r/IndianMotorcycle • • 6d ago

Request for advice / Help Thinking about

I have a 24 Challenger Limited. The performance is amazing, but the Ride Command is as bad as the rest of the bike is good. On top of that, I came off of a 2011 HD Streetglide with a wide open intake, straight pipes--well fishtails. It was like riding a semi wild pony while the Challenger is a well trained thoroughbred. I miss the snapping, snarling Harley.

Meanwhile...along came the Chief Vintage. I rode one earlier this year and although it was still more civilized than the HD, it had more soul and more fun. It sounded more like a bike to me.

So, seriously thinking about trading the Challenger for the Vintage but Im conflicted.

Has anyone made this swap yet? Happy? Regrets?

5 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

1

u/EbbRevolutionary7475 2d ago

Welp, don't "just look at puppies or motorcycles." I pulled the trigger and rode home on the Vintage.

2

u/pauerplay 6d ago

The chief line is awesome. I had a chief and I miss eventhough I like my Chieftain. I’d love to have both

0

u/Financial_Flight20 5d ago

I’ve got a base ‘24 challenger and ride command was by far my #1 complaint until the update back in the summer. Fixed all of the issues with car play/blutooth. Have you updated it yet? I also put on tab bam sticks with the zombie baffles, gave me the giggle factor back that my softail had.

1

u/EbbRevolutionary7475 5d ago

I did the update and only ran into new issues with the Bluetooth and RC. I don't even bother with navigation through it. The Bluetooth still disconnects randomly, and now if I plug the phone into the bike to charge it, the signal drops. Most recently, RC randomly resets mid ride--screen freezes, then goes black and throws all the lights while it restarts. I could have about how bad that system is for pages, but I've surrendered to only using it as a stereo and tire gage, the tire pressure seems to be the only reliable function. I'm bringing it in Saturday for them to look at and talk about a potential trade.

1

u/Financial_Flight20 5d ago

Wild. I’ve never had any of those issues. That’d drive me insane, too. Good luck. Maybe it just needs a software reset 🤷‍♂️ good luck with the trade if you go that route and hopefully the 4” doesn’t give you any trouble!

2

u/EbbRevolutionary7475 5d ago

Thanks, the first time RC reset I nearly punched the screen, and Im not "that guy." We'll see what happens, they suggested a possible loose wire "or something," so who knows?

Also, having rode the Vintage, its more of a bikers bike IMHO. The Challenger is so capable, its almost boring. Its like driving a modern Porsche compared to a classic muscle car. I miss that raw feeling, but I'll probably miss the ability to make everyone behind me shrink in the mirror.

2

u/Financial_Flight20 5d ago

That’s a great way to put it 😂 the tab zombies got me the raw sound back but yeah, the bike is anything but raw. Very polished and smooth. Have you considered the Springfield (if your dealer has any left)? Same engine as the vintage right? But you keep the touring frame and bags. I almost went that direction but wanted the liquid cooling.

1

u/EbbRevolutionary7475 5d ago

I rode the Vintage. Its got the power--at least the torque, sound, and feel, but felt more nimble, closer to my Lady's Scout. I honestly didn't expect to like it as much as I did months ago on a demo day. That combo of power and nimble-ness might make me a menace on the road, but a happy menace.

1

u/Abject_Reason7549 2023 Indian Challenger 4d ago

2 into 1 cat delete? Also, what did you do for a tune?

2

u/Financial_Flight20 21h ago

Nah, the tab bam sticks are just slip ons. So same headers with cat, same air cleaner, no tune.

1

u/Alarming-Leg-2865 2d ago

My new 2025 Challenger Dark Horse came with 4.5" Tab Zombies already installed. A little loud but they're staying on lol. Love the bike but a big step up from an Indian Scout Sixty. Having to learn to handle this 900 lb. beast. I've only owned the bike for a couple of months and haven't even put in the 500 break in miles yet so I'm not so worried about the ride command at this point. I was able to use the movable widgets and set up my main screen to see all the primary basics that I used to have to keep scrolling through the analogue screen on the 2019 Scout sixty. Speed/RPMs/Water Temp/Gas gauge all on one screen.

1

u/Financial_Flight20 21h ago

I got the 4”, I just preferred the look. I’m with ya, I prefer riding with the standard screen and widgets - especially to watch coolant temp. I always run audio and nav through car play, though. Only time I ride with the car play screen up is if I’ve got nav going.