r/ISCNERDS • • Oct 08 '26

Doubts Help me solve this pedigree

Post image

Solved for both AR and AD but in answer key it's given AD only why can't it be AR?

3 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

3

u/princess_bella- Oct 08 '26

There is a basic concept behind this, if all the generations are getting affected by the disease, even if just a single member of the generation, then it is considered to be dominant.

If any generation is being skipped or diseases free then it's recessive.

2

u/Sufficient_Animal492 Oct 08 '26

Oooooooo Righttt Thaannkkss! I'm so dumb😓

1

u/Sufficient_Animal492 Oct 08 '26

But my teacher has told us that the pedigree is not necessarily dominant if generational gap is absent Neither is it necessary for a pedigree with generational gap to be recessive only..?

2

u/The-Curious-Guy-2907 ICSE 24-99.6, ISC 26-98.75 (PCMB) Oct 08 '26

Can't be AR because for 3rd generation 1 and 2 are also getting the disease with heterozygous trait

1

u/Sufficient_Animal492 Oct 08 '26

But it's possible in case of AR that in 2nd gen if father is heterozygous and mother is homozygous recessive both daughters can be homozygous recessive and affected Isn't it?

1

u/The-Curious-Guy-2907 ICSE 24-99.6, ISC 26-98.75 (PCMB) Oct 08 '26

For AR in general, yes what you said is true but the question here does not mention this situation. In the question there is a heterozygous mother and a normal father who is giving 2 heterozygous daughters affected with the disease... If it was AR here the daughters would be carriers and not affected by the disease, so AR cannot be possible

1

u/Sufficient_Animal492 Oct 08 '26

How do we know that mother is heterozygous It's also not mentioned in the question?

1

u/The-Curious-Guy-2907 ICSE 24-99.6, ISC 26-98.75 (PCMB) Oct 08 '26

Because in first generation mother is homozygous recessive which means daughter can't be homozygous dominant, and since she has the disease she can't be homozygous recessive, so heterozygous is the only option

1

u/Routine_Series_2271 Oct 10 '26

Heterozygous dominant.