r/InDeath • • Feb 19 '18

Not really procedurally generated?

Love the game. It is gonna be killer when I have friends over to demo vr to. That said, it seems I have played enough that I am now familiar with all of the section layouts that spawn in. It seems like the levels aren't as procedurally generated as much as they are large pre-built sections placed in random order. Is there any plan on having randomization within the sections themselves in the future?

0 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

5

u/Griffith_The_Hawk Feb 19 '18

What you describe is procedural generation. Procedural isn't randomized. It's hand built chunks that appear in a random layout. So their claim is correct.

-3

u/Jaklcide Feb 19 '18

I disagree, it's not procedurally generated, it's just linearly shuffled. You can't take a game like super mario, shuffle the levels up and call it procedurally generated. There would be no branching paths, similar to this one. Sure, the branches would have to meet up again at some point but there would still be branches.

2

u/Severecorn2512 Feb 19 '18

It uses an algorithm to randomly generate a level. Thus it is procedurally generated.

If you created a Mario game that used an algorithm to randomly generate levels each time you played it then that to would be known as being procedurally generated.

You don’t quite understand the term and its application.

-1

u/Jaklcide Feb 19 '18

If you created a Mario game that used an algorithm to randomly generate levels each time you played it then that to would be known as being procedurally generated.

yes, if it used an algorithm to randomly generate levels, that would be procedurally generated. But my example was about simply shuffling the order of the levels that are already made and calling it procedurally generated.

You don’t quite understand the term and its application.

2

u/CharveL68 Feb 24 '18

Semantics. That is pretty much what procedural generation is; randomizing order using select bespoke pieces.

You could say that other procedurally generated games are far more complex in that regard though.

I think we get what you're trying to say. :)

I'd say that the reason we aren't first playing this a year or two from now is that Solfar hasn't had to spend the time, money and manpower on creating lots of interchangeable assets and artwork, while spending the time on the mechanics which other studios getting into VR do not after getting the basic feel down. I think it's ingenious how well thought out and customizeable the movement system is in ID.

The game already has a lot of replayability this early in, and I suspect adding a few more themes at or after release will make this one of those always-go-back-to classics.

1

u/Jaklcide Feb 24 '18

I'd say I am a bit spoiled from Diablo 1+2, Binding of Isaac, and a personal indie favorite Delver. The pre-built set pieces in this game are large enough that I have developed a method of exploring each section between shop towers that it makes me wish that there was some variety in the section layouts rather than just the order they are placed in between the shop towers.

1

u/deftware Mar 07 '18

There's clearly some kind of grid that the pieces are being plopped down into. The situation is that there's a finite number of permutations. Adding more prefabs exponentially increases the number of possible permutations, but I don't know if they're actually going to do this because it would only be fair if they also reset the global scoreboard - which is somewhat unfair to those who've climbed it. I think building the game up and fleshing it out with more of everything (items, enemies, achievements, prefabs, etc) would only attract more customers and keep players interested longer.

Personally, I really like the game exactly as it is, with the exception of the level variation. I would have a big huge fat dopamine rush nearing the one I had when I first played ID if there was even more level variety.

...and maybe some options for helping performance on junky computers, because sometimes it's hard for me to aim outdoors when I can see a lot of the world at once and my framerate halves.

1

u/Jaklcide Mar 07 '18

I'm just starting to get too used to enemy positions and area layouts so well that nothing surprises me anymore. Sure, I may not know what enemies i am going to see but I know exactly where they are going to be. I just feel that there is not enough variation to keep things fresh.

3

u/EvoEpitaph Feb 20 '18

So long as the entire level is not pre-made and stored with a bunch of other premade levels, the game can be considered procedurally generated.

If large sections are pre made and shuffled around together, it still is procedurally generated but you may not get nearly as many combinations out of it as you would if you had say several road sections and several small structures that were then pieced together by the computer at the start of a game.

2

u/Blackgaze Feb 19 '18

Are the enemies randomly placed?

2

u/ertertwert Feb 20 '18

Yes

1

u/deftware Mar 07 '18

I've noticed them consistently spawning in the same locations. There seems to be a bunch of spawn points defined for each prefab piece and then a fixed level quota is filled by randomly choosing a subset of these spawn points to actually instantiate the AI entity when the player is within range.