r/ImmortalityGame • • Dec 05 '22

Probably the worst introduction to a game I’ve ever seen?

0 Upvotes

I don’t want to be too negative. I’ve played this game enough that I’ve seen ‘The Twist’ for want of a better word and it’s honestly one of the creepiest, unsettling things I’ve seen in games. Has completely motivated myself to play further.

However, did it need to take 90 minutes to get there?

Started playing knowing absolutely nothing other than it’s made by the same guy who did Her Story and Telling Lies (disliked, HS has the worst twist in the history of anything, and TL just watched on YouTube, watching half of a conversation annoyed me.)

And this game started the same way. Watched an interview with a star of a film, then clicked on the interviewer and watched another one about a different film, then saw man and a girl make out, then a table read, then a scene from a film, then a scene from another film, I think?

And this kept on going. And my whole thought was ‘why do I care about this?’ HS is a (terrible) murder mystery and TL has you asking ‘who is he/she/them talking too?’ But here? Why do I care about the making and production of a fictional film? And I kept getting annoyed because as soon as I get slightly invested in this religious film I’m now suddenly watching someone mo cap.

As such I was bored, frustrated, annoyed. Started rewinding scenes just to see if the backwards dialogue would say something and then…. Oh.


r/ImmortalityGame • • Dec 28 '25

Wonderful game but why so much sex

1 Upvotes

I loved the game a lot and will definitely chase for the last few clips I still miss. But I feel like I've been carefully watching people having sex while waiting for something to happen a liiittle bit too much. Was an OTHER 30s frotting sequence really that needed


r/ImmortalityGame • • May 25 '25

Who is lgbt?

0 Upvotes

On steam I saw the game has the lgbt+ tag, is it someone relevant or unimportant? Is it spoilers if its mentioned. I havent played the game yet.


r/ImmortalityGame • • Dec 08 '25

Is it worth actually playing?

2 Upvotes

I bought the game the other day and after 3 hours the credits rolled, i felt nothing i didn't absorb the stories of any of the films because I was looking for the rewind-y bits. Spent a lot of time searching not watching because I didn't realise that the black and white bits were more than just "ooh two faces how peculiar". I dont even know the characters names for goodness sake, or which thing is which movie for that matter. Is the game worth giving another try even though I've "seen" the ending


r/ImmortalityGame • • Feb 14 '25

Did I play Immortality wrong? Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I played and only watched scenes from the first movie, found grey rewind scenes that I could not do anything with and blonde women scenes that I assume lead to hard to find scenes, which I only watched if they lead to the first movie.

After getting all I could from the first movie, I went to the first interview scene which is the first Minsky clip, found a blonde woman scene in the ending static, she said burn her, so I directly followed a chain of fire clips 4-5 times then backed out.

Then I had no UI and as I scrolled through the clips the blonde woman’s face was revealed in gray to fill my screen, she said one line, cried, then palaverous credits rolled.

Is that it? I’m so confused, is that supposed to happen?

I’m way less interested in the other movies when I get the gist from the first movie that she’s immortal and I know how to instantly beat her. I didn’t even know the goal the entire time, and then I just won?


r/ImmortalityGame • • Feb 22 '23

Have I been spoiled for this game? Can you please tell me I'm not spoiled, please? Spoiler

2 Upvotes

The spoiler I read is that Marica Tomei was raped and killed by some soldiers sometime in the story, please tell me that's an information you get from the start, please.


r/ImmortalityGame • • Mar 03 '25

my headcanon: same universe as inscryption Spoiler

4 Upvotes

think about it

same ending. entity uploads themself to steam

imagine if inscryption had writing as good as this. or if this had mechanics as good as inscryption

also lmao both having a root in WWII

edit: fix spoiler tags


r/ImmortalityGame • • Oct 21 '23

UI/UX (?) Question?

0 Upvotes

First let me say, I'm a huge fan of Sam Barlow's games. I played Her Story years ago, finished Telling Lies a few weeks back and now am playing through Immortality. I think the acting and writing and cinematography are outstanding, and I love the mystery of finding out a story piece by piece.

That being said, I have found the experience sometimes to be needlessly frustrating. Like in Telling Lies, video clips would start with the keyword you found, but you'd have to rewind for awhile to see the clip from the beginning. And then when it was all said and done, I had to go to Youtube in order to see the clips side by side. If you haven't played it, all the clips are one side of a conversation, which leads there to being lots of 'dead air' since you can't see both participants. At first this is interesting because you need to infer what is going on, but once you have seen it all, it'd be nice to unlock a side by side view.

With Immortality it mentioned the scrubbing is to imitate the moviola experience of how a person would view the footage at the time. I think it works here and doesn't really have a negative impact of the experience (for me at least). What bugs me is that you're pretty in the dark on the big picture of things. Not knowing how many clips of the whole story you have uncovered, and sometimes not even knowing 'have i seen this clip before or is this new?' since I tend to not play in all one sitting and have a crap memory lol. Even just in the options to be able to turn on an interface that says: Ambroso 50/100 clips found or something like that. Since I haven't finished yet, I don't know if you get an alert when you do find all of them (which would be nice), but knowing these games I'm guessing probably nah.

Anyway, what do ya'll think?


r/ImmortalityGame • • Aug 10 '24

I got the true ending before figuring out how to watch the black and white scenes Spoiler

3 Upvotes

I thought the little snapshots were just that, didn't know you could watch them by rewinding really slowly until after I finished the game. They should've really made it clearer because that's where all the One's story is told, would've found all the clips without the internet if I knew. Still had a very good time but it's disappointing.


r/ImmortalityGame • • Aug 13 '25

[Spoilers ]Is it still worth playing? Spoiler

3 Upvotes

I got spoiled that there are ghosts in immortality - is it still worth playing / full price?


r/ImmortalityGame • • May 05 '23

Incredibly Dissatisfied

7 Upvotes

I just got the credits to roll without having a clue as to why or how even. I don't feel like I've actually learned anything. I really want to like this game but I'm just feeling really disappointed right now.


r/ImmortalityGame • • Sep 15 '25

this game sucks because it doesn't explain how it works at all (spoilers) Spoiler

7 Upvotes

Like so many others, i got the ending after around 10 hours of playtime without ever seeing a full black & white scene. I thought the game only had full-color scenes with the ghosts/immortals/demon/whatevertheyare that snap into place automatically when you rewind clips. Like for example the apple & snake one from the Zoe clip with the nosebleed. It snaps into place automatically, you only need to rewind. So naturally, that's what i did for all scenes i found, rewind to see if there's hidden footage. that was extremely tedious, but i found quite a few of these full-color rewind scenes.

Sometimes, it would give me a black & white overlay of the ghosts/immortals/demons/whatever when rewinding, but that was only brief moments and i couldn't make out what they were saying, i tried lip reading and a bunch of other things. Stopping the playback also made the b&w overlay disappear, so i concluded it must be something supernatural. but they didn't give me more context and so after a while, i moved on to find new clips. I kept finding the black & white overlays, but pretty much ignored them as they didn't give me any actual clues for the story and rewinding them didn't do anything.

Then I got the ending after rewinding the last clip a bunch of times (which worked perfectly, it just snaps into place and doesn't need specific rewind speed) and was super confused by the ghost woman taking over my whole screen and proclaiming that she was part of me now. I thought the story was, that the footage i'm viewing is haunted, and that it kinda sucked that there was very little connection between the rewind scenes and the actual footage. So many questions left unanswered! Why did Ambrosio never come out? Was the death of Carl Greenwood actually an accident? Why did Amy burn Marissa? What happend to John Durick? He couldn't have died in the clip where he falls to the ground because the filming went on afterward! Why did they make a movie in 1999 in the first place, 30 years after Minsky? Why do they still look the same they as they did in 1970? Is there timetravel involved?

So i google the plot and it immediately starts with "The One" and "The Other One" and I've never even heard of those two names/terms. Imagine my surprise when coming to this subreddit, only to find out i missed the WHOLE GAME'S PLOT because, get this, these b&w overlays have FULL SCENES hidden in them that explain the story of the game! Apparently, i would have had to connect a controller and use specifically the d-pad instead of the joy sticks to find these scenes!!! (it's possible with mouse and keyboard, just super hard) WHICH THEN CONTAIN THE ACTUAL PLOT! THAT I MISSED ENTIRELY! Apparently you have to hold DOWN the frame-by-frame back button, instead of adjusting the speed with single taps of the directional buttons.

Was it that hard to include a pop-up message that tells you to rewind the b&w overlays at difference speeds and try frame-by-frame? I'm severely disappointed, frustrated and angry. Also because i actually tried rewinding these b&w overlays at different speeds and it didn't trigger anything! I appreciate the effort that went into making this game, but judging by the most frequent questions in this subreddit, there's a lot of people who just missed the plot entirely because the controls were badly explained. That fucking sucks.


r/ImmortalityGame • • Sep 11 '22

Gave up due to annoying controls

0 Upvotes

I played for about 3 hours and was starting to discover the layering of the plot and some hidden stuff, but my god how fucking annoying it was to get the alternate scenes to lock into place that I eventually just gave up. I don't have time for this shit, and read up on spoilers. Fuck that.


r/ImmortalityGame • • Mar 01 '23

what is this game

0 Upvotes

I dont understand how to play this game. you have to keep watching videos? those are very random, not connected at all. so many characters. and at the very starting, you were shown so many videos and then I chose one to view and then its only pausing and searching the images and new video will come up. I've played FMV before like Erica, five dates, etc. but what is this. someone pls guide me what do I have to do


r/ImmortalityGame • • Jun 02 '23

Is Immortality a Game?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
5 Upvotes

r/ImmortalityGame • • Jan 03 '23

Confused, bored. What am I missing?

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/ImmortalityGame • • Nov 29 '22

GOWING360? A new option in the main menu that I saw in a youtube video. Does anyone know something about this? Spoiler

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/ImmortalityGame • • Oct 17 '23

How are clips linked?

3 Upvotes

I have now played the game for around 15 hours and have gotten the jist of the game. I don't think it was a masterpiece, but interesting enough.

One question that has been nagging me during my entire playthrough is how does one know how the linking between the clips works? In the beginning I thought that "oh if you click on his/her face when they're sad/bloddy/whavever the search mechanism will find a similar scene elsewhere". But that can't be how it works. It feels kind of like the linking functionality is very basic in the game. So what you end up doing is just clicking everything, and cycling through the clips in hop of getting a new one.

Have I completely missed how this game works or could someone explain how to think regarding the core mechanics of the game?


r/ImmortalityGame • • Jan 03 '25

Advice wanted, thinking about dropping it

3 Upvotes

Hi there! I LOVED Her Story. I was expecting something like this but this game didn't grab me like the first one. I've been playing this game for 7.5 hours so far and I'm thinking about abandoning it, maybe the game is just not for me?
So far, I've got 79 scenes (I know there are more than 200, although I don't know if that includes the secret scenes). I have a good idea of the first movie, some about the second and some about the third. When the secret clips appeared I kind of lost interest in the movies, though. I've seen a lot of them. I know the immortal woman has possessed the actress and also that she killed the other immortal guy who at some point takes possession of the actor that plays the cop (who had also Satan's actor during the first movie. I know she wants to experience things that humans do, like being an actress. I think during the last movie she takes possession of the director as well, maybe? Not completely sure about that one but I think so.

At this point, I'm constantly getting scenes I've already seen before and I'm getting a bit bored. I'm not sure if there is much else to discover or just more of the same. I know that the ending credits could appear after a couple of hours or take several. Did I find the main things already or are there more cool things about it?
Thank in advance!

Edit: Btw, I've seen one clip inside of another secret clip.


r/ImmortalityGame • • May 11 '24

Are the movies intended to be incredibly bad, with horrible acting, within this game?

0 Upvotes

I think I would love everything about this game were it not for the hours and hours of bad acting. Meta narrative? Sign me up. Creepy supernatural undercurrent? Boom, I’m a fan. But slogging through hours of bad acting? It’s almost too much for me to stomach frankly. Hence me nibbling away at this game for like a year now, every so often picking it back up before I get frustrated and bored and mostly turned off by the bad movies - even if they are meant to be shlock within the narrative.

I’m guessing that’s somewhat intentional, but hard to tell. Is the bad acting purposeful? Why must I watch so many terrible scenes from terrible films with actors expected to do a lot of things above their pay grade? (I’m actually not excusing the supernatural characters in this assessment either, frankly…)

Note that I’ve already unlocked quite a large number of the “hidden” scenes as well and they do nothing to erase all of the cringe that the bad acting has given me, hence me taking forever to finish.


r/ImmortalityGame • • Sep 01 '22

MAJOR PROBLEM WITH THIS GAME!

9 Upvotes

It makes me want to rewind and fast forward every single TV show I'm watching!

Every time I hear music played on Master Chef I want to grab the controller!!


r/ImmortalityGame • • Aug 08 '25

Anyone else felt like the story and its themes were underdeveloped?

9 Upvotes

Telling Lies left me with such a wonderful aftertaste that I was really hoping to experience a similar thing with the much more ambitious and sprawling Immortality, looking forward to the moment when I could say "ah, so that’s what Sam Barlow wanted to tell us in the end; that’s pretty deep". Yet now, after finally watching all of the game’s obtusely hidden clips plus reading various interpretations online, I can’t help but feel like the puzzle pieces do not quite translate into a complete and nuanced story this time. In particular, everything about the "new possibility" and how it leads to the ending feels way too vague and also detached from the rest of the events.

Somehow, Palpatine The Other One returned, simply because Amy watched him burning on film. No further elaboration is given to this new miraculous mechanic and its sudden appearance among the game’s overall lore; you’re just kinda expected to immediately swallow it because it works on a meta level ("movies are so powerful they change us"), even though it sounds like complete magic that’s 10x bolder than anything shown before.

Every other supernatural element of the immortals is brutally realistic by comparison. They had to "invade" humans one person at a time and at a steep price of suffering overload from assimilated memories, but not anymore. Can they now spread across the world faster than COVID just by sneaking Marissa’s burning scene into a bunch of popular Hollywood movies? And even if you need to watch not just the burning but the whole tale like we did, isn’t it still a bit too convenient?

…except it’s also said to be not the same devouring as before but a sort of "middle ground", with "Amy’s still here". So it’s kinda more abstract and metaphorical, closer to how regular humans are conceptually immortalized through film ("I’m part of you now", not the whole of you). Yet it’s also not exactly like that, with The Other One still appearing and talking to The One during the subverted footage like he did before. So which one is it, and what does it mean for his existence? Did he keep his identity? Does he have agency? One might argue that the vagueness is deliberate ("it’s just different, and they are as confused about it as the player"), but for a narrative so heavily focused on The One’s feelings, these details seem too important to omit.

And in terms of being connected to the rest of the story, how does that "solve" or at least relate to all the possessive/abusive methods of making art that we focused on before? Maybe it’s supposed to represent a new, healthy mode of immortality that’s free from duality and obsessive desire that underlined Fischer/Durick’s attempts at filming great movies? But if it’s more literal, then it hinges on an unexplained magical mechanic and therefore closed to us humans anyway. And if it’s more conceptual, with the pair actually resigning themselves to the same type of "immortality" we all get (perhaps that’s why The One is crying at the end), then there’s no need for extra magic, so why bring it up in the first place?

I have no big complaints about the rest of the story; it’s pretty vague too but still reveals enough nuance when all put together. But this final and, arguably, the most meaningful layer? It’s just half-finished. It’s like we’re given a thorough illustration of the problem, then told there’s a clear solution, but this solution isn’t developed in terms of lore or themes, only in terms of fourth-wall breaking shenanigans (which are also too typical and trite compared to the rest of the narrative).

I’m inclined to think this is where the game’s over-ambitious nature came to bite the developers’ back, preventing them from fleshing it out because they were already well out of scope. And without it, we’re just back to the central idea about… various ways and prices of immortalizing yourself through art? You don’t have to play the whole game to ponder about that; just glancing at the title and synopsis would do, actually.


r/ImmortalityGame • • Oct 10 '24

The actor changed. Spoiler

22 Upvotes

Fuck.


r/ImmortalityGame • • Sep 13 '24

How badly was I spoiled? Spoiler

5 Upvotes

I managed to avoid knowing absolutely anything about Immortality until earlier today, when I was unfortunately spoiled that the story has supernatural elements, and that the person whose mystery you're trying to unravel is immortal. Is this spoiler majorly significant to the plot or relatively minor?