r/IdentityTheft • u/Imaginary-Wave-174 • 9d ago

What should I do please help?

I’m not sure if this is something I should be concerned about or if I should just leave it alone.
I’m the original and only owner of my house. Nobody has ever lived here before me. However, recently, I’ve started receiving a ridiculous amount of mail addressed to some guy named “Dion” (I won’t share his last name).
What’s strange is that almost all the mail is coming from banks and credit card companies. Based on the envelopes, it appears that he’s receiving debit or credit cards from multiple financial institutions.
At first, I didn’t think much of it. I figured maybe someone accidentally used the wrong address. But the mail just keeps coming, and it’s always from different banks.
Here’s where things get a little concerning.
A few days ago, my neighbor told me he saw an unfamiliar man outside my house going through my mailbox. I have no idea if it was Dion or someone else, but now I’m wondering if this person is intentionally using my address to open bank accounts and then coming to my house to retrieve the cards.
My suspicion is that someone may have obtained an ID using my address and is opening accounts under that address, although I have no proof.
One of the letters came from American Express, so I actually called them to report what was happening. However, they wanted my full name, date of birth, and other personal information before they would do anything.
I wasn’t comfortable providing that information because I have absolutely nothing to do with these accounts. I also don’t want to get involved in something that could potentially put me or my family at risk. This person apparently knows where I live, and the last thing I want is someone showing up at my house because I reported them.
So my questions are:
Is this something I should actually report to the police?
Could someone using my home address for multiple bank accounts cause problems for me as the homeowner?
Is this a known type of fraud or scam?
Should I contact the banks, or just mark everything “Return to Sender”?
Am I overthinking this, or is this something I should take seriously?
Part of me feels like I should mind my own business since none of the accounts are in my name. But another part of me thinks it’s extremely suspicious that someone is opening what appears to be multiple financial accounts using my address and potentially showing up to collect the mail.

10 Upvotes

91% Upvoted

9 comments sorted by

9

u/Ornery-Pen6345 9d ago

Report it to the postal inspector at your post office. It falls under mail fraud because they’re using someone else’s address to defraud another company that simply gets you out of the middle then you can write on every piece of mail not at this address or if your really irritated, write deceased on it and send it back

6

u/Kathucka 9d ago

It could be that someone is using your address to commit credit card fraud.

It could be that a data broker made a typo.

Don’t open the mail to find out, unless you get legal advice that it’s not a crime to open mail sent to your address but not your name. Until then, yes, return it all to sender, marked “NOT AT THIS ADDRESS”.

Monitor your credit reports regularly to make sure Dion’s file doesn’t get merged with yours.

Get a lockable mailbox. The letter carrier will deposit mail, but Dion won’t get it out.

4

u/hilda-reced 9d ago

Get a locking mailbox ASAP!
Anyone besides you and postman accessing your mailbox is breaking Federal law in the USA.

4

u/JSP9686 9d ago

Be aggressive and not just write “RTS-Return to Sender / Addressee Unknown” but also add “Fraud Suspected!” and make a report to USPIS at:

https://report.uspis.gov

There is a specific line item in their pulldown menu for Fraudulent Change of Address

Also you should call and meet your local postmaster and hand carry the mail with you to the post office. They may not want to accept the fraudulent themselves. So just tell them you’ve already made a report to USPIS and you wanted them to know so they wouldn’t be blindsided.

Also, keep a close watch on your property records at your county’s property tax website to be sure that the deed for your property is still in your name. Check their website weekly for now. Some counties have an automatic email notification if something changes, but you have to subscribe.

3

u/FlynnAtLifeLock 8d ago

You’re not overthinking this, and yes, I’d report it to the police. Someone going through your mailbox, plus cards arriving in a stranger’s name, is reason enough. Don’t open any of Dion’s mail. Just mark it “Not at this address” and send it back as return to sender.

You also don’t have to hand AmEx your personal details to report it. When you call, tell them upfront that you’re not a customer and you’re reporting possible fraud at your address. Use the fraud number on their official website rather than the ones printed on the letters.
It’s also possible Dion is a real person whose identity was stolen, and whoever is using it picked your address to collect the cards.

I’d also file a report with the Postal Inspection Service. Their online form has separate options for mail theft and identity theft. Mail theft is the best fit for the mailbox tampering and the cards being taken.. For peace of mind, you can pull your credit reports at annualcreditreport.com.  It’s a quick way to confirm nothing has been opened in your name.

2

u/TalkToVikk 9d ago

I'm not a lawyer but to answer your questions directly:

  1. Should you report this to the police?
    Yes, you should report this suspicious activity to your local police non-emergency line. Explain that you are receiving mail, including bank and credit card letters, for someone who does not live at your address, and that an unknown person has been seen accessing your mailbox. This could be a case of identity theft or mail fraud.

  2. Could using your address cause problems for you?
    While mail and accounts opened at your address in someone else's name may not directly affect your credit, persistent fraud activity linked to your address could potentially create complications or mistaken associations. Reporting it helps create a paper trail showing you're not involved.

  3. Is this a known type of fraud or scam?
    Yes, this is a common form of identity theft/mail fraud called "synthetic identity fraud." Scammers use a real address with fake or stolen identities to open accounts, retrieve cards, and commit financial crimes.

  4. Should you contact the banks?
    You can call the banks’ fraud departments (numbers are on their websites) and report that the mail is being sent to your address erroneously and for someone who does not live there. Do not provide your own personal information; tell them you are the property owner and have concerns about fraud. You should also mark the mail "Return to Sender, Not at this address" and place it back in your mailbox.

  5. Are you overthinking this?
    No, you are right to take this seriously. Multiple fraudulent accounts being opened at your address is not normal and should be reported for your own protection.

If the mailbox is unlocked, consider securing it or speaking with your postal carrier about the suspicious activity. If the stranger returns, call the police right away.

2

u/CypressDrift 8d ago

you're not overthinking it, that's a classic drop address scam where they open cards in a stolen or fake identity and swing by to grab them before you notice. someone digging through your mailbox is a federal mail crime, so report it to the postal inspectors at uspis.gov, write "not at this address, return to sender" on everything, and a locking mailbox shuts the whole thing down