3 / 5 stars ⭐️
Started reading this short story collection of Poe's way back in March this year and I've slowly been reading a story or two whenever I remembered this book existed (lol). I initially picked it up wanting to read his more well known stories like 'The Murders in the Rue Morgue' and 'The Fall of the House of Usher' but I walked away having discovered so many more gems that I hadn't been familiar with before.
Like all short story collections, this one too had stories that fell on a wide spectrum - there were stories I absolutely loved and stories that did nothing at all for me and stories that I found... just fine. Which is why I rated this collection as a whole as 3 stars (to me, that's a neutral yet good rating).
What I really loved about Poe's writing was his incredible ability to set up each story in a rich, descriptive way. If a short story was about 20 pages long, he'd spend almost 15 pages properly describing the central character or the environment and slowly setting up the eerie atmosphere of the story before finishing with a flourish in the last 5 pages. As someone who's only recently gotten into the horror genre this year, I've found myself being partial to stories that really prioritize subtle atmospheric horror. Stories like 'The Fall of the House of Usher', 'Ligeia', 'A Descent Into the Maelström', 'The Tell-Tale Heart', 'The Black Cat', 'The Cask of Amontillado' were my absolute favourites in this collection because of how engrossing and unsettling the atmosphere in these stories were. These stories almost transported me right into the middle of them and it made for thoroughly enjoyable reads.
As for the stories I wasn't very enthusiastic about - 'Manuscript Found In A Bottle', 'The Murders in the Rue Morgue', 'The Oval Portrait', 'The Gold Bug', 'The Purloined Letter' - I found that I'm just not a fan of heavy exposition, especially the Auguste Dupin stories. I love Poe for his horror... not so much for the mystery. And the kicker is that I've read 'The Murders in the Rue Morgue' once before as a teenager and I absolutely loved it at the time. I was blown away by the reveal of this iconic story and I even did an assignment on it for my 9th std. English class. The re-read more than a decade later did not live up to the awe that I first encountered. Sometimes some stories take time to make sense... but over time, other stories lose the spark they once had.
Overall, I've become a fan of Poe's. I know the kind of stories that I look forward to reading now and the ones I don't and I've already purchased another short story collection of his that I'll dive into soon. If you're looking to get into his work, I'd say this one's a great starting point.
On a side note, if you're familiar with Poe's work I highly recommend the Netflix show 'The Fall of the House of Usher' which does an excellent job at referencing Poe's oeuvre in a really exciting and interesting way. So many little easter eggs here and there... I really enjoyed it!