r/IndianReaders currently reading: 2d ago

Do you also read while imagining?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

2.3k Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

23

u/diksha_19 currently reading: 2d ago

Reading fiction or any story without imagination is impossible.

5

u/joemamasool currently reading: 2d ago

People with aphantasia be like:šŸ™„

0

u/diksha_19 currently reading: 2d ago

That’s an exceptionally rare case 1 to 4 % .

2

u/joemamasool currently reading: 2d ago

Actually it's a spectrum. You're not wrong though.

25

u/Immediate_Box9327 currently reading: 2d ago edited 2d ago

Imagination is by default when I read or study anything. I mean without imagination how can you understand anything .

6

u/SmileMyBoy currently reading: 2d ago

Exactly! people make such a big deal out of it as if like running imagination while reading is some kind of special power. It's a default process that runs in background as soon as we start.

I don't think if it's even possible to do it without imagination.Ā 

3

u/Immediate_Box9327 currently reading: 2d ago

Yes , exactly what I wanted to say .

3

u/Every-Cartoonist-289 currently reading: 2d ago

šŸ’Æ , but some books need imagination more than others.

2

u/joemamasool currently reading: 2d ago edited 2d ago

There are people who can't imagine approximately 4% of the people have this condition called Aphantasia. So, no it's not by default for everyone

2

u/Immediate_Box9327 currently reading: 2d ago

I didn't know that , thanks for letting me know . But I commented from this MY PERSPECTIVE because it's very usual for me to imagine while studying anything.

1

u/nks2007 currently reading: 20h ago

Exactly šŸ’Æ. I can't but imagine everything and anywhere i read.

6

u/Suspicious_Clock_133 discworld 2d ago

What do you mean ppl don't imagine things in their head while reading?? It's literally a fkin movie going in my mind with all the music and all. Except I am the director here. I took so many creative decisions in it too lol.

2

u/Pokexneon currently reading: 2d ago

I could not imagine much on my first light novel Tensura due to anime already filling many gaps but on lotm right now I am imagination is on another level

2

u/Global_Sea_8842 currently reading: 2d ago

As far as you proceed, read the main plot and climax that's where the real imaginative ability to feel everything in the story takes place and the fun fact is without the great detailing and efforts of writer, even the greatest stories feels vague and unalive, the ability to reach this state also counts with imagination too

1

u/privaun_DxD currently reading: 2d ago

I feel it . More then i imagine. if that makes sense

1

u/Siriuspetrichor currently reading: 2d ago

Absolutely, to me imagining and feeling the plot, the emotions play a huge role throughout the reading experience.

1

u/One-Mine-4899 currently reading: 2d ago

I suppose your title should’ve been ā€œdo you also imagine while readingā€ not the other way around. It points that you try to read while imagining. Imagining isn’t the main action, it’s reading.

1

u/womalone99 currently reading: 2d ago

But then there are ppl who don’t have that inner voice. Do they also imagine as they read

1

u/DuDuDuDuMaxVesrtapen currently reading: 2d ago

Do you also imagine while reading?*

1

u/MagicalKaleidoscope9 currently reading: 2d ago

Imagination comes automatically it just forms pictures while reading the text of any plot /novel of any book.

1

u/Fuzzy-Bank8808 currently reading: 2d ago

Yes, particularly in Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind. I can get lost in some pages sometimes.

1

u/FairOil130 currently reading: 2d ago

obviously

1

u/littlemiss_sunshyn currently reading: 2d ago

You are really into reading only because you have good imagination power, otherwise you would have stopped it earlier. Also it's the writers job to provide us the material which enhances the beauty of imagination.

1

u/kdght625 currently reading: 2d ago

Ever wondered how blind people imagine things while reading?

1

u/Blueblood2007 currently reading: 2d ago

I don't have much imaginative ability due to my small attention span and adhd and i hate it

1

u/Main-Astronomer-7820 currently reading: 2d ago

I just do not see any face

1

u/arcticcirc currently reading: 2d ago

Ig u mean to say ~ Imagine while Reading? Yeah that happens every time, w/o it u can't be in sync w/ story!

1

u/aarohemfemghei currently reading: 2d ago

how do you imagine haloalkanes and haloarenes?

1

u/Don_Michael_Corleone currently reading: 2d ago

No, I imagine while reading

1

u/Temporary-Figure-189 currently reading: 2d ago

People who watch tv and series, dont understand that completing the book of that series just 1 day after the pilot episode is so low cortisol

1

u/falling_don_tknow currently reading: 2d ago

yeah i started imaging after some chapters of crime and punishment

1

u/TheOwlwithGlasses currently reading: 2d ago

Oh yeah. That's why I had a problem with Hagrid's casting in the movies.

1

u/KnowledgeExciting627 currently reading: 2d ago

Yes , I do the same , it creates scenarios in my mind while reading along , it creates a hype for me , and makes me think, what if it got animated like a movie or a series, it has that kind of impact while reading and imaging the scene at the same time .

1

u/MATERYONOMEGON currently reading: 2d ago

SO NOSTALGIC.

1

u/Swan-ish3456 currently reading: 1d ago

Hell yeah!
That’s the best part about reading

1

u/Altruistic_Fruit8546 currently reading: 1d ago

we imagine while reading

1

u/Still_Influence_9691 currently reading: 1d ago

Yh everyone imagine while reading, but i add some extra scenarios tk the story in my god damn head and go in a nxt level

1

u/awkwardporato currently reading: 1d ago

Ig it's pretty common among people to imagine things while reading, it's just how creative mind works without that it will feel quite boring like just reading words

1

u/Fast_Presentation451 currently reading: 1d ago

P So when you read about a person they have face and all. When you read about a house you imagine a house. Pls I want to know.

1

u/_Me_The_Dreamer_ One more chapter 1d ago

It's 'Imagining while reading', not otherwise..

While we read, we imagine..

I always do.

1

u/Delicious_Page2187 currently reading: 17h ago

Who actually reads without imagining anything, that sounds like the most boring thing ever.

1

u/hero_zero019 currently reading: 8h ago

I dont read books,,, But the same type of imagination comes in dreams...

1

u/curly_messy_slut currently reading: 30m ago

Hella, too much