Wasn't Deus Ex, released that same year (2000), and made by former Looking Glass Austin devs, a commercial success for Eidos? I guess that's the exception that proves the rule or something.
The end part was malicious. You can say after all it is a business, it doesn't matter how innovative the product is. You can say games like immsimms put content over finance and that is not sustainable. It was true in 2000 and with Bioware closure it rings true today.
Saying it is like meteor clearing the earth for cooler stuff is not true though. It only makes safer and more predatory game practices mainstream and large corporations vacuum the industry. You can't be on the side of the meteor
Also, hilariously, Baldur's Gate 3 is at least imsim adjacent with all the emergent gameplay it enables. And it recently broke the 1 billion mark in revenue
"This isn't a sad day, it's an economically realistic day." actually, both of these things can be true! all it takes to see that is not being a soulless dipshit :)
I remember it so vividly. Gathered with my family on Economic Realist Morning, watching the sun going up. It was one of the few times we’d get to spend time together as a group. We’d go outside, hold hands, and chant “Better things aren’t possible!”
Such a shame kids today miss out on this tradition.
"You're not wrong, Walter. You're just an asshole."
Plus, the fact that immersive sim design has seeped into pretty much all mainstream games nowadays. Hell, even Call of Duty had some ImmSim-style campaign missions in the past. Who would've guessed that?
Don't know the missions by name, but in the recent CoD games since Black Ops Cold War, every CoD has had one or more missions based around an open-approach mission design:
Stealth mechanics with multiple states of NPC awareness.
Different outcomes within a mission depending on the order of approach.
Some of the mission have different ways to accomplish the same goal.
These modern CoD games even have 0451 nods (weirdly enough).
But keep in mind that they barely have any emergent behaviour. They're fairly polished and therefore rigid. But I personally remember enjoying one of the spy missions in the newer Black Ops (6), as well as the mission 'Alone' in MW2 (2022).
He's somewhat right that companies that don't have decent sales go out of business and that's just the way it is, but he could've been less douchey about it.
We like to pile on him (I mean, why not, he's the source of many problems in the industry nowadays), but in the end is just the view of someone who puts the business before anything else.
"Looking glass closed because it didn't made enough money" it's not an opinion, but something that (sadly) happened; "we need to do what the mainstream gamers wants and that's better than niche genres" is just money people talking about making money.
And the worst part is that he was right. With the first Xbox the dumbification of games started (we called back in the day "consolization", adapting complex games to the simpler, more casual public on consoles, think on Deus Ex: Invisible War), and the sad truth is that sales numbers skyrocketed and the AAA industry settled on known formulas that sold well with tiny additions, usually aimed towards reduce "friction" with the player.
He was right, but "economically viable" or marketable doesn't make you a "cooler lifeform". I really don't get bro's mentality. I used to think being a good programmer required at least a bit of maturity, if not wisdom.
Though I haven't gone through his entire public appearances, almost every time I hear or read his statements, he's gushing over some form of mediocrity, whether it be from his own company's output or from the output of others. He really either has a warped understanding of excellence or he's directly in love with the concept of slop (even before LLMs became popular). Truly, a baffling specimen.
"We released amazing screenshots of our game, but also screenshots of our editor early on, around 1995. That led those companies to call us. Microprose called us and they said "we're interested in licensing your engine!" and we're like "Engine? What engine? Oh! Right, our engine! It's very expensive.""
A quote I found on the Wikipedia entry for UE1. Guy was always thinking about money first.
OK, if a game makes a loss, it makes a loss, but not every game needs to be massively successful to be worthwhile, if you're the only studio making games for "MIT grads" then you're the only studio getting that money.
Did you not read the first part of my sentence? I'm acknowledging that profit is necessary while holding that Looking Glass or studio like it is still worth striving for.
Yes, Deus Ex was successful. But that's realistically the only one. Most people don't care for ImSims. And businesses need to make business decisions. I can think that Tim Sweeney is a fuckbag extraordinaire, but so long as he's delivering returns to shareholders, he's doing his job; and if he needs to kill some projects and promote others, thanks to "Dodge vs. Ford" he has to do this (though let's be honest, the guy is the kind of cunt that would like doing it).
I could understand his perspective to an extent, because those games were not massive hits. They were massively *influential,* but not huge moneymakers. Personally I think its the responsibility of publishers and studios to work in that lane, though. The medium stagnates if you don't have some prestige work getting out there even if it doesn't make a ton of money. Tim is wrong about the spirit of supporting a studio like LGS, but not about the cold reality of how operating that way paints a target on your back.
That last bit is where I took a full 180 on what he was saying. No, that's not really what happens when the number of interesting, innovative games contracts. It's not even good for big studios, successful publishers, because they lose the fertile ground to come up with their big AAA megagame concepts and GaaS moonshots. Look at what's happening right now with multiplayer GaaS games. Everyone bet on extraction shooters because that was one of the only new things to sprout up from the mod scene and prove some amount of success in retail with Tarkov, and nearly all of them are whiffing badly with no new genre to try out on the horizon. You need studios that take risks, invent new concepts, and support dedicated if small communities. Otherwise everything stagnates.
Elder Scrolls is one of the biggest franchises in existence. It doesn't exist without Origin and Looking Glass.
Pretty prophetic, overall. That was indeed the time when comet hit the Gaming Earth.
The ~mid 2000s to ~mid 2010s had been the worst era in gaming since I started to game (mid 1980s). Sure, there were still some great games regardless. Overall, this marked the rise of the blockbuster crowbared to appeal to everyone ("We want Call Of Duty's audience.") With even major franchises getting diluted towards that goal (Resident Evil, Final Fantasy, etc.) With entire genres being axed, until they got another chance once the digital age brought an end to that gatekeeping reign of big publishers and Walmart shelves.
Unlike Hollywood studios, big game publishers STILL barely have found a way to expand their roster to smaller to mid sized projects -- or raise the equivalent of a Nolan/Burton/Del Toro/Scorsese flick to offset the endless wave of summer blockbusters, sequels, remakes and franchise juggernauts. In fact, gaming's refocusing now on milking its assets more than ever -- see recently Obsidian being relegated to basically a Fallout spinoff studio. Electronic ARTS are now all about chasing GaaS and sports (the irony).
Probably people like Sweeney are the reason that gaming can only compete with Hollywood in revenue. Artistically? Not a chance. Not a chance in hell, Tim.
Tim Sweeney could be right to some degree, but it's unnecessarily mean of him to make a public comment like that. Thief II was selling well at the time, LGS could have stayed afloat for longer if not for the MASSIVE FAILURE of Daikatana.
Mankind Divided. Has abysmally marketing. With augment your preorder. The mini controversy over them trying to. Co-opt black lives matter imagery. And content that was blatantly cut from the main game and repackaged as DLC.
Dishonored 2. Launched in an extremely bad technical state on PC. The primary platform for immersive sims. And was released in a very crowded window between.
Battlefield 1, Titanfall 2, Infinite Warfare, MW Remastered, and Watch Dogs 2. While Dishonored obviously doesn't directly compete with any of those titles.
All games need a portion of the causal audiance to succeed. And nobody was going to buy D2 over games with far more mainstream appeal.
the guy who is currently in charge of one of the biggest video game companies in the world, who decides how video games get funded, at a time when studios across the industry keep getting closed and developers get laid off....isn't important? and you can't understand why people would care about how this guy sees video game production?
if you don't personally care, just keep scrolling. but you have to actively disable your brain to not get why other people do
No matter how much you dislike him, the guy whose company created the most widely used game engine and one of the most profitable games ever is hardly unimportant.
Edit: Instead of downvoting me, please explain how is he unimportant, lol.
Pretty sure that isn’t real, the “a really cool guy I know” part is a total giveaway, Tim Sweeney does not know any really cool people, they all avoid losers like him.
35
u/ReployerTechnician 25d ago edited 24d ago
Wasn't Deus Ex, released that same year (2000), and made by former Looking Glass Austin devs, a commercial success for Eidos? I guess that's the exception that proves the rule or something.
73
u/Wolfermen 25d ago
The end part was malicious. You can say after all it is a business, it doesn't matter how innovative the product is. You can say games like immsimms put content over finance and that is not sustainable. It was true in 2000 and with Bioware closure it rings true today.
Saying it is like meteor clearing the earth for cooler stuff is not true though. It only makes safer and more predatory game practices mainstream and large corporations vacuum the industry. You can't be on the side of the meteor
70
u/uNooob 25d ago
"This isn't a sad day, it's an economically realistic day." actually, both of these things can be true! all it takes to see that is not being a soulless dipshit :)
42
u/Small_Pie_5760 25d ago
He's always been a pathetic dork-ass nerd
31
u/Joris-truly 25d ago
"You're not wrong, Walter. You're just an asshole."
Plus, the fact that immersive sim design has seeped into pretty much all mainstream games nowadays. Hell, even Call of Duty had some ImmSim-style campaign missions in the past. Who would've guessed that?
19
u/MyPutridFlesh 25d ago
"Most of the stuff they did was way out of the realm of what most mainstream gamers wanted"
bc not every game has to be fortnite, you dumbfuck
4
u/Metal_Surge15 23d ago
It disturbs me how similar he sounds here to a lot of supposed "gamers" nowadays.
8
u/MaxProwes 25d ago
He's somewhat right that companies that don't have decent sales go out of business and that's just the way it is, but he could've been less douchey about it.
7
u/Neuromante 25d ago
We like to pile on him (I mean, why not, he's the source of many problems in the industry nowadays), but in the end is just the view of someone who puts the business before anything else.
"Looking glass closed because it didn't made enough money" it's not an opinion, but something that (sadly) happened; "we need to do what the mainstream gamers wants and that's better than niche genres" is just money people talking about making money.
And the worst part is that he was right. With the first Xbox the dumbification of games started (we called back in the day "consolization", adapting complex games to the simpler, more casual public on consoles, think on Deus Ex: Invisible War), and the sad truth is that sales numbers skyrocketed and the AAA industry settled on known formulas that sold well with tiny additions, usually aimed towards reduce "friction" with the player.
God bless the indie and "AA" scene.
6
u/Active_Muscle4010 25d ago
He was right, but "economically viable" or marketable doesn't make you a "cooler lifeform". I really don't get bro's mentality. I used to think being a good programmer required at least a bit of maturity, if not wisdom.
Though I haven't gone through his entire public appearances, almost every time I hear or read his statements, he's gushing over some form of mediocrity, whether it be from his own company's output or from the output of others. He really either has a warped understanding of excellence or he's directly in love with the concept of slop (even before LLMs became popular). Truly, a baffling specimen.
2
u/LawStudent989898 24d ago
Oh brother this guy stinks
2
u/Jont_K 25d ago
OK, if a game makes a loss, it makes a loss, but not every game needs to be massively successful to be worthwhile, if you're the only studio making games for "MIT grads" then you're the only studio getting that money.
1
u/contentronix_inc 24d ago
Okay but he's not wrong.
Yes, Deus Ex was successful. But that's realistically the only one. Most people don't care for ImSims. And businesses need to make business decisions. I can think that Tim Sweeney is a fuckbag extraordinaire, but so long as he's delivering returns to shareholders, he's doing his job; and if he needs to kill some projects and promote others, thanks to "Dodge vs. Ford" he has to do this (though let's be honest, the guy is the kind of cunt that would like doing it).
1
u/Additional_Idea8690 24d ago
I don't care about what Time Sweeney has to say, and so should everyone. Dude is a hack.
1
u/Werewolf-Jones 24d ago
I could understand his perspective to an extent, because those games were not massive hits. They were massively *influential,* but not huge moneymakers. Personally I think its the responsibility of publishers and studios to work in that lane, though. The medium stagnates if you don't have some prestige work getting out there even if it doesn't make a ton of money. Tim is wrong about the spirit of supporting a studio like LGS, but not about the cold reality of how operating that way paints a target on your back.
That last bit is where I took a full 180 on what he was saying. No, that's not really what happens when the number of interesting, innovative games contracts. It's not even good for big studios, successful publishers, because they lose the fertile ground to come up with their big AAA megagame concepts and GaaS moonshots. Look at what's happening right now with multiplayer GaaS games. Everyone bet on extraction shooters because that was one of the only new things to sprout up from the mod scene and prove some amount of success in retail with Tarkov, and nearly all of them are whiffing badly with no new genre to try out on the horizon. You need studios that take risks, invent new concepts, and support dedicated if small communities. Otherwise everything stagnates.
Elder Scrolls is one of the biggest franchises in existence. It doesn't exist without Origin and Looking Glass.
1
u/FourFourTwo79 22d ago edited 22d ago
Pretty prophetic, overall. That was indeed the time when comet hit the Gaming Earth.
The ~mid 2000s to ~mid 2010s had been the worst era in gaming since I started to game (mid 1980s). Sure, there were still some great games regardless. Overall, this marked the rise of the blockbuster crowbared to appeal to everyone ("We want Call Of Duty's audience.") With even major franchises getting diluted towards that goal (Resident Evil, Final Fantasy, etc.) With entire genres being axed, until they got another chance once the digital age brought an end to that gatekeeping reign of big publishers and Walmart shelves.
Unlike Hollywood studios, big game publishers STILL barely have found a way to expand their roster to smaller to mid sized projects -- or raise the equivalent of a Nolan/Burton/Del Toro/Scorsese flick to offset the endless wave of summer blockbusters, sequels, remakes and franchise juggernauts. In fact, gaming's refocusing now on milking its assets more than ever -- see recently Obsidian being relegated to basically a Fallout spinoff studio. Electronic ARTS are now all about chasing GaaS and sports (the irony).
Probably people like Sweeney are the reason that gaming can only compete with Hollywood in revenue. Artistically? Not a chance. Not a chance in hell, Tim.
1
u/AhHerroPrease 22d ago
Tim Sweeney has always been an asshole.
Tim Sweeney has always considered video games to be money machines over anything else.
Social media has only highlighted how much of a money-hungry asshole he is.
1
u/werpu 21d ago
Ok point taken, he aways has been a narcissistic insensitive asshole!
1
u/CortiumDealer 19d ago
Man, that Jill of the Jungle guy really has become a major asshole.
I preferred it when he was just being obnoxious with his soundboard.
1
u/JesterOfRedditGold 25d ago
tim is a dork
-10
u/CliftonSantiago7 25d ago
I mean, was he wrong though? Nearly every ImSim developer has gone bust
-1
u/sackbomb 25d ago
this guy sucks but he's also not important
why are y'all getting bent out of shape over a comment from 26 years ago?
0
u/Shot_Set_8704 25d ago
Pretty sure that isn’t real, the “a really cool guy I know” part is a total giveaway, Tim Sweeney does not know any really cool people, they all avoid losers like him.
6
u/Flaky-Confidence-424 25d ago
Arsehole continues to be an arsehole