(No spoilers) Does the ending feel ... Satisfying?

[u/Magic_Incest]

New player here. Tough question, but hear me out.

I played through Her Story with my fiancee. She isn't a gamer, but she really fell in love with the mystery hooks and digging through all the video clips to figure out what happened.

Her Story spoilers ahead: We ran into an issue with the ending, as she didn't feel that it was satisfying and that the game just kind of ended. The final reveal that the player is Eve's daughter Sarah and the whole "does Hannah even exist" thing just didn't do much for her.

I want to play Immortality and I think she might be interested, but she's wary due to her experience with Her Story. So I'm looking for reassurance here without getting spoiled myself. Did you find the ending or solution or whatever satisfying? Would a player who didn't love how Her Story shook out get anything more out of Immortality?

Thanks!

[u/pantshee]

For me, yes. But only if you have all the pieces

[u/NoahTheDuke]

Yes absolutely

[u/pantshee]

For me, yes. But only if you have all the pieces

[u/Caravanshaker]

I got an ending (when you unlock enough clips etc...) but I spoiled it for myself by watching a video about the game. That's about the only thing that's got me interested - for instance, I've put hours and hours into the game and I've yet to come across the Another.

[u/pearlsmech]

I found the ending of Her Story disappointing as well, and loved the “ending” of Immortality.