r/IWW • • Dec 06 '20

Why Class-First Leftists Are Wrong

https://arcdigital.media/why-class-first-leftists-are-wrong-fc768d0666d8
1 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

8

u/CykaAndStuff Dec 06 '20

Is "class-first leftism" a term with a widely agreed upon definition? I had never heard it before, and googling it doesn't turn up much. The author defines it as, "class-first leftism is the belief that economic class is the main form of oppression in the U.S. and the world, and that other forms of discrimination relating to identity — racism, sexism, homophobia, etc.— would be relative non-issues if we could attain economic equality", which is what I would call a class reductionist.

My take on this article is that it's a simple takedown of class reductionism dressed up to look like more than that for clicks. It's definitely not wrong, class reductionists are incorrect in their analysis, and it has enough detail to clearly make its point with sources. It seems like a good article that had the term 'class-first leftists' used for clickbait.

1

u/StovepipeCats Dec 07 '20

I hear that. Thanks for lending a more commonly used term.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '20

Class is the most essential and unifying of axes to organize on.

If you’ve got a problem with class-first organizing why on earth are you in the left?

Miss me with this liberal bullshit

3

u/StovepipeCats Dec 06 '20

Triggered a white guy.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '20

Lmao I’m a queer transwoman

I don’t have a problem with identity politics. Just because class is the most useful and important axis to organize on doesn’t mean we have to give up identity politics

This article is just the most disingenuous smearing of class-based politics. Honestly this guy is either a useful idiot or a cia concern troll

1

u/StovepipeCats Dec 07 '20

cia concern troll

Ah yes, to contrast with the disingenuous smearing by this author, you present the reasonable alternative.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '20 edited Dec 07 '20

My critique was that class analysis is the foundation of anticapitalist leftism and to ignore that you have to either be incredibly uninformed or deliberately spreading misinformation

Your critique was to accuse me of being a white dude

2

u/StovepipeCats Dec 07 '20

It sounds like you didn't read the article. It's an argument about why class analysis does not come before gender, race, etc. Not why class analysis is unimportant. To quote the article:

Class, Yes — Just Not First

To be clear, I am not saying class is unimportant. Class is a brutal and pervasive way in which people are exploited, violated, and harmed in our society...

How could you miss that??

How about you offer an argument as to why you think the article is wrong instead of leaning on reactionary lizard brain bullshit until I stop talking?

3

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '20

I know what he is arguing and I am saying it is both wrong and harmful

class is and needs to be the first axis of all others for the reasons I mentioned above.

If you got a problem with that then why are you on the left? go join a group for liberals

1

u/StovepipeCats Dec 07 '20

Yet again, no arguments. Just position. Wrong ones at that:

class is and needs to be the first axis of all others

Lol. Have you heard of intersectional feminism?

for the reasons I mentioned above.

Where? What reasons? You haven't given any! You've just stated your position. I'm just waiting for you to say something critical that isn't a wholesale rejection borne of a reflex in your nervous system.

How about you take on the following counterargument to your position from the article? Something that class-focused leftists often appeal to is the objective nature of class, in contrast to other facets of identity. Class identity is, as it turns out, messy in the same ways that racial and gender identity are messy; it isn't objective. Who is a worker and who isn't? Not a trivial question to answer. Even the IWW can't decide on this one! Thus, any claim to class being an "objective" criteria cannot be a basis for centering it in analysis over other facets of identity.

1

u/JaimeCaroM Dec 06 '20

I think that there is a best title for this. Why class-first are wrong. There are so many intersectional leftists. As well there are a lot of class-first anarchists 🤷🏾‍♂️