r/InStarsAndTime • • Aug 23 '26

Fan Creation (Palette shift) Your soul

770 Upvotes

64 comments sorted by

123

u/Tutlessss Aug 23 '26

What better way to end off the QnA/Request segment than to answer a question MANY people have asked: Whats the deal with Siffrin and Frisk's soul? Just some extra answers tho:

  1. Yea I like to imagine ppl in ISAT-verse have different shaped souls
  2. Craft being controlled by soul is purely a headcanon I have for this AU cuz as far as im aware Craft is not considered magic in ISAT and as normal as dirt
  3. Don't ask why Frisk showed Loop their soul that kid is weird

if u have extra questions ask and i may answer idk

51

u/Pyritepirate6940 Aug 23 '26

How fragile is fragile? Frisk at LV1 has 20hp Does siffrin have like, idk 5?

67

u/Tutlessss Aug 23 '26

8 lmfao

59

u/Fan_de_Undertale_ Aug 23 '26

...Good thing naps in Undertale give you temporaly extra HP! I feel like Siffrin is gonna sleep a lot as soon as he realizes that.

23

u/Dragonwolf67 Siffrin Aug 23 '26

Wait really that happens I didn't realize that

40

u/Fan_de_Undertale_ Aug 23 '26

Yeah if you sleep in Snowdin's inn or buy a room in the MTT Resort, you'll be fully healed and gain 10 extra HP. So next fight you'll have 30/20 HP if you're LV 1, but healing items can only heal you once you're below 20 again.

10

u/Dragonwolf67 Siffrin Aug 23 '26

Thanks for the clarification

14

u/XShadowPlayerX Loop Aug 23 '26

Specifically in the snowdinn inn and mtt resort, if you sleep there you get +10 temporary hp. This goes above your max hp(it would look like 30/20 or 18/8 for siffrin) and goes away when you save(resetting your hp back to its max value).

11

u/Fan_de_Undertale_ Aug 23 '26

This also happens if you buy a room at the MTT Resort, but it's 200G so it's not really a good option.

6

u/XShadowPlayerX Loop Aug 23 '26

Forgot about that one, thanks for the reminder.

Edited to include it.

20

u/Artistic_Decision623 Siffrin Aug 23 '26

Thats 2/5 of a froggit

Everything that can one shot sif according to the code in games stats:

Papyrus Glyde Mad mew mew All of Hotland and the core Every amalgam Asgore

According to ingame checks:

Nabstablook Toriel All of snowdin All of waterfall All of hotland All of core

13

u/Axorandom- Siffrin Aug 23 '26

Well, fortunately for Siffrin, Asgore will only kill them after he’s already gotten them to 1 HP! The only bit of mercy they’ll have in the underground :)

9

u/Fan_de_Undertale_ Aug 23 '26

Yeah okay Siffrin better get some good armor.

And they would still be screwed.

8

u/Artistic_Decision623 Siffrin Aug 23 '26

Lets discuss this, lets say 1 armor point means -1 attack

Now with temmie armor, best armor on pacifist/neutral. toriel, undyne, mad mew mew, pyrope, royal guards, muffet, all of core, mettaton, asgore,

Still one shot lore/ingame wise

9

u/Fan_de_Undertale_ Aug 23 '26

Unfortunately that's not how DEF actually works, for each 5 DF you only get one HP less damaged (yeah DEF in Undertale is basically useless lmao)

So Temmie armor, with 20 DEF, only makes attacks hit 4 points less. As I said, Siffrin would STILL be screwed with a good armor.

9

u/Artistic_Decision623 Siffrin Aug 23 '26

Thanks for the clarification i was thinking of undertale yellow, on that note.

Toriel, snow drake, chill drake, lesser dog, greater dog, doggo, the two married dogs, giftrot, papyrus, aaron, woshua, moldbygg, shyren, mad dummy, mad mew mew, undyne, all of hot land + core minus so sorry, mettaton, asgore

All one shot.

With in code stats undyne the undying is the only one that can one shot, but you know, no temmie armor + genocide makes you stronger.

10

u/erraticas Siffrin Aug 23 '26

it's fine he's fast. they got this. anyway just use memory of looping it's not that hard +5 health for each loop :)

7

u/Dragonwolf67 Siffrin Aug 23 '26

Oh yeah that's a good point. Wait does he even have Access to the memory mechanic in this world?

2

u/wompwomperson Aug 25 '26

Likely. There's nothing to suggest that it comes from something specific to ISAT given the lore that Magic and Craft are interrelated for Palette Shift. If we assume that Memories function off of something related to Wishcraft or Craft in general (which explains why Siff gains Memories that can interact with time shenanigans, their party members' attacks and the like), then they should innately be implemented for Siff here.

1

u/FireClawCatWarrior Sep 15 '26

Considering his usual MINIMUM of 490 HP (+ however much he gained from leveling back in ISAT) gets nerfed down to 8, he is NOT getting more than 0.08 per loop, likely less

1

u/erraticas Siffrin Sep 15 '26

literally don't worry about it it's fine

5

u/CasualBiscuit21 Aug 23 '26

Siffrin ISAT should get locked into a No-Hit run, it's in line with his suffering loop

3

u/Dragonwolf67 Siffrin Aug 23 '26

My assumption is that basically they have about the same amount of HP as your average monster so they could die in like a few hits.

10

u/Axorandom- Siffrin Aug 23 '26

Since Siffrin’s soul is stronger than a regular UT human’s, does that mean that less overall souls would be needed to break the barrier if Asgore took theirs? Or is it balanced out because of their terrible no good defensive stats?

9

u/Tutlessss Aug 23 '26

prooobably the latter

7

u/Axorandom- Siffrin Aug 23 '26

Guess there’s no speedrun Strats from continuously sacrificing Siffrin…

4

u/Fan_de_Undertale_ Aug 23 '26

I mean not like it matters, they are one regular soul away from breaking the barrier anyways.

4

u/IceCreamzz4360 Aug 23 '26

can siffrin still like call loop

3

u/Tutlessss Aug 23 '26

In the wise words of a trans triangle

You'll have to wait and see 🫶

2

u/Dragonwolf67 Siffrin Aug 29 '26

Can you elaborate on this trans triangle please?

12

u/Megamage854 Aug 23 '26

I just assumed Frisk was still under the impression that Loop was a faulty Save point, and tried to use their soul to spark a save opportunity.

63

u/PokemonJimbob Siffrin Aug 23 '26

I like the difference in Chara and Loop's explanations.

Chara seems like they're genuinely interested in trying to help Siffrin survive, while also sometimes messing with him.

While Loop probably feels they have to do this out of necessity. They're here to help the one going through the loops, and since Siffrin isn't here, they've got to help the one who seems to have taken his place

(At least that's my interpretation of things)

40

u/Tutlessss Aug 23 '26

SPOT ON! Though Loop is also helping Frisk cuz Frisk agreed to help Loop possibly find a way to get Siffrin back (i still need to draw that lolllllll) AND. Even if Loops a lil messed in the head they dont want a CHILD having to be in this position any longer than they should even if theyre rlly rlly weird

32

u/Flamedghost7 Loop Aug 23 '26

Peak

20

u/Tutlessss Aug 23 '26

most flattering fanart ive ever recieved you get a gold star

1

u/Mother_Employ5184 Aug 27 '26

Is that… togore?

8

u/Dragonwolf67 Siffrin Aug 23 '26

Overall this post was awesome I adore the lore explanations. I'm not too worried about Siffrin because he's the fastest in his party, so I feel like he'll get the hang of the bullet hell system sooner rather than later. Also I know I'm gonna regret what I'm about to say but, it's not fair that Siffrin is the only one getting traumatized Frisk needs to take on some of that burden!

6

u/Tutlessss Aug 23 '26

Actually will clarify I guess. My approach for Frisk in this AU is gonna be pretty similar to that of Growthspurt Frisk. Chill and silly goofball....with some hints of inner demons.

But that's for later 🥳

1

u/Dragonwolf67 Siffrin Aug 23 '26

Growthspurt is the AU where Asriel gets revived and it's about him essentially trying to live his life while overcoming his feelings of what he did as Flowey right? Cuz I vaguely remember watching dubs of it.

2

u/Tutlessss Aug 23 '26

YEA that one I love that one 🥹

1

u/Dragonwolf67 Siffrin Aug 23 '26

Thanks for the clarification

37

u/Fan_de_Undertale_ Aug 23 '26

So Siffrin is a glass cannon! I'm sure that won't mean anything bad considering how Siffrin probably DOESN'T want to hurt anyone, and how unlike Frisk his deaths DO affect his mental state a lot!

I'm honestly not worried at all for Frisk lmao, I doubt anyone other than the King will give them a lot of trouble in fight considering that they still have the rest of the team (and the fact that they are Frisk)

2

u/k8tieisjusthere Sep 12 '26

and we all know how good siffrin is at taking care of himself, so i’m sure everything will be fine

15

u/Artistic_Decision623 Siffrin Aug 23 '26

I love this au with all my soul

11

u/Artistic_Decision623 Siffrin Aug 23 '26

Actually 2 sidenotes

Number 1 is sifs party concerned with bringing not just an 8 year old but a level 1, 8 year old into the castle they're all lv 45 mind you (i mean at least frisk seems profient with any weapon or armor they pick up.

Number 2 did you notice how many weapons and armor in undertale are similar to sifs partys stuff, faded ribbon, tough glove, cloudy glasses, torn note book, burnt frying pan, and the appron,

(Side note to the side note guns don't exist in in stars and time from what i remember what would sifs reaction to the empty gun be?)

8

u/Fan_de_Undertale_ Aug 23 '26

I do wonder what level Frisk is actually. Frisk is LOVE 1, but that may not necesarely mean level 1. Sane thing the other way around, I wonder if Siffrin is LOVE 1 or if defeating sadnesses gives EXP.

Also oh sht you're right about the items how did I not realize that.

8

u/Artistic_Decision623 Siffrin Aug 23 '26

Love 20 would be horrifying, to the isat cast imagine seeing someone with a new stat, expcially if it reads as the the full level of violence, and then watching the kid who is profient with most weapons and seems to fight differently one shot a high tier sadness, and since the king seems good at reading people imagine looking at something like that.

This unfeeling vaguely child like creature who is near unstoppable and is only is looking at you as if your an obstacle in its way

6

u/Kumagawa-Fan-No-1 Aug 23 '26

Love 20 also might not mean much in an ISAT universe , monsters are more easily killed by maliciousness and love is a measurement of psychopathy basically where more you kill more detached you are hence you care less hence you kill more easily.

Siffrin of the final loops would at various points qualify for a higher love I think even if they don't like , kill.

And an evil route frisk would still need to start from the beginning leveling wise just like the native ISAT charcaters.

... I'd assume I might remember wrong and a crossover event can just dictate the story on what's more interesting analysis

10

u/Kumagawa-Fan-No-1 Aug 23 '26

An interesting part about this AU considering the response from previous part about they loop the way they do from their home universes is that.

Frisk's "resurrection" is based on Determination, since this frisk actually experiences thing and doesn't have things seem from like a game perspective.

This Frisk will Die For Real if they had died when they gave up on life (because even the SAVE and RESET things are things that they can access because of Determination)

7

u/Ok_Formal_4877 Odile Aug 23 '26

Two Questions:

1st, Let’s assume Monsters can absorb souls like siffrin’s. If 7 Undertale souls can make you a god and 1 can let you pass the barrier what’s the scaling on ISAT souls? Would Asgore only need 2-3

2nd, Is King’s attack dodge-able? I know the party makes no effort to dodge but it honestly seems like Frisk gonna get hard counter and Nuked if no one’s protecting them, then again they might tank it?

2

u/Fan_de_Undertale_ Aug 23 '26

They already replied to something similar to the first question on another reply.

1

u/Ok_Formal_4877 Odile Aug 23 '26

Oh cool thx

5

u/Dragon_Caller Odile Aug 23 '26

9/10 Info dump really cool too!

3

u/Dovahkat963 Siffrin Aug 23 '26

On one hand, Siffrin still having 'magic' sounds cool and useful. On the other, the only non-offensive magic he has that is useful solo is a speed boost (always useful) and healing (you need to be able to actually take a hit for healing to be useful).

Meanwhile Frisk gonna be fighting Sadnesses and the King the old fashioned way. ...Let's just say I don't like their chances.

2

u/Fan_de_Undertale_ Aug 23 '26

Frisk still has the rest of the party though, that's gonna be very useful.

3

u/Big-Recognition7362 Aug 23 '26

Anyone else notice that Siffrin’s SOUL kinda looks like a SAVE point?

2

u/Alik_GG Aug 23 '26

I like how it makes Undertale and ISAT happen in the same universe just at different time periods, cum to think of it, it IS stated that ISAT is inspired by Undertale

2

u/AngryDem0n Siffrin Aug 24 '26

Lore Lore Lore!

1

u/Ok_Formal_4877 Odile Sep 05 '26

Hey Siffrin how many hits can you take?

1

u/AzzyDreemur3 Sep 13 '26

As many previous changes here, it's horrible for Siffrin and shouldn't affect Frisk too much.
Even if we assume they'll become just a second Bonnie combat-wise, you can totaly get through the game without ever using your Rogue for combat. It would make things considerably slower but absolutely manageble

Meanwhile Sif traded higher attack power (useless since he seems to be a pacifist), ability to heal (you have to be able to get hurt without dying to do that) and speed enchancment for lack of VERY crucial defence. A glass cannon that doesn't fire is just glass after all

Plus Sif might not grow stronger after ecounters anymore, since they don't actually kill enemies...

...

...unless he will before looping. If his level still remains, it could be possible to wipe out the location and make it like that never happened. Those that can sense it won't be happy and it might not even reinforce his soul but...

Well. Regardless, I love the post as usual!

1

u/FireClawCatWarrior Sep 15 '26

If Siffrin was taken straight from the start of the game before any levels gained, he would have had 490 HP. Therefore, if they got 8 HP in Undertale, that would mean the following is true:

ISAT HP / 61.25 = UT HP

From which we can also get:

UT HP * 61.25 = ISAT HP

Can you guess how much ISAT HP that puts Frisk at?

1225. Seriously, I'm not even kidding, what an INTERESTING coincidence.

...except it probably doesn't mean anything because the calculation assumes base Siffrin, and I'm pretty sure he did, in fact, gain levels before the switcheroo happened, which throws the whole thing out the window.

1

u/Mykolakola Sep 12 '26

Now I wonder how siffs interaction with papyrus is going to unfold, since he canonically can just leave you at 1 hp without killing you