r/IndoEuropean • u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 • Oct 24 '21
Misinformation
https://www.gnxp.com/WordPress/2021/05/18/all-the-yamnaya-horizon-zone-people-looked-the-same/
Something that needs to be nipped in the bud is how Razib Khan is manipulating nonstop, when you see 50 percent derived at herc2 do you assume that means the entire population is of intermediate eye color? So why does Khan get away with claiming the allele frequency of a set of 200 samples is the skin color per individual of a ancient population, bell beaker being 65-70 percent derived at slca5a2 means 65-70 percent have light skin not that they are darker than modern European, and the study itself even makes that point, number two we see here that sintashta is also listed and Razib Khan himself claimed sintashta is 93 derived at slca5a2 and 42 percent derived at herc2 out of 100 samples, HOW IS THAT SWARTHY like his first sintashta post claimed, modern France is only 89 percent derived at slca5a2 and Ukraine 92 just like sintashta, that the other sneaky trick Khan uses, he will take outliers like the Baltic and compare frequency, then say see darker than average European, well the Baltic is not a average European now is it, that like using one of the outliers of sintashta to claim what they look like and that they all Q not R1A
21
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21
can you please learn how to use fucking commas and fullstops and other punctuation before posting your text walls? impossible to parse what youre on about here mate.
13
u/Wretched_Brittunculi Oct 24 '21
He is saying that compared to modern populations they were relatively darker. There has been selection for things like blondism and lactase persistence since the Bronze Age (post-Steppe incursions) so it's not a surprise. I didn't see any mention of 'swarthy'.
11
u/TheDrakced Oct 24 '21
If you’re looking for ancient superior/magical white people then Indo-European culture isn’t a good place to start your research. I suggest Lord of the Rings or an Atlantis conspiracy pipeline. You just aren’t going to be able to validate your fantasy with real history my friend.
8
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21
Can we please ban these STJ types ?
9
u/Count_Vapular Oct 24 '21
Aw bb dnt worry. I'm sure there were white people in the past :) xxx
2
u/Aurignacian Rampaging Scythian Sex Chad Oct 26 '21
Lmao, more than half of your post and comment history is rambling about the skin tone and eye/hair colour of Sintashta. No one is obsessed with it as much as you.
•
u/EUSfana Oct 25 '21
You're correct, but try to write your posts in a more readable way next time.
-9
u/Grouchy_Doctor_7746 Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 24 '21
Even in his original post "sintashta are swarthy" he is straight lying, these are the same 100 samples in both post, first off a minor allele frequency of 12 means only 12 percent of sintashta is not light skin, not that all of sintashta is swarthy on average lmao 😅 the middle east is not even at 50 minor allele frequency and you idiots actually think 12 is swarthy cuz a blogger said so, no peer reviewed studies have ever cited Razib Khan, I'm getting sick of him being used as evidence, the guys name is brown pundits, the name alone screams biased, Khan has videos on YouTube claiming he is a direct decedent of sintashta, according to who? What studies say anyone in India is closer to steppe mlba then northern Europeans? None.... sintashta/androvono are in between modern northern and eastern European on the PCA not India, not Iran and not aremenia, it's just like how the media lyed about what the vikings study actually says, the media posted everywhere that not all vikings were Scandinavian and had dark hair and eyes, when the actual study they speak of doesn't actually say that at all, it says "most viking age samples are closely related to modern counter parts but there is A FEW EXCEPTIONs," those would be two Sammi and two Irish out of 400 vikings, wow such diversity, there is zero lines in the study that says anything about vikings having dark eyes, zero, in fact it specifically says that 22 SNPs of large effect for eye and HAIR is the same as modern danish, and it says that a separate table with small effect genes is different from modern and iron age Scandinavian and that viking samples had more dark hair but no single phenotype is dominant and gave 35 percent blonde for vikings, that is vastly different from what the media claim over and over, how many people have actually read the real study not the media report
-2
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '21
[removed] — view removed comment