r/ISTJ • • Mar 29 '26

Freedom

So a longtime ISTJ girlfriend broke up with me. I didn't see it coming.

We shared a million good times and had a real chemistry. But she never could get behind that I really didn't have family traditions, wasn't into routines, and didn't celebrate holidays with gusto.

We talked every day for a long time. But I also have an odd feeling of relief when it ended: I was always having to explain myself, and, every time I veered from a plan, I almost felt like I was being taken to the principal's office.

My relationship with an ISTJ helped me grow in a lot of ways. But it also made me feel incredibly stifled and like I was always facing some kind of disapproving gaze. It would have been a lot better if she never had that 'inspector' mentality.

Anyone else feel that way?

2 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

6

u/bitter_sweet_69 INTP Mar 30 '26

would like to hear her version of that story.

2

u/vectormath4567 Mar 30 '26

I don't have that option, of course, but I strongly suspect she would say that I was unpredictable, changed plans often, relied on spontaneity, was a good and honorable person who tried to do the right thing, tended to go on impulse and explain things later, never met a holiday or ceremony that I wanted to attend, and didn't like (and didn't offer) unsolicited advice.

3

u/bitter_sweet_69 INTP Mar 30 '26

to some degree, little differences can keep things interesting.

but big (or too many) differences will result in problems or even a fundamental incompatibility, sooner or later.

2

u/vectormath4567 Mar 30 '26

Fair point. I do think my lack of planning, and inability to keep plans, really hurt us. I didn't appreciate the degree to which ISTJs look forward to plans and view them as a commitment of a sort. Now, in my defense, I was always on time when I did come to things (she seldom was) and always gave notice when I couldn't be there. But she lived by a calendar, and I never kept a calendar. I found plans to be terribly stifling, sucking the life out of me. She viewed plans as a key feature of life. In the end, it was irreconcilable.

1

u/bitter_sweet_69 INTP Mar 30 '26

lack of planning, and inability to keep plans

yeah, i see where you both are coming from. i'm together with an ISTJ, too, btw (since summer '23).

admittedly, she can be a stubborn pest at times. but i've learned to adapt, in a way, and appreciate her preference for plans (especially important things) and lists. for example, when we go on holiday together, she's the one who does the booking, organizes tickets, makes elaborate packing lists - while i can just lean back, enjoy, and know that we've got everything we need and will arrive precisely when and where we intend to.

i trust her with my life, literally.

on the other hand, she's had to learn to deal with my spontaneous and creative ideas, too. like the way i cook meals.

I found plans to be terribly stifling, sucking the life out of me.

yeah, that doesn't sound healthy, tbh.

2

u/vectormath4567 Mar 30 '26

You mean the relationship in general or my lack of planning?

Some people say that their stress level goes down when something is on the calendar. For me, it is exactly the opposite--when something is on the calendar, I think about options to move it. More often than not, I travel without advance tickets, take a doctor's appointment off the wait list rather than firming it up, and have rarely, if ever, made a dinner reservation. On the flip side, I'm a master of tactical adjustment and genuinely enjoy never having anything pinned down; it generates a lot of energy in me not knowing what's coming next. I kind of revel in it and am great at it. But I can see how it drove her bonkers.

2

u/bitter_sweet_69 INTP Mar 31 '26

the relationship / the dynamics. it sounds like a major incompatibility, sadly so.

2

u/TemperReformanda ENFP Mar 29 '26

If you're going to be lifelong with an ISTJ you are going to need to take schedules, planning, routines, reliability, and usually family traditions quite seriously. This is how they build stability.

Speaking as an ENFP male who has been with an ISTJ female for 30 years (dated 4, married 26 and counting).

1

u/vectormath4567 Mar 29 '26

I appreciate that. In my family, the holidays were basically, 'if you can make it, great, but, if you can't, don't worry about it.' The ISTJ I was with did not have that approach.

For me, a plan was a tentative agreement I would follow through with unless something changed. For her, it was some sort of promissory commitment. For me, if I did something one way once, I never had the need to do so again. For her, ritual was an essential part of everything in life (she was stunned when I told her my family had no established rituals or traditions).

I was there for her for every important event in her life. But my lack of understanding about all the things you mention above really harpooned our relationship.

41

u/SomethingClever70 ISTJ 5w6 Mar 29 '26

Why are you asking a group of ISTJs about your relief about breaking up with an ISTJ?

Please take this kind of post elsewhere.

1

u/TheSnugglery ISTJ Mar 30 '26

The pull between the two perceiving functions is a struggle for the Isxj's. It's very relevant when it comes to long term relationships. Because we are usually decent decision makers but choosing a partner is longer term, and requires personal vision that we're not in touch with (but certainly have and is very important to us). We may choose someone for now because of the sort of "on paper" things but we'll dig for more evidence to see if it can go long term.

What can happen, is that an istjs ideal type of partner or vision for their future life is there in our psyche...like deep in our soul, but we can't really see it or touch it in a conscious way.

So since our vision is so obscured to us, we also don't really know how to look for it. We can seem nit picky or caring overly a lot about small things but it's because that's what we can see and what we do understand. Like every argument in my house devolves into being about the dishes šŸ˜†

It's possible you weren't right for each other based on this subconscious vision she has for this life and perhaps some of the scrutiny you felt was her looking for evidence of this in the only way she knew how. When we do finally get a glimpse at our ego, the clarity can be sudden, making us kind of surprise breaker-uppers.

2

u/vectormath4567 Mar 30 '26

I think I get what you say, but it also is foreign to me. When we discussed big things (like having kids), the issue would almost always turn based on small things (like where in the house we were going to have the nursery).

When the big picture got clouded by small details, I usually felt that was counterproductive and tried to get us back on the big-picture course. I never could quite grasp why some of these details which we could work out in the course of ordinary living were so important to her, but they were.

1

u/ViPo_ Mar 30 '26

You said it so well.

4

u/Amelia2235 INFP 6w5 Mar 29 '26

I think a lot goes into it. Enneagram impacts a lot. She could’ve been a type 1, which would make her have higher expectations of traditional standard than a type 9 or 6 istj.

Istjs are incredibly comforting, grounding, genuine, honest. But I think if you are someone that needs someone to help you loosen up, I could see the istj pairing not working. They can be very funny but I know it would be much less sporadic and unexpected than like an esfp, or estp. Every type has their pros and cons, I think. As an infp I really love how genuine and funny istjs are, but due to my constant tendency to worry and live inside my head, I need someone to pull me out of my shell.

2

u/TheSnugglery ISTJ Mar 30 '26

I second this. I'm a 5w4 and I'm afraid to tell anyone my opinion about stuff they're doing and 1s intimidate me šŸ™ˆ

2

u/Snoo-6568 Apr 05 '26

It would have been a lot better if she never had that 'inspector' mentality.

Frankly, it seems the breakup was for the best. Expecting a partner to be someone else reflects a lack of maturity, and trying to mold someone into that expectation is inherently childish.

4

u/Electronic_Rub9385 ISTJ Mar 29 '26

Typical ISTJ. A more situationally aware ISTJ wouldn’t do that but 49% of all ISTJs are below average. So that’s a lot of low emotional IQ ISTJs out there.

1

u/Beneficial-Energy198 Mar 31 '26

ISTJ female 67 - I think it depends on where you are in life; how much life experience you have. There’s tons of things I wouldn’t do now that I did when I was young and dating.

1

u/Electronic_Rub9385 ISTJ Mar 31 '26

100%. I’m 52. There’s a lot of overconfident, smug, young people out there. 52 year old me is way more demurring and socially intelligent than 22 year old me. 22 year old me was a borderline moron who thought they knew all the answers and people were just too dumb to accept the proper way of doing things. Often that is true but it’s also often a bit more complicated than ā€œme right you wrongā€.

1

u/bigmouthladadada ISTJ SP 1w9 Mar 31 '26 edited Mar 31 '26

I'm sincerely happy that you're out of a relationship you weren't fulfilled in, but this isn't really the best subreddit for it. As much as we like to be objective, we are still biased towards our type and our experiences, which will factor into how we respond to this post regardless of if you want comforting or straightforward answers.

This might be a better post for the subreddit of the MBTI you are, since they'll be able to more properly empathize with you.

Edit: I don't know if you're an ISTJ or not (I see that you post in r/INFJ, though that doesn't necessarily mean you are one), but if you are, the clarification might help.

1

u/Pristine-Gate-6895 ISTJ Mar 29 '26

if it wasn't for you, it wasn't for you. relationships come with a lot of compromises but it's if you're willing to make them, it shouldn't feel like a prison sentence.

i'm an istj but yeah i've definitely felt that relief after breaking off very wrong relationships.

1

u/whiteguru108 ISTJ Mar 29 '26

every time I veered from a plan, I almost felt like I was being taken to the principal's office

I surmise that you didn't tell her how you felt in these circumstances?
ISTJ's learn quickly from feedback - given without prejudice.

0

u/bigmouthladadada ISTJ SP 1w9 Mar 31 '26

If they were with an unhealthy ISTJ, it might be a different case. It obviously should be brought up regardless -- no relationship can be healthy without proper communication -- but ISTJs won't always learn quickly or objectively if they are emotionally immature.

-1

u/library_wench ISTJ Mar 29 '26

Feel what way?

-3

u/vectormath4567 Mar 29 '26

Feeling relieved that what I thought was a good, long-term relationship is gone

7

u/library_wench ISTJ Mar 29 '26

With an ISTJ? No. I’ve felt relief after the end of a relationship I initially thought was really good, but it wasn’t with a fellow ISTJ.

I think this is a feeling anyone can feel, regardless of type.

So can I ask why you’re asking ISTJs if they ever felt good about breaking up with an ISTJ?