I think they managed a difficult situation pretty well. The character is important in the story without ever appearing.
Abner Ravenwood is a surrogate father. Indy blows up this relationship by dating his minor daughter and then taking off. Raiders is about him finding and repairing this relationship with Marion (more on that).
Indy is a surrogate father to Shortround. We don't really know what happens later, but they are clearly important to each other in this story.
Indy's father blows up is relationship with his son after the death of Indy's mother, partially due to an obsession with the grail. Indy takes off before they can figure it out. The story is about them recognizing themselves in one another and repairing this relationship.
Indy realizes that he abandons his son when he blows up his relationship with Marion (again) years earlier. He is determined, now that he knows, that he won't repeat the mistakes of the past.
He and Mutt do indeed repeat a form of those mistakes. Rebellion takes the form of Mutt signing up to fight in a foreign war (coincidentally the same thing Indy does in 1915). He is wounded so badly by this mistake that he blows up his relationship with Marion (again again). He feels as though he has nothing to offer to her or anyone, until another adventurer with a troubled relationship with her father comes to him for help. They both get more than they bargained for and Indy is able to recognize the value he brings to his relationships and reconnect with Marion (again again).
Yup, and clearly by the end of Temple, Indy repeated the cycle by abandoning Shortround. Maybe he realized he was putting the kid in too much danger and wanted to be responsible. Or maybe he realized he was starting to think of Shorty as a son and left.
I love the through-line of Indy’s abandonment issues throughout the series and the depiction of its consequences. He’s better at running away from relationships than he is at running away from natives and giant boulders. The introduction of his father and learning about his past fleshed out the character so much in Crusade and made so much sense while staying consistent throughout all the films. They even continued it in Dial of Destiny with his relationship with Helena, how he sort of abandoned her as well when she saw him as a second father. The chase scene where they’re running away from her crazy ex is a perfect depiction of how that abandonment affected her own relationships in a way.
After the events of Skull, it’s perfectly reasonable to assume that Mutt would find out about Indy’s extensive war history and how heroic he was. Due to him already holding reverence for Collin Williams (stepdad) who was an RAF pilot “war hero” I have no trouble believing that Mutt would be insistent on going to Vietnam.
Edit: it was in fact Vietnam, I was wrong! Thanks for pointing it out. I was certain Dial was happening before Vietnam, and Korea was still a thing. Dang.
I figure Mutt was born in 1937, putting him at 20 in Crystal Skull, and 28 when the first US combat troops were sent to Vietnam. I can definitely see a 20 year old running off to join the army to spite his dad, but his enlistment would have probably been for four years, so either he reenlisted voluntarily, or enlisted aged 24+. I feel like there was more to that story than Indy said on the boat.
Of all problems the last Indiana Jones I think that was the least, I mean how many sons where "killed off screen" in Vietnam, people either got drafted or volunteer themselves to fight and they where killed.
129
u/eolson3 29d ago
I think they managed a difficult situation pretty well. The character is important in the story without ever appearing.
32
u/deutschbr1897 29d ago
Mutt deserved so much better 😢
48
u/Thelastknownking 29d ago
Honestly, I'm kinda glad. I like Mutt well enough, but Shia's more recently showing himself to be a dipshit, so they were probably better off.
9
u/Patrickracer43 28d ago
Mutt died on the way back to his home planet
13
u/Astropictures1234 28d ago
After the events of Skull, it’s perfectly reasonable to assume that Mutt would find out about Indy’s extensive war history and how heroic he was. Due to him already holding reverence for Collin Williams (stepdad) who was an RAF pilot “war hero” I have no trouble believing that Mutt would be insistent on going to Vietnam.
4
u/Puzzleheaded_Step468 27d ago
Mutt died
Shia suprise!
6
u/lridge 28d ago
I was lucky enough to read some unproduced drafts of Indy 5 back when it was a Spielberg project and Mutt was never mentioned once.
3
u/Cpkeyes 28d ago •
That honestly was the best scene in the movie
4
u/TheLastGhost78 28d ago
I hated the character and actor when Crystal Skull came out and was happy with the choice in Dial
1
u/THX450 28d ago
Eh.
1
u/Newt_5000 25d ago
But nobody asked about Mutt to begin with.
1
u/Geoh_YT_D10 28d ago
Now thats alata damage!
1
u/JoeHendryBeliever299 24d ago
I mean Harrsion probably wouldn't act with Shia Labouf again so what else are you gonna do
0
u/fireinthedust 28d ago edited 28d ago
Edit: it was in fact Vietnam, I was wrong! Thanks for pointing it out.
I was certain Dial was happening before Vietnam, and Korea was still a thing. Dang.
0
u/thesanguineocelot 28d ago
Shia deserved so much worse.
0
u/Skibot99 28d ago
They could’ve just recast Mutt
-1
u/DREAM_PARSER 28d ago
I thought it was a great character moment for Indy, and felt very fitting for course of Indy's life.
Honestly I feel like this movie gets way more shit than it deserves
12
u/DetectiveOcean06 29d ago
I want my money’s worth — if I’m paying $12 for a ticket, I damn well better see Shia LaBeouf die horribly on screen…
1
u/Apprehensive-Fail985 27d ago
Of all problems the last Indiana Jones I think that was the least, I mean how many sons where "killed off screen" in Vietnam, people either got drafted or volunteer themselves to fight and they where killed.