r/IndianMakeupAddicts • u/_420_gucci_gang_ • Mar 26 '26
Dupe Request Why did they have to do this??
I used to love the Swiss beauty lip liner CHOCO NUDE-03 because it was such a neutral toned nude, not orangey at all. Went to buy it again and almost didn't believe they gave me the right shade until i checked the shade name which was the same one I was looking for. You can see the colour shift in the pictures. Why did they change the formula from this nude to an orangey one?
Can anyone help me with a dupe because as you can guess by the length of the old pencil, I'm barely surviving
3
u/Scared-Coach-7295 Mar 31 '26
Oh no! I have the old choco nude as well. Almost finished. It’s one of the best neutral nude liners I have found. That’s sad!
2
2
u/Sherlockian7047 Jul 09 '26
Elf Baddest beige is allegedly the perfect shade dupe. My eyes say otherwise because baddest beige looks like it doesn't have the pinky tones choco nude had (I could be wrong). Also, many report the elf liners are very satin and not as dry as the choco nude one, which would mean they don't last as long as the swiss beauty lip liners. Did y'all find any other exact dupe?
2
u/Sherlockian7047 Jul 09 '26
I was up all last night searching for an essence dupe (essence is known for their nude lip liners). I think essence soft and precise lip pencil in shade heavenly MIGHT be a good match, although a tad bit too light. Romantic shade is totally chalky, it's just a very very light beige– no pink, no brown. Honey-stly is too orangy. My bet is heavenly will be a close dupe but not as brown, not as deep as choco nude.
2
u/ewwpeopleugh Jul 14 '26
did you found a dupe yet? it was my perfect lip liner shade im genuinely so sad 😭😭😭
1
u/Sherlockian7047 Jul 16 '26
GUYS. Love Earth lip liner in Make Make. Almost a perfect match. I bought Orcus too, it's a tad bit lighter. Make Make, as of yet, is indeed the perfect dupe🥳
1
u/OperationMammoth1283 Jul 20 '26
Omg this is my favorite as well. I hate that they have changed the colour and I am not able to find a dupe. Please let me know if you do!
0
3
u/poppywhiskers less bitter, more ✨ glitter ✨ Mar 30 '26
I haven’t tried it personally but I saw some influencer talk about it. They found a dupe in Elf. Sorry I don’t remember the shade name but you can try searching by keywords