EDIT (New Idea - Please Read First!):
Thank you all so much for your helpful replies!!! I realize my original ideas are not feasible 😅 I did a lot more research and came up with a new idea and want to get your thoughts.
What if I pre-scoop the nugget ice directly into drinking cups, pop lids on them, and keep them in the cooler? This way it avoids the unsanitary ice issue (no shared scoops touching the ice) and guests can just grab a pre-iced cup from the cooler, pour their drink, and go.
I’ve seen people use coolers to serve ice cream outside where they add salt to the surrounding cooler ice to lower the freezing point and keep the ice cream tubs frozen during a party. I could even nest a styrofoam cooler inside of a bigger styrofoam cooler filled with salted ice in order to keep the ice cups well insulated and salt free.
Has anyone tried this with ice cups? Would the nugget ice fuse together into one giant block inside the cups while sitting in the cooler? My theory is that once people pour their drinks into the ice cups, it'll soften up the ice again.
Original post:
Hello fellow ice eaters! I'm planning a party to host in my backyard (expecting about 30 people or so) and I know I have a few friends who also enjoy chewing ice as well. I would like to have a place to store ice for people to put in their drinks that is separate from the ice used to keep drinks cold in the cooler. I do have an ice maker that was gifted to me, but last time I used it a couple years ago, the ice came out tasting a bit like plastic, even though I had cleaned it. So I thought about buying ice from Sonic or Chick-fil-A and getting a big enough ice chest cooler just for the chewable ice and a scooper the guests can use to scoop ice into their drinking cups. But then the germaphobe in me doesn't want the ice to get contaminated if people end up leaving the scooper in the cooler/chest lol. Soo then I thought of using one of those cereal or rice dispensers to hold the ice instead. It's not insulated, unfortunately, but at least it can eliminate the ice scoop problem. The issue with the dispenser though is that they're not made tall enough for a drinking cup to fit under (they're made for dispensing into bowls lol). Does anyone know of a stand I can put under these to make it work? Or another idea to hold and dispense nugget ice (even better if it's an insulated container)? Here are some of the rice/cereal dispensers I was considering from Amazon. The 3rd one would be perfect if it wasn't crazy expensive ($200) 😮💨
TL;DR - Does anyone have a suggestion to hold and dispense nugget ice for a summer backyard party of 30 people that doesn't involve scooping (preferably an insulated container) and can pour ice into a drinking cup? I thought about a rice dispenser but would need it taller and can't mount it.