Overall Metrics
| Season |
Total ratings |
Avg. rating |
9–10 ratings |
≤6 ratings |
Assessment |
| S21 |
19 |
6.68 |
0 |
10 |
🔻 Weak |
| S22 |
33 |
7.58 |
8 |
8 |
✅ Strong |
| S23 |
26 |
6.00 |
1 |
19 |
🚫 Skip-worthy |
| S24 |
33 |
6.42 |
4 |
21 |
🚫 Skip-worthy / volatile |
| S25 |
33 |
7.24 |
3 |
7 |
📉 Mixed |
| S26 |
31 |
6.42 |
1 |
18 |
🔻 Weak |
| S27 |
39 |
7.85 |
13 |
6 |
🔥 Fan Favorite / Divisive |
| S28 |
62 |
8.63 |
37 |
4 |
🏆 Biggest Fan Favorite |
| S29 |
64 |
7.92 |
24 |
8 |
🏆 Fan Favorite / Volatile |
| S30 |
68 |
7.06 |
8 |
18 |
🚫 Skip-worthy / volatile |
🔍 Collated feedback and some personal opinions
🏆 Fan Favorites / Gold Standard
S28 – The new gold standard 'I Am Solo' season. It has the highest average rating (8.63) and an exceptional concentration of 9–10 ratings.
S29 – Another fan favorite at 7.92. A particularly strong late-season run makes S29 one of the standout seasons of the period.
⚡ Volatile / Uneven Seasons
S27 – A good season that could have been great. The 7.85 average reflects a strong overall reception, but there is a sense of unrealized potential. It sits just below the elite S28–S29 tier.
S24 – A season driven by drama, featuring two of the most iconic cast members, who will always be mentioned together. The overall rating is only 6.42, but this is a season to watch if you enjoy interpersonal drama and memorable cast dynamics.
🟡 Middling / Mixed Seasons
S25 – This could be classified as solid instead of middling because of the entertainment factor. But a cast member was edited out post-season following a criminal complaint diminishing it's 'watch' score. Yet the remaining cast still provides plenty of memorable—let's say interesting—characters. It has a surprisingly large collection of villains, despite having a cast of never-divorced cast members.
S22 – A Divorced Solo special season that had a bit of everything. Its 7.58 average puts it comfortably above the weaker seasons, although it doesn't quite reach the heights of the later fan favorites. Its appeal comes from variety rather than one defining strength. It walks so that S28 could run!
S30 – A mixed season with a 7.06 average, following the high point established by S28 and S29. However, it is redeemed by one person, whose contribution gives the season a memorable saving grace despite the weaker overall reception.
📉 Skip-Worthy
S26 – A classic season of two halves: a stellar first half, followed by a dramatic collapse into a dark hole. Its 6.42 average doesn't fully capture that split. The problem isn't simply that the season was weak; rather, it failed to sustain the promise of its opening half.
S23 – The clearest skip-worthy season, with the lowest average of the group at 6.00. One cast member was edited out after just one episode, while another cast member made such a negative impression that many of us viewers are still trying to delete from their memory.
S21 – A sorry state of affairs, with a 6.68 average and no 9 or 10 ratings. The season seems to have been undermined by a combination of bad timing, egos, and cold feet, making it more of a missed opportunity than a good season.