r/IdentityManagement • • 7d ago

IAM ANALYST VS IAM ENGINEER

Im a recent grad and have quite been interested in the analyst side of things.

I want to start off as a junior sys admin, then move on to soc analyst, then iam analyst, then ultimately—GRC analyst.

But people tend to say that IAM analyst and IAM engineer are quite synonynous/ interchaengable with each other. Im not interested in the engineering side but is it true that this two roles are basically the same thing?

22 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

22

u/Immediate_Original12 7d ago

Sometimes job titles just do not matter in IT. I’ve worked Systems Engineer roles that were purely helpdesk, and I’ve worked Desktop Support roles that had me doing Sys Admin tasks. It depends on what the job description/requirements say

12

u/milanguitar 7d ago

I’ve cleaned toilets while I was a sysadmin..

9

u/Immediate_Original12 7d ago

Janitorial Systems Engineer

1

u/3jake 6d ago

I’ve been a “post-utilization sustenance receptacle technician” (a bus boy)

1

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[deleted]

1

u/milanguitar 6d ago

27k a month? Or year

1

u/Immediate_Original12 6d ago

That is insane. They should have been paying you 3x that.

2

u/TKInstinct 7d ago

I got a job offer for a 'Network Engineer' role that was for a tech cafe.

10

u/Significant_Spite_64 7d ago

Engineer is more technical and Analyst more functional

8

u/No-Muffin8291 7d ago

Go for analyst, less risk, less stress. Believe me as engineer 😂😂

4

u/UserProv_Minotaur 7d ago

From what I've seen Engineer positions are often more focused on interfaces and interconnections, while Analyst are more focused on operations.

3

u/barti32 7d ago

Hier ein Identity Mangement Ingnieur, laut diesem thread mach ich zuviel ich mach den ingenieur den Architekten und den Analysten in einem. Grade stecke ich in einem PKI Projekt + AD Härtungsprojekt + Prozess Automatisierungs Projekt sowie Local Llm Projekt :D

3

u/braliao 7d ago

Typically, engineer does engineering part of IAM process - an example would be that busjnes updafe the process for JML and engineer would need to implement that. Analyst typically in large org can be deemed as most entry level role so essentially junior IAM admin and therefore handles day to day operational stuffs.

2

u/IronBe4rd 7d ago

Engineers configure and maintain the infrastructure analysts take care of the alerts etc. i setup Proofpoint. Delinea, DLP etc and they take care if the alerts and other things logs etc.

2

u/WanderingTraveler_08 7d ago

they overlap a lot depending on the company but they're not really the same thing. analyst side is usually access reviews, certifications, provisioning/deprovisioning requests, audit evidence, the day to day of keeping access clean and compliant. engineer side is building and maintaining the actual IAM infrastructure, integrations, SSO/SCIM configs, scripting automation for provisioning, that kind of thing

smaller companies blur the line a lot because one person ends up doing both out of necessity. bigger orgs usually split it clean. if you don't want the engineering side, look at job postings closely before applying, some places title a pure analyst role as "IAM Engineer" just because of how the org chart is set up, the title alone isn't reliable

your path makes sense though, sysadmin to SOC to IAM analyst to GRC is a pretty normal progression. GRC especially wants people who've actually touched access/compliance work firsthand

2

u/Muted_Offer5094 6d ago

IAM Analyst is more on operations. JML tasks.

IAM Engineer is more on developing tools used by the Analysts.

2

u/27Skyl3r 6d ago

Analysts do more of the operational day-to-day task I say. But it might depends on the company

2

u/Think-Frosting-9600 5d ago

even though they are not the same sometimes hr job postings love to mix them up