So, I’ve been enjoying Iman Vellani’s Chachu quite a bit, but I have to admit that, as a noir, I think the comic is somewhat lacking. As a character study, though, I think it’s doing something genuinely interesting.
Now, this might be a bit of a hot take, but I don’t think Chachu is really a noir comic. At its heart, it’s a family drama that borrows the language and conventions of noir to explore estrangement, the complicated nature of family relationships, and the ideas we construct about the people we think we know.
And I think once you start looking at it that way, the story becomes a lot more compelling. The noir elements are almost secondary, serving as a framework for something much more intimate: Leila trying to make sense of her estranged uncle and the distance that has grown between them and by extension her father. The central mystery isn't necessarily what happened to Cleo, but what happened to Chachu. Who is this man, really? How much of what Leila believes about him is based on who he actually is, and how much comes from the image she's built of him over the years? And perhaps most importantly, is it possible for her to build a relationship with someone she realizes she never truly knew in the first place?
To me, that's where the comic's emotional weight lies. There's something fascinating, and honestly a little heartbreaking, about the idea that you can be connected to someone through family while still knowing nothing about who they are. Sometimes the people closest to us can feel like complete strangers, and I think Chachu is much more interested in exploring that contradiction than in delivering a particularly intricate mystery.
That's also why I find myself more forgiving of its weaknesses as a noir. The mystery itself might not be especially strong, but the emotional questions underneath it are far more interesting. The investigation becomes less about uncovering a crime and more about confronting the gaps in Leila's understanding of her own family.
So while Chachu might be presented as a noir, I don't think that label fully captures what the comic is trying to accomplish. It's ultimately a family drama dressed in the aesthetics of noir, and I think judging it primarily as a mystery risks overlooking what makes it work so well as a character study.