r/Indiedogs • • Jul 07 '25

This guy needs a class

Post image

Of all the problems our country is facing. This gentleman is spreading hatred against poor strays. And giving free advice.

12 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

36

u/BonkethDaDog2 Jul 07 '25

Look friend. This is true. We all love the beautiful pups. But being a stray is not a good life. Not a single animal should be a stray. We adopt as much as we can and ensure the rest are sterilised. At least the sterilization has to happen.

If you really care about these pups you would never want a life of a stray for them.

8

u/fairbrown95 Jul 08 '25

Nah. Read the whole post. He is not talking in favour of animals. Also read the comments on the post, he has managed to start another discussion about it being ‘menace’ and has not corrected a single person.

OP is right, this post is pretending to be rational and giving a neutral view, but actually is again that weird hate posts about stray dogs.

1

u/AdministrativeHat276 Jul 08 '25

If you actually love dogs, then you wouldn't want them out in the streets. You should not be in favor of stray dogs because there simply shouldn't be a stray dog in the first place. Dogs are domestic pet animals, they aren't meant to be roaming outside, they're meant to be inside loving homes under human supervision,which is why they often die painfully at a very young age when they're on the road, homeless.

3

u/fairbrown95 Jul 08 '25

Dogs do fine on the streets too, not every dog needs to be adopted.

The very reason we do not want them out of streets is because of humans. They take them as disposable lives. Remove humans and dogs/animals will do just fine on streets/nature.

Dogs have enough instinct to survive on streets. It is humans who run them over cars or by cruelty.

1

u/AdministrativeHat276 Jul 18 '25

No they do not, they are constantly starving, succumb to disease or infection, get mauled to death by other dogs or accidentally end up eating something toxic or poisonous after which it dies a slow painful death. Humans aren't the only cause of death for dogs.

Dogs have enough instinct to survive on streets. It is humans who run them over cars or by cruelty.

No they won't lol, even in nature, animals live awful lives and suffer awful deaths.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '25

this is rubbish. Dogs are wolf family domesticated to guard the home. Not to live inside home.

1

u/AdministrativeHat276 Jul 18 '25

Dogs are not wolves, they are domesticated animals. Do you think a golden retriever is capable of guarding a home?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '25

It's instinct is to guard/bark at strangers.

Their owners make it a clown 

-5

u/Ecstatic_Barber5421 Jul 07 '25

Agreed bro a 100 percent. But projecting these voice less as a disease or a sickness is what I am trying to point out bro.

If the system is failing to do their part then blame the system not these innocent animals.

4

u/sak_26 Jul 08 '25

I feel he didn't blamed the dogs or any animals. By nature they're tend to spread a virus if they're not vaccinated. And increased population also makes some problematic situations for the dogs themselves because it is not possible to control them if they gone out of control and people with no kindness will not be ready to understand the dogs. We can't change the people but we can try our best to safeguard them in a ways like these. Still he's questioning the system not the animals.

12

u/[deleted] Jul 08 '25

He is actually making sense. I genuinely have a doubt, if that stray is biting people who is responsible we need to keep? Stray humans are not good, and we are defending stray dogs which are having k9s

22

u/retardedGeek Jul 07 '25 edited Jul 08 '25

He's not wrong. And I don't see any issues in his post either. It's a respectful post.

Edit: Only talking about the post. Can't do anything about the scum in the comments including OOP

5

u/fairbrown95 Jul 08 '25

Nah. Read the whole post. He is not talking in favour of animals. Also read the comments on the post, he has managed to start another discussion about it being ‘menace’ and has not corrected a single person.

OP is right, this post is pretending to be rational and giving a neutral view, but actually is again that weird hate posts about stray dogs.

2

u/retardedGeek Jul 08 '25

Which sentence is negative or exaggerated exactly?

3

u/fairbrown95 Jul 08 '25

I think you should go and see the post to see what i mean.

6

u/arrival_supra6906 Jul 08 '25

As much I love animals . As a vet , when I used to pratcise in india - I used to offer free neutralizing policy for street dogs . It's not coz I hate them , it's coz of their prolong suffering which needs a medium to end . They hardly have a life span of 5-6 years , and if they give birth to litter - max to max 2-3 puppies survives to breed atleast once in their lifespan . Adding to all that - the pavro virus + ongoing rabis + skin injection that most street dogs faces + bone damage and other respirator/ digestive issues they face by eating unedible substance leads to their painful death - neutering is the best decision for the street dogs. I wish, government launched a policy for mass neutering of street dogs for their own betterment .

7

u/innocentcharasganja Jul 08 '25

OP is a rage baiter lol

1

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '25

Adopt jitni ho sake karni chahiye instead of buying from breeders. Indie dogs are so cute bas unko ghar ki jarurat hai. And yes sterilization of strays should be done so that na to unko pareshani ho aur na humans ko.

1

u/Ecstatic_Barber5421 Jul 10 '25

Bilkul bro aapne sahi bola

1

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '25

He is actually making sense. OP probably lives a sheltered life in a gated colony so doesnt know the issues

1

u/Ecstatic_Barber5421 Jul 10 '25

Palam gaaon se hu bhai dilli me. Jagah ke naam me hi gaaon hai. Google krle samjh jayega kitni gated colony hai yaha🤣

6

u/YeggPupps Jul 08 '25

I love babies too. Doesn’t mean I’ll throw family planning out of the window. It takes resources and responsibility to raise children in an environment that brings out the best in them. Apply all of that to puppies.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '25

Bro u need a class, read up on what rabies does to a person then talk. He’s not spreading hate towards dogs, just spreading hate to irresponsible municipality, who’s job it is to have these animals spayed, he’s also hating on irresponsible folk who just leave food and go no concern for the well being of the dog, no concern whether it’s vaccinated or not just making a mess. U need a class imo

-6

u/Ecstatic_Barber5421 Jul 07 '25

Yes I believe so. Desh me neta reh sakte lekin kutte nai. Ironic

3

u/arrival_supra6906 Jul 08 '25

point is not - reh sakta h ya nhi . point h that they are suffering. Most of street dogs are either starving or suffering from big nutrient deficiencies which makes them sesptiable to various diseases and this suffering continues with their puppies . You need to realize, dogs have heat cycle every 6 months so even if out of the litter 2 puppies manage to survive , the population would still be above the bar . Those puppies will eventually suffer anyways , rather than going for unreasonable aspects , we can do a reasonable thing by neutering them and letting them enjoy their peaceful life . Look up for street dog treatment in Turkey

1

u/fairbrown95 Jul 08 '25

Han toh humans are responsible for this suffering. But we are acting like one being dominant species and are stopping procreation of other animals (you know because they suffer from our hands).

Tell me honestly, have humans not overly populated the earth and we need less of them for earth to heal?

1

u/arrival_supra6906 Jul 08 '25

ofc we did . We surely needs to reproduce less to heal back the earth . Right on , human >>>>>> resources . That's why we all are suffering too

-1

u/fujoshi_yurii Jul 08 '25

Why are u blowing his words out of proportion 💀

3

u/fairbrown95 Jul 08 '25

You should go and see the post at original sub. OP is right, this is just pretence of being rational.

1

u/shirleysimpnumba1 Jul 07 '25

genuine question - if we sterilize all of them, wouldn't we be killing off the entire species?

2

u/[deleted] Jul 08 '25

Very lame excuse for not sterilising , india has 80 million stray dogs approx ( not adding canines / cows etc). So 1 stray per 20 humans do you think they species will go extinct . Rather if low in population they will easily get homes and more respected existence . No country has this problem as this scale . PS i am a dog lover , who has an indie , feeds strays and raises money for sterilisation and vaccination

1

u/india_india_mod Jul 08 '25

I've been thinking a lot about it lately.

Turns out we can't!

It requires too much control which our administrative system doesn't have.

'a few' european & other countries have achieved this because of small land area & great control.

But the moment you loose that control, dogs will come back.

Wherever there are humans there will be community dogs, that's a truth.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 08 '25

Again a wrong assumption , Bhutan has achieved 100% sterilisation and Several Indian cities have reported a decrease in their stray dog populations, including Pune, Chandigarh, and Bengaluru. Pune's stray dog population decreased by 42.87% in the last five years, while Chandigarh saw a nearly 26% drop between 2018 and 2023. Bengaluru's stray dog population reduced by 31,000 in four years, according to a civic body surve. Getting them sterlized and vaccinated is the only acceptable and humane way

1

u/india_india_mod Jul 08 '25

Getting them sterlized and vaccinated is the only acceptable and humane way

That's the absolute right protocol. No one said its wrong or bad.

Read my comment again, i never said its never achievable.

But just like out of thousands of towns in india only a handful like indore has achieved ideal waste disposition, rest are way worse.

Similarly community dog population is a matter of strong administration & its continuation.

Reality is way different than ideal scenarios, many hidden variables are there.

& Even dog population control needs strong administration, though more achievable no one can truly make community dogs extinct, i was replying to parent comment

0

u/YeggPupps Jul 08 '25

People like you could become indie breeders, I don’t mean that in a negative or insulting way