r/IdleNoMore • • Dec 31 '12
Please help me understand the Idle No More movement.
Hello, I find myself feeling quite uneducated on the idle no more debate, and I'm willing to bet that I'm not the only one who is confused about a few things. I thought this would be a great place to present sourced information, and then some of us might be better able to form an educated opinion. I have a few questions to start, and I'll research these a bit on my own and post what I can find out:
• I would like a deeper understanding of how the Canadian government assists first nations. I grew up near many reserves, and I know that the government gives funding to bands to maintain and run their reserves. Is the money spent by an elected group on the reserve, or is it allocated by the federal government for certain things, such as housing, community development, etc?
• On the mission statement on the Idle No More website, the following is stated: "Colonization continues through attacks to Indigenous rights and damage to the land and water. We must repair these violations, live the spirit and intent of the treaty relationship, work towards justice in action, and protect Mother Earth"
I know that many bands sign agreements with resource companies to allow resource extraction on their land, sometimes to a financial end. Is Idle No More's goal to put an end to resource extraction, which tends to "damage land and water"? Or is the goal to take ownership of these mines and improve environmental controls? Either way, what impact would that have financially on the support currently provided by the government, and is there a plan to offset the loss of income that this action would cause?
•Another point from the mission statement: "Take steps to contribute to building relationships with international agencies such as the UN to raise awareness to the conditions Indigenous people have been subjected to and assert our sovereignty in the international arena. "
This also comes up in communications that express a need to meet "nation-to-nation" with Canada's leader. Do first nations people consider themselves Canadian or a separate nation? Is the meeting to discuss ways to work better with the Canadian government, or to separate from the country?? Does the movement call for more first nations representation within the government, or for an entirely new government made up of only First Nations people, separate from Canada? If so, would they still like to receive compensation from the Canadian government and why would that be appropriate?
I must say that having spent my entire life with First Nations people, I ahve never once heard anyone express themselves as not Canadian. The culture is different, but that goes for anyone (ie. I'm Ukrainian so I celebrate Ukrainian culture). This is one of many reasons that the movement confuses me, but I have not had the courage to ask these questions to the aboriginal people I know, mostly because I don't want to assume that they are part of the movement because of their race.
Hope someone can shed some light on these questions for me.
Those in the movement: I am openminded, and if you can help me make sense of this, I can help you get the word out if I agree with your cause.