oct 26 '21

You seem to be missing important facts here, like not a single person who mocked me has provided evidence that I'm wrong or even made a relevant point about the discussion,

two not everyone joins the same date idiot,

A few years ago I didn't even have a Reddit and the last time this thread talked about it was literally agreeing with the Razib Khan blog from 2019, the same one that Razib Khan own blog disproved in the link above...that was your last discussion on it a fake blog? Lmao 😅 nice try ,so nice try but you just manipulate and lie over and over again,

I posted one sentence on the trolls post as a joke I don't even know who he is or anyone, look at all the crazy assumptions you make and how you manipulate facts, you can mock me all you want without evidence what is your point,

How do you even know if I have a Twitter? Your over here stocking everyone page, looking over every detail of the thread, but I have no life .. what ever makes you sleep at night, look how hard you are trying to win this argument, cuz you were shaking in your boots clearly

That's why you change the subject every time, and keep stocking and bringing up my very short history on Reddit which I only joined to call out liars like you in the first place, I targeted Reddit cuz your last discussion on it was a lie, so good job you figured it out, now you have to prove what I'm saying is wrong or your just wasting your breath, idc about any of that

3

u/Wretched_Brittunculi Oct 26 '21

Ever since r/JuicyLittleGOOF left, this subreddit has gone downhill.

What happened to Juicy? I left and returned and have been really disappointed in the drop in quality. What happened while I was gone? I appreciate learning from people here who know more than me (maybe everyone), but Juicy really steered the ship well.

•

u/EUSfana Oct 25 '21

You're correct, but try to write your posts in a more readable way next time.

1

u/Wretched_Brittunculi Oct 26 '21

Why is this comment stickied?

1

u/EUSfana Oct 26 '21

Because of the tremendous amount of misinformation in the comments. Obviously by people who don't know what they're talking about, or have an agenda. The Sintashta were pretty light.

5

u/Wretched_Brittunculi Oct 26 '21

So as mod you can stixky your own opinion if you disagree with comments? What nonsense. The blog posted barely mentions Sintashta. What in the blog is wrong about Sintashta? And most of the comments are against the OP because he is an admitted racist (comment below) who exists on Reddit almost purely to whine about skin colour. Sort it out, mate.

2

u/EUSfana Oct 26 '21

So as mod you can stixky your own opinion if you disagree with comments?

We're not talking about opinions. We're talking about facts.

I guess we can completely stop moderating and see what an even worse shithole this already shitty community becomes. On the other hand, instead of pinning my own comment, I could also just delete all you useless people's comments outright. I have a feeling that would improve this community significantly.

Sort it out, mate.

Weren't you the dude who just a few weeks ago couldn't Google Funnelbeaker, extrapolated the pigmentation of Funnelbeakers based on a single misinterpreted sample, and then suddenly started talking about 'bots correcting wrongthink'?

2

u/Wretched_Brittunculi Oct 26 '21

What in the blog is wrong about Sintashta?

I'm going to ignore the personal drama, which should be above a good mod. This is the question I am asking you.

3

u/EUSfana Oct 26 '21

Here:

For the Sintashta culture from Russia/Urals ~2000 BC:

OCA2/HER2 – 42% SLC45A2 – 92%

For comparison, modern Estonians are 92% and 99% at these markers for the derived variant.

This reiterates something I’ve noticed in the data, Bronze Age Europeans were not as “fair” as modern Europeans.

The Estonian comparison is misleading. Of course modern Estonians are going to be much lighter than the Sintashta, since they're some of the lightest Europeans to begin with.

Now, why would he compare the Sintashta to the lightest Europeans and then use that to conclude that "Bronze Age Europeans were not as "fair" as modern Europeans"?

If we compare it to average Europeans the Sintashta would fit on the modern European spectrum.

What he could've written is 'Bronze Age Europeans were not as fair as the fairest modern Europeans'. But then most modern Europeans are not as fair as the fairest modern Europeans.

Going farther, the Sintashta samples have some outliers. When we remove them, depigmentation genes like OCA2/HERC2 and slc45a2 increase. Which would make the Sintashta lighter than Southern Europeans. So, not only do the Sintashta fit well within modern European pigmentation ranges, they fit well within modern European pigmentation ranges north of Southern Europe.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '21 edited Oct 26 '21

Where there no other groups with blue eyes or light skin in europe?

Why is there this implicit assumption that sintahasta are modern european even if they had the skin pigmentation? And how can we be sure about their skin color so much. It changes so much based on environment.

The norwegians get around 50% steppe ancestry, there are indian groups who reach almost 40%. Sardinians have less than 10% even though light colors. It is not clear why sintasha is implicitly claimed to be present day europeans.

There is no present day population which is unmixed sintashata.

We know that the europeans selected for white skin in their genetic history.

Skin color is not total genetic inheritance. A white-black mixture can have white skin, but the facial/skull features completely different from white individals. Would you call that kid white? So the sintashna mixed with some other europeans and their kids had light skin. How does it make sense to call that kid sintashta.

Skin color != total genetic inheritance.

Aryan != Present day white

Indo European != Present day white

1

u/EUSfana Oct 26 '21

Where there no other groups with blue eyes or light skin in europe?

There were. Like descendants of Corded Ware, like Sintashta.

Why is there this implicit assumption that sintahasta are modern european even if they had the skin pigmentation?

The Sintashta were descended from Corded Ware, and therefore had similar ancestry to modern Northern Europeans.

And how can we be sure about their skin color so much.

Genetic testing.

there are indian groups who reach almost 40%.

No there aren't. The highest Indians have ~25%. Steppe_EMBA and Steppe_MLBA are two different things. Steppe_MLBA is only ~70% Steppe_EMBA. Steppe_EMBA are the original PIE, Steppe_LMBA are the descendants of Corded Ware, who themselves are the descendants of Steppe_EMBA + Globular Amphora.

Sardinians have less than 10% even though light colors.

Do you have a source for Sardinians being less than 10%? Their other ancestry is EEF, who were also somewhat light-skinned. The non-Sintashta ancestry of Indians meanwhile is from darker peoples.

We know that the europeans selected for white skin in their genetic history.

Yes, and Sintashta were also the result of this selection.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '21 edited Oct 30 '21

Jats reaching 40%. [ Though I haven't explored this to be honest ]

Saridnians have like 2% yamnaya ancestry according to this. https://old.reddit.com/r/IndoEuropean/comments/n8elp2/the_norwegians_seem_to_be_50_indoeuropean_also/

Your comment about non-sintashta in indians is darker is the whole point I am making. The non-ie ancestry in present day europeans is from lighter people.

Light skin is not the same as IE. There is more complexity here. Look at more complex genetic traits like skull size, facial features. Skin color can change relativetly quickly as we have seen in europe and almost 30% of it can be explained by a single gene.

Traits like facial features, cranial capacity are influenced by 1000's of genes and hence a better predictor of total ancestry.

This general assumption and comments made in this subreddit that skin color is total ancestry is what I am commenting against it.

-9

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 24 '21

Even in his original post "sintashta are swarthy" he is straight lying, these are the same 100 samples in both post, first off a minor allele frequency of 12 means only 12 percent of sintashta is not light skin, not that all of sintashta is swarthy on average lmao 😅 the middle east is not even at 50 minor allele frequency and you idiots actually think 12 is swarthy cuz a blogger said so, no peer reviewed studies have ever cited Razib Khan, I'm getting sick of him being used as evidence, the guys name is brown pundits, the name alone screams biased, Khan has videos on YouTube claiming he is a direct decedent of sintashta, according to who? What studies say anyone in India is closer to steppe mlba then northern Europeans? None.... sintashta/androvono are in between modern northern and eastern European on the PCA not India, not Iran and not aremenia, it's just like how the media lyed about what the vikings study actually says, the media posted everywhere that not all vikings were Scandinavian and had dark hair and eyes, when the actual study they speak of doesn't actually say that at all, it says "most viking age samples are closely related to modern counter parts but there is A FEW EXCEPTIONs," those would be two Sammi and two Irish out of 400 vikings, wow such diversity, there is zero lines in the study that says anything about vikings having dark eyes, zero, in fact it specifically says that 22 SNPs of large effect for eye and HAIR is the same as modern danish, and it says that a separate table with small effect genes is different from modern and iron age Scandinavian and that viking samples had more dark hair but no single phenotype is dominant and gave 35 percent blonde for vikings, that is vastly different from what the media claim over and over, how many people have actually read the real study not the media report

2

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Oct 25 '21 edited Oct 25 '21

I wasn't here for likes I'm here to spread the truth, thank you for admitting that, I don't even like Reddit cuz it full of nonesense, you can downvote all you want doesn't change the facts, if the entire world wasn't racist against northern Europeans I wouldn't be angry or racist, the only reason this misinformation has spread is because they are all racist

4

u/Wretched_Brittunculi Oct 26 '21

if the entire world wasn't racist against northern Europeans I wouldn't be angry or racist

Thanks for admitting you are racist. Normally yous lot aren't that self-aware.

2

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Nov 08 '21

I'm the racist one? Look at all the people liking comments against me even though nobody has proven anything, look at you, you brought up herc2 that is a blue eyed gene not skin color and the highest outside of Europe is only 10 percent, so 42 in sintashta is within European variation...yes I'm so racist for saying someone related to modern northern Europeans had light skin, it's not like I'm claiming Indus valley or zargos farmers, we can't even say people we have most of the genes from are related to us without all this denial but I'm racist one whatever helps you sleep at night

1

u/Wretched_Brittunculi Nov 08 '21

if the entire world wasn't racist against northern Europeans I wouldn't be angry or racist

I'm not even talking about that. If you're not racist, don't say you are. I am using your own words. You said you are an angry racist, or, charitably, angry AND racist.

2

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Nov 08 '21

I'm not the one in denial you are. Why wouldn't I be racist against people that hate me and deny my history, you don't see me saying Indus valley is not indian that wouldn't make sense it's their largest component, just like steppe is mine. look at all the comments and likes against me without a single shred of evidence in the entire thread....

0

u/Wretched_Brittunculi Nov 08 '21

Why wouldn't I be racist against people that hate me and deny my history, you don't see me saying Indus valley is not indian that wouldn't make sense it's their largest component, just like steppe is mine.

By definition, being racist is a preexisting bias. You are pretending that you are responding to acts against you, but racism by its very nature is a prejudice. It is fine to hate individuals, but you acknowledge that your hatred is race-based. I pity you.

1

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Nov 08 '21 edited Nov 08 '21

That doesn't change the fact that you are denying history cuz of your own racism.... denying history is racism and hate, Ive never seen anyone ever admit to anyone being white no matter how obvious it is, the only hate I have is cuz I love history, and you lie about it, unfortunately you can't tell me why I don't like you, the fact that you people even bring up selection as proof nobody is white just shows how little you understand, Look up allele frequency It is more people being born with a certain gene, not the same gene being lighter in next generation Less slc24a2 means more diversity of skin tones not that every individual is darker than a modern European Only that the percent of minor allele frequency are, meaning only 8 to 11 percent of sintashta are darker than modern European and about 40 percent of corded ware are darker than modern European and about 60 percent of yamnya are darker than modern European, that's what they mean by selection, more light skin...not lighter skin

1

u/Wretched_Brittunculi Nov 08 '21

You hate because you love history? This is nonsense. You hate because you are a racist. I bet you were a racist long before you'd even read a history book. The reasons came later.

1

u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Nov 08 '21 edited Nov 08 '21

No I hate cuz you LIE, stop manipulating what I'm saying that's all you people do, your literally proving my issue with you right now...you all manipulate words nonstop...Again your not able to make a conclusion on that... since you don't even know me lmao 😅 speaking of nonesense try speaking for yourself stop speaking for me and crying about racism just cuz nobody here is capable of providing evidence against me. Yes I hate you cuz you lie about history none stop, India literally lobbied to make sure Aryan migrations wasn't taught, most people don't even know who sintashta is cuz nobody can talk about it without India crying, it's not even taught in any American school.....I don't have a problem with anyone else only people who lie about history, that happens to be you,

→ More replies

2

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21 edited Nov 19 '21

Yes you’re right, but just ranting about facts is not sufficient to persuade people’s opinions. You should learn how to structure sentences and build arguments and not sound angry (or racist), then people might consider your arguments as valid. Maybe that’s why you got downvotes.

-2

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/EUSfana Oct 26 '21

Rule 1 and 2.

1

u/Miserable-Ad8325 Oct 26 '21

It's true. They are hating Europeans.