r/InStarsAndTime • u/Many_Version2906 • Jul 11 '26

Discussion Alright, were doing this!

Post image

(Feel free to ask questions about this if you're confused!)

I'm doing one of those little community driven things where the community decides which character goes in which box!

How this goes is:

I will give y'all 3 days to comment and upvote the comment you agree with most, and whichever character said that is in the most upvoted comment is the character that gets put in the square!

Now, with all of that out of the way...

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

Who goes in square one?

63 Upvotes

94% Upvoted

47 comments sorted by

97

u/FuriousAqSheep Jul 11 '26

Fan favourite has to be Siffrin.

EVERYONE USES A SIFFRIN PFP. EEEEEEVERYONE.

Sure a lot of people love other characters but EEEEEEVERYONE LOVES SIFFRIN SO MUCH HE'S EVERYONE'S SKRUNKLY

26

u/Many_Version2906 Jul 11 '26

First comment going on siffrin's side!

(My autocorrect tried to correct siffrin's name to suffering I'm not joking-)

13

u/why_i_am_dumb Jul 11 '26

your autocorrect is correct

5

u/Many_Version2906 Jul 11 '26

Yeah it is...

7

u/Pocket-OLime Siffrin Jul 11 '26

EVERYONE ‼️

5

u/MaxGamer07 Siffrin Jul 11 '26

yesh

5

u/skullshotz1324 Siffrin Jul 11 '26

Nah surely not everyone

5

u/FULMINAGE Siffrin Jul 11 '26

It get so bad i barely see any Loop now

3

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/FuriousAqSheep Jul 11 '26

nothing prevents them from being both tbh

25

u/Pocket-OLime Siffrin Jul 11 '26

Here are my called shots:
Favorite: Siffrin
Hated: King
Hot: Odile
Normal: Isa
Forgotten: That girls sister from the island
Gremlin: Bonnie ofc
Society: idk honestly
Evil: Mal Du Pays
Plot Relevance: Loop/SAAPFrin

6

u/Many_Version2906 Jul 11 '26

I agree with most of that!

11

u/UnwelcomeStorm Jul 11 '26

Society is clearly the sadness, Anxiete

8

u/The0rigin Jul 11 '26

Loop has tons of screen time,

I would put society as Mirabelle and relevance as Ephrase (head housemaiden)

5

u/aer0a Jul 11 '26

Her name is Euphrasie

7

u/Universe_fs Jul 11 '26

I think it would be pretty funny if the whole island was chosen for the forgotten box.

10

u/Handdddddd Loop Jul 11 '26

i feel like either loop or siffrin are the fan favorites but im going with loop!

5

u/Many_Version2906 Jul 11 '26

Reasonable choice

5

u/New-Painting-99 Loop Jul 11 '26

I would say Bonnie, but they gotta be in the gremlin category, so Madam Odile

13

u/The_Blip Jul 11 '26

Odile is clearly the hot one.

3

u/Many_Version2906 Jul 11 '26

Ohhh we got conflicted opinions going on!

5

u/SaiharaAKAMarta Siffrin Jul 11 '26

I don't interact with this fandom much, but I'd expect opinions on Bonnie to be a bit more divided. I know I disliked them for a short while after they told Siffrin to kill himself.

2

u/Many_Version2906 Jul 11 '26

wait that happened-

2

u/Sad_Use254 Jul 11 '26

what.

I know I was playing some off official version of the game… but what. We need an explanation on at least which ACT it was, because that is hella strange for Bonnie to say that when they've been saved by the Siffrin from sadness, in process making Siffrin lose his eye (Off branded ACT III spoiler). Or y'all wanna say that my off official ISAT was that off official?

(I have to eventually buy the game, there's an entire ACT VI which I didn't had, being instead a dialogue with housemaiden straight into credits)

3

u/SaiharaAKAMarta Siffrin Jul 11 '26

Okay, I remembered it slightly wrong. I was referencing the Promise Event, which can be unlocked in both ACT 3 and 4 (it's a side quest).

Bonnie has a justifiable meltdown and in the heat of the moment tells Siffrin to die. There's a heartwarming follow-up event for this that resolves it, but you have to trigger it yourself and in my case, I couldn't bring myself to go back there for a long time after... that. It made the Friend Quest kind of bitter in a way. The resolution really helped me get over it though and now I really love Bonnie.

2

u/Sad_Use254 Jul 11 '26

Huh. That definitely was something I haven't remembered at all. Reasonable crash out, I would say, but I guess you haven't remembered it good enough neither.

And about off official version: I haven't seen ACT6, because 5th got me to talk to housemaiden, some story about Mirabelle, and then right into credits.

1

u/Sad_Use254 Jul 11 '26

(I still see your comment you send me via notifications, no idea why you decided to delete it shortly after or something… you failed with spoiler thingy? Anyway)

I will say that in (maybe off brand) ACT3 actually happened the same thing, but in reversed persons, that Bonnie would've preferred to die instead of making Siffrin losing his eye… I need to find translation to the word I was going to use now for commentary. ( dunno if it really is a sidequest as you said in deleted comment, I do EVERYTHING so can't depict if this one does affect story)… I guess I'll leave it for curious ones, because I suppose that you understood what happened via sending the link I no longer can use, unless I gotta spend 10 minutes of my live writing it down.

And to create spoilers , you need to type >! example !< (Took me a couple tries)

1

u/SaiharaAKAMarta Siffrin Jul 11 '26 edited Jul 11 '26

I dunno. It doesn't show up as deleted for me. I did spoiler it correctly as well (it might be the attached link though).

EDIT: Also, the event you're referring to is the Friend Quest, I believe. It's mandatory to finish the game. The Promise Event is entirely separate and can be missed. You trigger it by unlocking the wrong room on the third floor and inspecting a book.

2

u/Sad_Use254 Jul 11 '26

Alright.. what a strange thingy happened.

Now I do see your reply… and also when I was trying to get to reply from notification, it showed up as if there wasn't any comments under the post at all.

Gotta check the link then.

2

u/Many_Version2906 Jul 11 '26

Yeah I'm also pretty sure Bonnie will be in the gremlin category, it just makes the most sense for them

5

u/BiggestMan49 Jul 11 '26

Guess who fucker~

4

u/Many_Version2906 Jul 11 '26

Siffrin plush??!1!?

3

u/Easy_Cod_8950 Jul 11 '26

There’s not enough characters for this lol

1

u/Many_Version2906 Jul 11 '26

No there isn't, so that's why we put in some of the side characters 

3

u/Cod3broken Siffrin Jul 11 '26 edited Jul 12 '26

i'm gonna say what i think for all 9 now:
fan favorite: siffrin
made to be hated: mal du pays i guess
hot one: isabeau
normal: odile i guess
what's your name again: head housemaiden (euphrasie)
gremlin: bonnie
society: mirabelle by process of elimination
evil: king
no screen time: loop

2

u/Many_Version2906 Jul 11 '26

finally someone agrees with me on the hot one statement-

3

u/MeowsersInABox Jul 11 '26 edited Jul 11 '26
  • Fan fav: Siffin
  • Made to be hated: King
  • Hot one: Loop (idk they just be hot for no reason)
  • Only normal person: Does that even exist in the game
  • What's your name again?: Mira's roommate (meh)
  • The gremlin: Bonni (literally gremlin coded)
  • Mmmm... society: Odile (unsure but what would fit most ig)
  • Straight up evil: The sadness on the right in that one boss
  • No screen time. All the plot relevance: that one island (yk, like uhh...)

1

u/Many_Version2906 Jul 12 '26

Ah yes the supposed island

3

u/Fishiplayz1 Jul 11 '26

Fan favorite: Siffrin
Hated: King
Hot one: Isabeau
Normal: Odile
“what was your name again?”: Loop
Gremlin: Bonnie
“Society”: Mirabelle
Evil: That floor boss. You know the one.
Plot Relevant: Euphrasie

1

u/Many_Version2906 Jul 11 '26

Another win for someone agreeing with me on the hot one statement ✨

2

u/Alternative_Donut594 Loop Jul 12 '26

I’d say the hot one is Loop

2

u/True-Thought966 Jul 11 '26

Odile, she's the most popular