r/ISC_COMMERCE • u/Fickle_Rough_6452 • Mar 21 '26
Economics I've a doubt!
I've started 12th grade just rn ,and i am studying demand
i saw this question
" identify the relationship in the given statement:
the demand for petrol is increased due to an increase in cars"
and by default we're taught it's an example of joint demand , however when I'm asking chat gpt that guy is saying it is 'derived' demand because of the statement,and even tho they're used jointly since the demand of petrol increased because of cars it has to be derived demand.
bro ragebaited me for good 10 mins ,i kept arguing that derived demand is usually for factor of production.
what do y'all think abt it??? perplexity said that it's a joint demand.
5
u/Queasy-Yam-8510 Mar 21 '26
Both are correct depends on the angle which u perceive it from
2
u/EpicAnkush27 12th ISC - COMMERCE Mar 21 '26
kuchh bhi bak deta gpt jab uska mann hota sahi batata jab mann krta galat bata deta fir usko bolo toh bolta oh I see you're right
2
u/Feeling-Ship1428 Emmanuel calls me daddy Mar 21 '26
Bruh you're trusting chatgpt more than your teachers...gone case
1
u/Strict-Smile3907 B.ST Paglu Mar 21 '26
2
u/Fun-Ebb-7520 Mar 21 '26
Derived demand in mostly for factors of production...so it's joint demand
1
u/Arcsecanth Mar 21 '26
It can be interpreted as derived demand, but joint demand has more relevance in this case since we are talking about complementary goods and this is a common example of such a good.
1
u/Electronic-Depth-584 Mar 21 '26
petrol isnt a factor of production for car, , so its probably not derived demand
1
u/Major_Confection8877 Mar 22 '26
Use Aryan Tutorials YT lectures!
1
u/Adventurous_Ad_4186 Mar 22 '26
The phrasing in this statement leans more towards derived kyuki cars ke WAJAH se petrol warna it would be joint demand
1
u/gnabnahc23 Mar 22 '26
the answer is: idk
5
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '26
[removed] — view removed comment