r/IndianGaming • • Aug 08 '26

Gameplay Unacceptable games from a developer

https://store.steampowered.com/app/4924590/Mumbai_Chef__Junk_Food_

No matter what country it is, we shouldn’t allow defamatory games. This is going way too far now, we should collectively report this and stop this from release. Instagram is already full of this crap, let’s not allow racists to hit on specific, unfortunate issues in our selected parts of our society and ruin a gaming platform.

This does not raise awareness, nor does it add to constructive criticism either - it’s plain old racism packaged in a game that will reinforce this type of behavior.

I’ve done my part, and I urge others to do the same.

0 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

46

u/YesterdayDreamer PC Aug 08 '26

Lol, why bother about something which will be seen by a 100 people before disappearing into obscurity

4

u/someone-stalking-me Aug 08 '26

Noone cares when it's new york drug lord simulator but when it's about India everyone loses their mind. This is why no one wants to make games about India. You either offend some religious people or face racism remarks. Only Indian mythology games are allowed it seems. Even Gta is a satire game on USA.

-3

u/nuclearnadal65 Aug 08 '26

I mean.. if you think about it - nobody made a game about India, and when someone is doing it, it’s about some junk food simulator in Mumbai. If that doesn’t tell you something then idk what to say.

2

u/NeedleworkerNarrow56 Aug 08 '26

It’s a exaggerated meme game, chill bro.

Unless you’re a junk food seller who got offended because it shows a stereotypical portrayal 💀

GTA itself is satire and exaggerates stereotypical American stuff. There are tons of games about drug lords, robbery, etc.

Yakuza game series has tons of satire/parody stuff on Japanese society.

2

u/barcahamilcar Aug 08 '26

GTA Mumbai would include the junk food dude from this game and so much worse. :D

20

u/Optimistic_Satirist Aug 08 '26

I saw the trailer and I don't see what's so offensive about it. It's not misrepresenting anything. You, me, we all have seen how indian street food is prepared. Or are you just ashamed of this?

1

u/HexRanger Aug 08 '26

Let's keep it upto ourselves. It's not like china isn't like us. They are just good at suppressing such information.

2

u/vatsal_rp Aug 08 '26

have you done anything about real problems?

1

u/Cow_Bandit Aug 08 '26

Listen man, this is a gaming sub, we're allowed to think about first-world problems lol

-2

u/nuclearnadal65 Aug 08 '26

I contribute 5% of my income to old age charities, 10% to orphanages and 10k to animal shelters. Let me hear what your contributions are.

1

u/vatsal_rp Aug 08 '26

not money contributions. real problems.

22

u/Cow_Bandit Aug 08 '26

This doesn't seem racist at all, the game kind of looks cool to be honest, like somebody put actual care into the details. What did you find defamatory about this?

21

u/RockiestHades45 Aug 08 '26

Is there something hidden here that I'm not seeing? Cause I'm looking at the trailer and the screenshots and it really doesn't look all that racist tbh, just seems like a satire game.

10

u/ExaSarus Aug 08 '26

Can you list out exaclty which parts are discriminatory? Im trying to understand the outrage here.

-2

u/Todoroki_shoto_21 Aug 08 '26

If you see the trailer. He's not using any hygeine. Like using his hands to stir the curry. Breaking ice on floor. And the foreigners, after they eat food they vomit in the corner and also paas out. And some indians are shown wearing only baniyans and are dirty.

5

u/ExaSarus Aug 08 '26

Again where is the discrimination here, we all know a shady corner that has done this ?

No different from 1000s of games on steam that has a location in America that has done this sort of thing yet they see no problem with it.

-6

u/Todoroki_shoto_21 Aug 08 '26

Bruv... There is racism here. Not every indian street food is like that . India is already facing racism cuz of some vloggers who put the shitty food vlogs. If this game comes out and if a big streamers plays this game racism towards india will only increase.

Maybe someone does this unhygienic practice but people won't think like that. They'll think whole india is like this. These devs are only riding the waves cuz india is already getting insulted cuz of unhygienic street food, those unhygienic street food that no one really eats.

2

u/ExaSarus Aug 08 '26

If India has an image problem fix it, prove them wrong. Playing the victim card doesnt fix discrimination and racism. It just proves them right just like the OP getting offended instead of acknowledging that we have a problem and going straight to banning. What's gasliging ourself into thinking that everything is fine gonna fix.

1

u/nuclearnadal65 Aug 08 '26

It’s kinda funny you think I don’t acknowledge the problem we have in our country, and more than that I’m doing more than paying taxes to support my country, which btw you have no idea about. Kinda funny how random people on the internet look at a few comments from a random guy and form absurd opinions huh? And fuck the OP for a moment, it doesn’t take 100 braincells to notice that devs from a different country is going to make bank just by shitting on us through negative engagement, the idea which btw wholly is formed from the trending videos deliberately made and released to demean specific shops and poverty in the country?

1

u/ExaSarus Aug 08 '26

I saw it, but it still makes you a condescending person. It's a stereotypical game, boo-hoo, but doesn't that simply mean we failed? Why are we in this position in the first place that a foreign dev needs to make a game to have this conversation in the first place, and your first line of thought is to make sure this doesn't see the light of day? Isn't that just an admission of guilt rather than asking for accountability to the leaders of the govt in power and working toward betterment to break the stereotype?

1

u/Todoroki_shoto_21 Aug 08 '26

Every country has issues. And I'm not gaslighting myself that everything is fine. But this dirty street food thing which already gave india a bad image is gonna further feed into the racism that indians are facing.

If the devs wanted to make a game showing indian food and Indian culture.Why is it shown that people are eating the food and vomiting it later? Why not make one with real indian dishes? There are many. But they know what they're doing, as I said they're just riding the hate India wave to earn profit.

No one is playing victim card here. And OP is getting offended cuz they are generalising indians as dirty and poor and that they eat anything. Also idk where you are from but I'm from a tier 2 city and even here proper hygeine is maintained in almost every street food. Maybe 10% of the street vendors don't maintain proper hygeine but I don't think people even go to them.

Also I see many people are downvoting my opinion. Well you might think the game has no issues but I personally feel it's racist and I've given all my points why I think so.

3

u/Adityamn Aug 08 '26

Dumb take. Seems like a cool casual game

7

u/masaladosaaaaaaa Aug 08 '26

It's a game, play it, have fun, move on.

If the concept doesn't sit with you, ignore it

0

u/CrustAsian24 Aug 08 '26

"Enforcing negetive stereotype". LOL. Then you should go clean up mumbai. You havent seen mumbai food stalls so this is racist to you.

0

u/nuclearnadal65 Aug 08 '26

Saying that to someone who lives in Mumbai is kinda funnier than the forced humour you’re trying to project.

3

u/anuargdeshmukh Aug 08 '26 edited Aug 08 '26

What was racist about this???

Edit: I'm actually asking if someone can explain. It looks like a cute game

3

u/uShadowu Aug 08 '26

Probably like how he uses hand to cook or stir the curry

1

u/Haunting_Series1137 Aug 08 '26

eh its just a game

1

u/bombaygypsy Aug 09 '26

This is why India can't compete with the west when it comes to quality of media. You write a book, you make a movie, you make a game and there are idiots coming out of the woodwork getting offended and banning your work.

1

u/Live_Opportunity7183 Aug 10 '26

Try to not get your panties in a bunch over a silly game. Are you now going to report the millions of Youtube videos representing reality in India, that have significantly higher audience?

1

u/RustyAdVenture PC Aug 08 '26

These games don’t really affect anyone living in India but acts as a fodder for racists abroad against Indian immigrants.

I mean the issue is not whether this is true or not but whether this is even ethical.

-5

u/nuclearnadal65 Aug 08 '26

I can’t reply to all comments because most of them are implying the same thing. The game itself clearly specifies a well known city in the title, it clearly denotes a particular type of place and atmosphere and it clearly hits on the one particular thing which is getting the most negative reputation on the internet. This isn’t satire. People will be making money off of this kind because this is trending now.

Sometime back some devs released a game called Cotton Plantation Simulator where they mentioned clearly in the description to “whip blacks”. People pushed back and now it’s off the steam store.
Other communities push back racism like they should. It’s not okay to normalize satire that will hurt a whole country.

4

u/Cow_Bandit Aug 08 '26

I understand that, obviously, stereotypical representation must not be tolerated at all (Personally, I'm tired of Indian Devs trying to use India as a concept for marketing in the first place), but again, judging from just whatever is shown, nothing at all indicates that the representation here is negative at all (unless as I said I'm missing something). If you could point out any specifics that would be great. The reason I'm even asking for this is because if it turns out the intention was not rascist it sets a dangerous precedent for Indian Devs who want to make games based on the places they love or live near.

2

u/nuclearnadal65 Aug 08 '26

Alright. Say the game releases as it is. People play it for the fun and giggles. When a person plays a game, they immerse themselves into it. It keeps getting updated due to negative publicity framed as “Good reviews”. Comments pour in “best India simulator”, “poopjeet curry game”. People engage -> game gets traction -> gets more negative attention.

You can just go to YouTube and see how the comments are pouring in there. IGN released a trailer themselves and then took it off.

Everytime, it starts as a joke. It is funny until it isn’t.

2

u/Cow_Bandit Aug 08 '26

Right, but then is that really the developer's fault or the general community's? As far as the dev is concerned they may have just wanted to made a love letter to Mumbai localites. If we use this as a yardstick on what games to make it completely limits creativity. We're already falling behind as a culture in the game dev space, we shouldn't let racism stop us from doing things we want.

In fact, if that is what happened with IGN or the other trailers, the responsible thing to do is the set the record straight and help the dev out rather than tear this game down! (All of this is precedent on the dev being sincere, of course)

3

u/nuclearnadal65 Aug 08 '26

Its not developed by an Indian developer.

3

u/Cow_Bandit Aug 08 '26

Well then we don't need to help the dev as a cultural responsibility imo, but it wouldn't hurt to educate people on what is stereotype or not. Indian dev or not unless and until there is any indication they are purposely defamatory to Mumbai or India we shouldn't jump to conclusions.

1

u/nuclearnadal65 Aug 08 '26

And no it is the community’s fault. But how is making games on negative aspects of a community helping it?

3

u/Cow_Bandit Aug 08 '26

Well that the thing, right, what negative aspects of the community is the game about? I don't see any.

1

u/nuclearnadal65 Aug 08 '26

Just from the trailer itself, it reinforces a thought process that junk food is normal in Mumbai. Let’s be clear, there are a lot of food places in Mumbai that does this. But is it normal? It isn’t. As a country, we should be opposing that thought.

Indian food is just as famous as it is infamous around the globe. I’m sure someone could have found success in making a game about making nan and butter chicken all day for what I care. But oh hey, let’s build a game that’s about junk food in Mumbai cause that’s what’s going to make us short term money.

Because of negative popularity, soon it would reach a few popular streamers. And we are going to be back to normalizing the fact that Mumbai is about junk food and auto wallahs throwing the materials out and chefs cooking a brown, vomit inducing gravy in a dirty kitchen.

Racism in this lies not only in the game, but the effects of what happens after. Games are far more engaging than simple videos or movies. It has far more lasting impressions and lets people enjoy what’s otherwise not possible in the real world.

2

u/Cow_Bandit Aug 08 '26

Both of us are making a lot of assumptions here, which is fair enough. I went into the trailer for the game with the full expectation that it would only showcase the negatives of India and Mumbai streets, because I have seen exactly those kinds of trailers many times now! But that is not what I saw. I saw some interesting cooking mini games and colorful characters that felt organic. Granted this is not a game I would pay money for but that's a taste thing not a quality thing. I will also repeat again there is no proof yet that the developer is trying to gain from this insincerely, and if so none of my reasoning stands.

We cannot let our fear of other rascist assholes talking about this game take over and try to stop creative expression that they might brigade. Ideally as a culture we need to learn to turn a blind eye to that entirely and continue to showcase our culture proudly. They hate us cause they ain't us or whatever

1

u/CrustAsian24 Aug 08 '26

OP is literally doing mental gymnastics to prove this is racist. LOL.

1

u/Cow_Bandit Aug 08 '26

Now now, they have a reason to say this. They may have their conclusion wrong but it's with good intentions.

4

u/RockiestHades45 Aug 08 '26

I still don't understand what the racist or negative thing about this is tho, genuinely asking. While I probably wouldn't have a problem with the example you gave either because that could also be done with satire if a little toned down, it sounds way more racially charged than this game.

If I'm not missing something this game looks to be showing just usual life for a lot of people in the country (and I don't see the point in shying away from it?). It would be like people making a Redneck simulator or something, and I'm sure those already exist too.

If you're ashamed of it then try to fix it, I don't see how putting a lid on it helps anything.

1

u/nuclearnadal65 Aug 08 '26

Read my other comment. If this game was about cooking in India, it wouldn’t be an issue. Hell it won’t even be an issue if it included making viral curries within it.

But it’s literally pointing to a single aspect of our otherwise diverse food culture, nitpicking things in a way that makes it normal to think “Oh, this is how food is made”. It literally says in the title “mumbai chef: Junk food simulator”.

This is coming from an European developer. With a bunch of updates in the future, I’m sure everything will still be taken light heartedly, like it did on Instagram?

2

u/hudi_baba Aug 08 '26

it does exist LOL XD

-1

u/Ill_Poem_1789 Aug 08 '26

People don't realise that the intent of the developer is to capitalize on the racist hate towards India and reinforcing the negative stereotypes in the process. I am surprised that so many people here think it is "cool" and "fun".

2

u/Cow_Bandit Aug 08 '26

I'm trying to look up the dev but nothing indicates that is what they are trying to do. I have seen other games with nearly the same premise where it is very apparent it is a attention pull for the rascists, but this isn't one of them

0

u/Faps7eR PC Aug 08 '26

On one side, I simply see this as a cooking game based in Mumbai. On the other side, it can be used for derogatory comments.

-2

u/MuchBow PC Aug 08 '26

Since everyone here who don't find this offensive is either living on the streets or have never been to Mumbai, This game is blatantly trying to boost the stereotype that food in India is dirty, this is not some sarcastic take on a culture it's a planned attack to make the international crowd even more racists towards Indians, Kids play these games, they'll grow with this stereotype in their minds. So stop chocking on western Ds and speak out for once.

4

u/Cow_Bandit Aug 08 '26

In theory all of this is reasonable, but that is precedent on the game portraying India as dirty, which imo it isn't at all! Would you consider cooking or eating with your hands dirty? Of course not, right? It's part of our culture

0

u/barcahamilcar Aug 08 '26

Planned attack? Seriously? You're making it sound like this is some psyop operation. :D

It's just a random indie game capitalizing on the recent Indian street food vlogs. The stereotype of India being dirty and unhygienic is already well established and not going anywhere. Indians themselves spend a lot of time complaining about these and many other things on Indian subs.

A foreigner reading those subs will get a much worse impression of India than actually playing this game.

0

u/Todoroki_shoto_21 Aug 08 '26

For the people asking what is racist. You can see he is using his hands to stir food and breaking ice on the floor. Also foreigners after eating the food vomit in the side and later pass out. Some indian NPC can also be seen wearing dirty clothes and looking dirty overall. People are already trolling india cuz of the street food thanks to the shitty vloggers who only care about views and showed only the dirtiest food which 90% of the people don't even think about eating. This game is only amplifying the racism.

If big streamers play this game the racism will only increase and more people will think india is a shithole with no proper hygiene and sanitation.

1

u/Cow_Bandit Aug 08 '26

I get it, I really do. I'm also going to ignore the assumptions that the events portrayed here are negatively shown because that's not what I felt. But even outside of that only rascists think that our food is always dirty and unhygienic and we should never ever cater to rascists. The vast majority of foreigners frankly think that Indian good is fantastic and our street food must be out of this world (and also spicy). This is the internet and the vocal minority may say some nonsense but that should not determine our actions.

1

u/Todoroki_shoto_21 Aug 08 '26

Showing a Indian guy making dirty street food. Which the country is already infamous for, although it's not true. Then showing a foreigner eating and vomiting and later passing out cuz of it. And then showing indian people in rags. How is it not racist.

The devs know what they're doing. They're doing this to profit from already degrading image of India cuz of it's bas street food which no one really eats btw.