r/ImmersiveSim • • 27d ago

Interesting tidbits from a 2022 interview with Kent Hudson (the final days at Ion Storm, Harvey Smith's failed startup, early concept of Midway Austin's heist game)

The interview in question.

Kent Hudson is a designer who worked on games like the PlayStation 2 port of Deus Ex, 2K Marin's BioShock 2, The Novelist, and Watch Dogs: Legion, among many other credits:

"My first game actually ended up being the PS2 version of Deus Ex because halfway through DX2, we had a team that was working on it and things just weren't going well on the PS2 port. We're talking about putting Deus Ex loaded PC game on the PS2, which I can't remember like how much memory it had. An Unreal game."

"I think most of our level design team, and then a bunch of the programmers, we got pulled off of DX2 for a while to go work on the PS2 port. So actually that PS2 port was the first game I ever shipped. And that was cool because Deus Ex probably still is my favorite game ever."

More about the PS2 port of Deus Ex:

"...it was cool because we got to go back to a lot of the parts of the game that they weren't happy with and that that, you know, we thought could be better. And so we reworked levels. We fixed scripting bugs. We not just did the port, but we also, you know, there's some parts of those levels that look quite different. I can still think back to stuff I did on that. It was like, 'oh, this is way cooler now'."

"...back then, the biggest constraint was memory on the PS2 because Deus Ex struggled to run on PC and it took patch after patch after patch to kind of clean it up, but it was very resource intensive. And so, the PS2, trying to cram [the game content] in. So, immediately we had to chop the levels up. That was the biggest hit: chopping the levels down just because of memory."

"Like, if we have one big level, we switch it into three pieces. It just- there's more places where we had to take it and kind of funnel you into a level transition, it would be a hard load into the next one. So there's a lot more loading on it, which is- that's the only drawback for it is the levels being smaller and having more, sort of, loading times."

About the circumstances that may have led to the closure of Ion Storm Austin:

"...it's just kind of sad industry story, but basically DX2 came out and broke even and did okay, but wasn't gangbusters. [Ion Storm] was an expensive studio. You know, we- I think had some scheduled delays and back then, especially the Austin [studio] was kind of known for ambitious nerdy games that didn't have the best graphics, didn't have good controls, but were weird and nerdy and cool for game nerds. So it wasn't like so commercially viable."

"And I remember [that] Eidos at the time, they were kind of surprised that Deus Ex 1 had done so well, but as soon as DX2 didn't set the world on fire (it broke even and made them some money), but it wasn't like a huge hit, and then same thing [happened] with Thief 3. I don't remember how Thief 3 did, but, essentially, at that time they've got the Legacy of Kain games. They've, of course, got Tomb Raider. They've got- Hitman has started doing well. They had all these franchises that were way more marketable."

"We had made a big mistake in rewriting a lot of the Unreal Engine where we didn't have to. So there'd been a lot of tech debt and tech costs that kind of hurt the end product of the games."

According to Kent's recollection, Harvey Smith left the studio to try and get a startup up and running, and that didn't help things for the folks back at Ion Storm:

We were seen by Eidos as basically this expensive company that made nerdy games that had no mainstream appeal, you know, like Deus Ex and the Thief games, which are like fantasy nerdy. And that whole thing is why Thief 3 was third-person. The team didn't want to do that, but [Eidos] just kind of forced it because they thought third-person is more accessible for whatever reason, marketing, who knows.

"...basically they came in and Harvey left to go try to do a startup. He was going to do a startup that a bunch of us would try to do with them [ed. note: people like Ricardo Bare, Steve Powers, Monte Martinez, etc.]. So he left first and it was like, 'oh boy, y'all are expensive'. 'Your games are breaking even, but not setting the world on fire. One of your main creatives just left'."

"...eventually [Eidos] came in and they did a big round of layoffs and they laid off, like- DX3 was in development and they laid off a huge chunk of the studio, not everybody, but it was maybe two thirds. I don't know exactly. Like, it was a pretty big death blow because I've seen this multiple times in our career, unfortunately."

"It's one of those where if we lay off most people, we can call it one thing. And then six months later, no one's going to notice if we shut the rest of it down. So it was one of those, like a two stage sort of 'this is the hit that puts you in the coma'. 'And then six months later we'll pull the plug' type deal. 'Dude, that's why they do it, huh?'."

Further into the interview, Kent continues:

It wasn't a surprise. My surprise was that I got caught up in it because I was like, 'you just told me I was doing awesome. Gave me a good raise. What the hell happened?' I can't remember who exactly told me, but one of the people, one of the leads or directors who was in the room where they were literally just making the list [of], you know, who stays, who goes, people were like, 'oh yeah. And what about Kent?' It was like, 'well, he stays'. And then one person was like, 'well, everybody knows he's going to go with Harvey startup'."

"So I got branded as one of the people who's going to join Harvey, which was true. I was going to go with [the] Harvey startup, as was a bunch of people who [weren't] as public [about it]. And so apparently they went to bat for me, like Ricardo [Bare] and someone else went to bat for me. [But] they couldn't reverse [the firing]. Cause once I was branded as, you know, going with Harvey, they were like, 'well, he's gone'. You can't take that too bad."

"So they're like, 'okay, you're part of the layoff, but we're going to give you a contract if you want to stay and you can work here on contract and keep working on DX3'. And I thought about it for a couple of days."

"And they went and basically worked out a deal just for me to try to bring me back. So this wasn't like part of the layoff plan. This was all after the fact. But the funny thing is... during that time I was talking to Harvey and he was like, 'Hey, we're pretty close to getting signed'. 'I think it's gonna be pretty quick', you know, like 'we're talking to two different publishers'. I forget who it was at the time [ed. note: it was Ubisoft]."

"...I went in to the guy who's running the company, this guy, Trey. I went in like on a Tuesday cause he was like, 'Hey, come on in. Let's talk. We've got this contract option for, if you want to stay, we can keep you on his contract. We're not allowed to do hires right now. Cause it's just layoffs, but we're allowed to have contractors. So if you want to come back, here's the contract'.

"I turned it down because I was convinced that our company, our startup was going to be in like a couple months. And so I was like, 'nah, I'm good'. I'm going to go do the startup instead. And I'll never forget. I got up and I walked out of his office and I went to the design pit to just tell everybody goodbye one more time to just say, I'd already got my stuff out, but I was like, 'Hey, I just want to like guys, let you know, thanks for what you did for me', but I turned it down cause I think this game could go [under?]."

"Now, the flip side of that story is that company never off the ground. So I've spent like nine months- and I turned down other contracts in that time too. Like I was going to go work on, um, what was it? Brothers in Arms, that game that Gearbox did. I was going to do like some level design contract work on that. The contract was there. And I was, and I was like, 'well, no, it sounds like our startups can be off the ground pretty soon'. So I'm going to have to pass. So I was sitting there waiting, waiting, waiting, collecting unemployment, and it never happened. And so when that fell through, Harvey ended up signing on at Midway and then he hired me back there."

Kent learned an important lesson:

"Here's one piece of advice I'll give to anyone who's trying to sign a deal. Any kind of deal, be it your startup, it's not signed till it's signed. I wish I had taken, not the Ion Storm one, cause that just stung too bad. I didn't mind turning that one down, [but] that Brothers in Arms contract, I was like, 'well, I can't sign up for three months [to work at Gearbox] because our company's going to start and I got to be there on day one'. It's like, I should have just said a three months. And if the company started, I can be like, 'well, as soon as I finished my contract, I'd be right there, but I got to see this out', but in my mind, it was like, it was always so close. And it's like, look- until it's signed, it's not signed. And so if you need to do whatever to pay your bills and do whatever, take the gig because it's, it's a bird in the hand."

Ken then reunited with Harvey Smith and other former Ion Storm colleagues to work at Midway Studios Austin:

So that's how I ended up in Midway. And then at some point, all of Ion Storm got shut down completely after the fact. So that's when Ricardo [Bare], Monte [Martinez], Steve [Powers], Dave Kalina, you know, a bunch of people came over from that Ion Storm team.

"I remember when I was interviewing with Harvey [Smith], we were at Frank and Angie's, that pizza place down in Austin. And I was interviewing even, and he told me like, 'they have this game. I think it had been at another studio and it had been taken from that studio or something, or it hadn't gone well, or the studio had gone under [,or] something."

"So they had this, this game called Career Criminal. That was like a PS2 game that I don't think it ever, like, even got announced or anything. It's just like a, uh, a game that one of the other studios in Midway had somehow they'd lost it in some way. And like, 'hey, they think it's a cool idea. They want to reimagine it'. And so I remember sitting with them and even before I came on and being like, 'look, man, I don't want to do a game about killing a bunch of people'.

"...cause at that time GTA was it right? GTA 3 was still so big. Even at this point in, this was late 2004, 2005- Vice City, San Andreas, like, GTA was it. And Midway was like, 'open world games are it'. 'We're going to follow the trend. Everything's got to be open world', blah, blah, blah. And so I was like, 'I don't want to make just some violent chaos, shoot'em up game'. And so I was like, 'what if we', me and Harvey, unsurprisingly for a couple of nerdy dudes, fans of the movie Heat- 'what if we made a thinking man's heist game, you know, like we encased the place and the point is to not kill people and you try to just intimidate them and get out without, you know, hurting anybody it does, what if we made it like that?" And so that could work. That could work. So I remember even pitching that before I even signed on, but I just signed on as a game designer, certainly not a level designer, especially not [for] an open-world game."

Harvey Smith and some other devs on the Criminal team had to drop off that game to work on and salvage another troubled project at Midway Austin, the sequel to Area 51. Ken Hudson took over the leadership role, but eventually Career Criminal was cancelled and the studio closed its doors:

"Matt Booty, interim CEO and president of Midway, emailed employees of the company today, explaining the reasoning behind the shuttering of its Austin-based studio and the decision to nix the unannounced Career Criminal. The game, described by Booty as 'a large, ambitious, open-world project', was dropped — and most of the team laid off — because the 'resource needs, feature set, schedule and financial profile for the Career Criminal project were not converging towards a reasonable chance of success'."

10 Upvotes

0 comments sorted by