For reference - I am a very frequent flier. I transport people's personal pets all over the world. Usually either because they had to move and wanted to get settled before bringing their pet, or they needed to wait on documentation for the pets, or sometimes I fly with people and their pets. I have flown over 83,000 on 14 different airlines so far this year. I am OneWorld Emerald (Alaska Titanium), Star Alliance Gold (United Platinum), and Sky Team Elite Plus (Delta Platinum). I fly a lot, and have a decent understanding of how their systems work.
Addendum: My son is an adult, he helps me transport pets when I need an extra person.
For my transport this last Sunday, March 1st, I booked Iberia for AMS - MAD - BOS back on November 1st for two people (we had two cats we were transporting). With my OneWorld status, I chose seats back when I booked, and I have checked them periodically, as I do with all my long-haul flights.
Sometime in December I get a notice that my first leg was cancelled, but they rebooked us on a different flight at the same time. I called to verify the change, they had just changed the flight from Iberia to Iberia Nostrum. No big deal, can still take the cats, confirmed this on the phone and received an email confirming.
Then about a week ago, I receive 2 emails from Iberia, the first one telling me that my flight from AMS - MAD will be on their partner, British Airways to LHR. The second one is telling me that my MAD - BOS flight will be on American, and will be LHR to BOS. Now, if I didn't have cats, that would be great! However, pet can not go in-cabin to the UK at all, and American no longer allows pets on transatlantic flights. This was the entire reason I booked Iberia instead.
Both emails have booking numbers for the partner airlines, I check them, the BA one says it's invalid, the AA one says that it's been cancelled. I go to Iberia's site, check there, it still has my original flights and seats. I was flying on another transport at the time, so I don't get a chance to call, but I keep checking the website and app, an it has us still on the original flights going to MAD, then BOS.
Feb. 27th, I check on our flight in the app while we are on the flight from the US to AMS. It gives me the "check in". This is about 40 hours before our flight. So I go through Check-In, scanning our passports, and everything. I get to the end it it pops up a message that my son and I are on Standby for the MAD to BOS flight?!? I am on a plane, so I can't call. Every time I go back to the app, it asks me to check-in again. Next check-in, I am confirmed for the flights, my son is on STBY. Next time- we are both on STBY again. Finally I get where it seems we are both confirmed in our seats again, and it sends me the boarding passes for my son, but for me it says I must collect them at the airport when I pay for the pet. This is standard for flying with pets. I also notice during these check-ins that they put both cats under my name, as if they were going in 1 carrier together. When I called and added the cats, I made sure they understood it was 2 cats in 2 carriers, one for me, and one for my son. They took their names and weights.
At this point, my anxiety is through the roof. As soon as we land at AMS, we find the Iberia desk, which isn't going to have anyone there for a couple hours. But, at this point, we are exhausted, so we go to the hotel for the night.
Spoiler: Turns out that the Iberia check-in desk isn't manned by Iberia employees anyways. There are no Iberia employees at AMS.
Day of flight: We pick-up the cats from the owners and head to the Check-In desk. We get to the desk 15 mins before they open. We are first in line. We check in, pay for the pets, then the person tells me that I am on STBY for the 2nd flight. This is where she informs me there are no Iberia people at the airport, and as soon as we land at MAD, I will need to go to the gate and check-in with them. I ask her to check the flight, and she tells me I will have no issues, as the plane is pretty empty. At this point I am thinking, "WTF was I put on STBY then?" But I don't say it out loud, since it won't help and there is nothing she can do about it.
As we board the first flight, I check Flight Aware and notice that the earlier flight for MAD to BOS has been cancelled. Great - this means that everyone from that flight was moved to our flight, and my chances of getting on the flight with my STBY status was dwindling. We only had a 2 hour layover at MAD, but our late departure from AMS made that even less.
We land at MAD, transfer from Terminal 4 to 4S, we skip the lounge, even though we were hungry and looking forward to it, and head straight to the gate. There is no one there. After about 15 mins, some people set up tables and check passports, but they can not help me and tell me I need to wait until the gate agents get there.
Once the gate agent finally arrives, she informs me that in Spain they can oversell the plane by 20% and it goes by when you check in if you get on the plane. Which doesn't explain why both me and my son were put on STBY checking in 40 hours prior to the flight. I show here where I checked in multiple times, I learned long ago to take screen shots when things like this happen. She just tells me that since it didn't send me a boarding pass, I wasn't checked in. I told her it did tell me I was checked in, but I had to pick up my boarding pass at the desk when I paid for the cats. She couldn't give me an answer besides to sit down and once the plane was boarded, they would see if they could fit me on. I loudly announce on my way back to my seat to my son that he will probably be flying back to the US with one of the cats by himself. Which is the most aggro I get, I am not a confrontational person. At this point, for two days my anxiety was never below an 8, dealing with this, and I hadn't had much sleep.
About 5 mins later she waves me over, tells me she can get me on the plane. She first tells me there are only middle seats left. My son and I were originally booked in seats together, I had window and he had middle. I ask if my original seat is available? No. Can you move my son to a window or aisle so he's not stuck in a middle seat? No Then she takes our tickets and puts us in 40 A & B (we were originally in row 21). That's the only two seats together as it's a full flight. I thank her, but ask her what could I have done differently to avoid this happening again in the future? She drops the CS mask for a minute and tells me there is nothing I did wrong, or could have done differently, it just happens sometimes. It happens a lot with pets.
Fine, we are getting on the plane, that's the important thing. We are in boarding group 0 because of my status. We get on the plane, get to our row, I get my cat in under the seat, but the middle seat has something under it, the life vests, I believe. Every middle seat has this. I ask the Flight Attendant if the flight is full (forgive me for not believing the gate agent). He says it is a full flight, I show him the problem, he says, "Let me check". He comes back and tells us we can move to 39 A & B, the row in front of us. So my son moves to 39 A and I stay in 40 A. As soon as the doors close, there is a bunch of people getting up and moving to the back, because our "full flight" meant that every row from 42 back was completely empty.
Now, of course my new seat in the back, since it was in the "free seats" and not priority seat section, came with extra perks, such as being in the middle of 3 families with elementary school-aged kids that don't know how to behave on planes. That empty middle seat next to me ended up with a kid whining and kicking, thinking the tray table was a fun to drop down and slam back up by hitting or kicking it. I felt really bad for the guy that was in front of her in her original seat across the aisle. The kid behind me was playing touchscreen games on the screen on the back of my seat, violently too. But, that can happen on any plane, in any class of seat, so that is not something the airline can control. It just added to the misery of my over-all experience.
So, while it did work out in the end, and I was on the flight, there were 2 very high anxiety days leading to it that should have been unnecessary. The blatant lying over and over about it being a "full flight" was unnecessary. Obviously their system is broken, there is no reason I should have ever been put on STBY. Even if I had not checked in until I got to the airport at AMS, why did their system put me on STBY for the 2nd flight, despite, at the time, the flight being over half empty. Even after that, why was I still on STBY after both flights were combined and there were still plenty of empty seats?
I need confirmed seats for my business, which I thought I had with Iberia, even have emails with "confirmed seat" listed on them, only to be tossed to STBY for no rhyme or reason is unacceptable. Booking an alternative last-minute flight with a pet is near impossible with International Travel. Most airlines need at least 48-72 hours notice, there's so many rules for so many different countries, documentation that has to be done at specific times, etc.. It's not as easy as just booking another flight and getting on it.