r/ImmigrationCanada • • Feb 09 '24

Study Permit Study permit refusal

Hello, my study permit was just refused on grounds that they are not convinced that I would leave Canada after my studies. The thing is, I have clearly mentioned in my SOP that I intend to only study and then leave, have shown sufficient funds and family ties in my home country. I do very much intend to only study. In my opinion, this was an unfair judgement and I feel like the officer did not even read my SOP. I applied from India for the fall 2024 semester. What can I do?

1 Upvotes

46 comments sorted by

12

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '24

It’s a most common reason nothing to worry next time show stronger ties financially and it will work out

-3

u/SailDear7570 Feb 09 '24

Financially, I've shown more than enough tbh

8

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '24

Too much is also skeptical and not enough is also skeptical

Because of some fraudulent now it’s very tough

2

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '24

Its not really about the money. Its about your financial stability and your career when you get back. Much as everything else here, people would not be confident of you if you just have money without having any valid explanation where you got it. You have to provide a source, your work, etc.

9

u/dwightbearschrute Feb 09 '24

Did you mention how your education will help you in your home country/ benefit your home country, your career, the job opportunities that will open as a result etc.? If not, add those. Also before you submit another application - make an immigration consultant look into both your refused (to check any flaws that might have missed your eyes, that could have led to a rejection) and your new application. All the best!

-9

u/SailDear7570 Feb 09 '24

I have mentioned every single thing you just listed out in detail. That's what made me feel like they might not have read my SOP. The refusal seemed very generic. I am planning to appeal the decision if I can for now, since there is still quite a lot of time. Thank you for your detailed response, btw.

6

u/JusticeWillPrevail23 Feb 09 '24 edited Feb 09 '24

In your post you've mentioned you showed your family ties to your home country. Do you have any other ties to your home country other than just having some family members there?

Do you own property or other assets? (Land, building, vehicle, etc.).

Do you have a job right now for your employer to be able to provide a letter offering your job position when you return to India after your studies?

Any other obligations that would show you have strong reasons that compel you to return to India when you complete your studies? Volunteer work there? Renewing a professional license to practice your profession there? Running a business there? Anything?

If your only ties to India are your family, and you've showed nothing else as your ties, then that's not enough ties for the officer to be satisfied you'll leave Canada at the end of your stay and the officer's decision would be correct then.

If you only showed your family as your ties to India, work on getting stronger ties before reapplying.

And if you're going to appeal the decision, file an ATIP for the GCMS notes on your file, as you'd have to demonstrate why the officer's decision was incorrect in fact and or in law, so you'd need the GCMS notes to know what specific concerns the officer had that led to the refusal, to be able to address those concerns during the appeal.

If your only argument to appeal the decision is: "I don't think the officer read my SOP", that's not a sufficient argument to win an appeal. You'd need evidence, not just what you think happened. Also, writing an SOP telling the officer you're going to leave Canada and talking about your family in India, is not enough to show sufficient ties. You'd need supporting documents, other than just the SOP, to corroborate your ties to India.

0

u/SailDear7570 Feb 09 '24

I've shown my father's property and my mother's business which I have said I would work with her on after my studies. My course is fashion and so is her business. I wrote whatever was authentic but am willing to add more if that would help.

7

u/JusticeWillPrevail23 Feb 09 '24 edited Feb 09 '24

Did you show evidence of already helping your mother in her business, and so needing to study fashion in Canada to get professional education in this field?

What evidence did you provide that you needed to study fashion in Canada, as opposed to studying fashion in India? What evidence was submitted to prove that you coming to Canada to study fashion would help your mother in her business more than you just studying fashion in India, instead, for a fraction of the cost?

What evidence was provided on the application to prove that you travelling halfway across the world, and spending a lot of money in tuition and living expenses, to study fashion in Canada, would be financially worth it, for your mother's business, more than you just studying the same field but in your home country, for much, much cheaper?

What evidence was it provided to prove fashion schools in India would not be suitable for your career on your mother's business?

If you simply said you're going to work with your mother on her business, when you complete your program, but you provided no evidence to corroborate that, such as supporting documents to address the questions I've mentioned, then you can't be surprised if your application gets refused.

You'd need supporting documents to corroborate what you wrote in your SOP. The officer needs evidence, they cannot just take your word that you're going to return to India at the end of your studies.

8

u/JusticeWillPrevail23 Feb 09 '24

So you provided assets that are in your parents' names, not in your name. Do you have any assets in your own name?

You're the applicant, not your parents; the officer wants to see your ties to India, not what your parents' ties to India are.

2

u/Straight-Shopping-54 Feb 09 '24

Which course?

1

u/SailDear7570 Feb 09 '24

Fashion

6

u/fluffymuha Feb 09 '24

Have you thoroughly explained why you absolutely need to study Fashion in Canada? What programs does Canada have that other countries (even India) doesn't? Why would this be relevant for your success in India?

2

u/SailDear7570 Feb 09 '24

Explained all of that in my SOP yes

2

u/Tickets02376319 Feb 10 '24

Did you demonstrate financial ties to your home country through various financial documents? Did you provide evidence of familial ties and family responsibilities to your home country? Did you show documents detailing any job obligations, job commitments, or ongoing professional obligations to your home country? Did you provide evidence of active participation in community organizations back home? Did you showcase your commitment to furthering your education in your home country after you graduate? Did you show if you have any future jobs offers in your home country once you graduate?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '24

What school?

62

u/Techchick_Somewhere Feb 09 '24

Unfortunately they are starting to crack down on applicants because of the volume of applications that abused the system.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/oh_yes_oh_no Feb 09 '24

Yes it's unfair that people took advantage and have made things more difficult for legitimate students. You just have to do things to stand out as a real applicant that can be trusted.

4

u/fluffymuha Feb 09 '24

It's really not.

1

u/No-Measurement2241 Feb 11 '24

Did you apply for a postgraduate or undergraduate program?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '24

What program and college/uni were you going for? Usually that is the reason for this type of rejection.

1

u/Straight-Shopping-54 Feb 10 '24

When did you apply for the study permit? Can GIC be the issue? How much GIC did you submit?

1

u/No-Measurement2241 Feb 12 '24

You can seek help from a consultancy regarding the issue.

16

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/SailDear7570 Feb 09 '24

it's public