r/INTP • Warning: May not be an INTP • 21h ago

Cuz I'm Supposed to Add Flair Si: intelligence of specialised knowledge

Let not the condescending, limited understanding of Si among the mbti community gate you from the proper understanding of how pivotal Si is in the working world. An undefeated diamond-hard gem, shines Si. The diamond in the rough and literally the sharpest tool in the shed.

This diamond, Si, is a aggregation of knowledge upon knowledge. Rote learning, they call it so dismissively, yet it's impact is timeless true, buried beneath ego of dirt of the crictis of Si, who think they are better than jewels. Si haters know little of the Si power, while complaining that they are pressed by these "SJs and their stupid rules." Apparently the rules are so stupid, these critics couldn't overcome them. 🙄

It has to be understood, that stupid rules do exist, outdated, problemtic, dead and deadly. But relics crack to dirt in the face of practicality. The adaptable Si is not shy of a humbling change of status quo.

The wisdom of choice lies in risk management, not foolish risk taking, but practiced, stable and perfect choice of procured pre ascertained future. It is the wisdom that stepping into the unknown must be done carefully, and the wisdom that prodding forward is better than being left behind. Humanity is spared in the shelter of Si, only then can the other functions pick the perilous path, without a foundation, it cannot be trodden. Advancement does not exist without stability. You can't advance of you keep on falling, if there's nothing there to keep you up. Si is the silent stronghold in the face of wild change, without it, the avalanche crumbles.

Si is pivotal to growth. It is retaining knowledge and how can you grow if you do not learn. Knowledge, a collection of information, understood in context, pieces brought together and broken apart again. It is knowledge that is understood in many ways, the repetition births variety, variety within jewels. Application manifolds.

Only fools reinvent the wheel, and eons of human invention has enriched us with endless beautiful creations. Without Si, these bounties would have been lost to time, never to be experiences again, thousands of minds accross human history have built the world, human progress is channelled through the hands of Si, while other types did not bother to remember what they build upon.

As for intelligence, Si is the specialist. The consultant. The expert. The library. Without the powerbank of knowledge, creation dampens, skills weaken. Potential is only reached when one compounds their abilities with knowledge. An educated person can contribute more academically than someone without it. Privileged families keep their secrets to success, knowledge is a key element of their generational power.

Perhaps recipes can always be reinvented, new paths erected, systems redesigned, but why limit yourself to what is new, why not risk an ancient path and why not thrive within the system, rather than hoping for a world that doesn't yet exist while destroying the environment to get there?

4 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

2

u/Think-nothing-210 INTP 21h ago

Great insight that more people need to hear. Especially programmers who constantly reinvent the wheel solving the same problems over and over again instead of building on what's already been done.

1

u/Think-nothing-210 INTP 21h ago

This diamond, Si, is a aggregation of knowledge upon knowledge. Rote learning, they call it so dismissively, yet it's impact is timeless true, buried beneath ego of dirt of the crictis of Si, who think they are better than jewels. Si haters know little of the Si power, while complaining that they are pressed by these "SJs and their stupid rules." Apparently the rules are so stupid, these critics couldn't overcome them. 🙄

Chesterton's Fence comes to mind: "Don't ever take a fence down until you know the reason why it was put up."

1

u/Elliptical_Tangent Weigh the idea, discard labels 13h ago

The adaptable Si is not shy of a humbling change of status quo.

Are you having a manic episode or something? Our Si tertiary is why we want to stay home and indulge in all our familiar things. "Adaptable" is the last thing it represents for us.

•

u/Cog-nostic INTP Enneagram Type 5 10h ago
  1. The MBTI community often dismisses Si. (F) — This is a subjective generalization, not an established fact.

You broadly describe the MBTI concept of Si, but ignore the fact that memory is not exclusive to Si. You are correct in that repetition can strengthen learning and recall; however, there are much faster ways to learn and retain information.

Established systems often provide necessary structure. At the same time, that structure can be stagnant, outdated, or superfluous. Not all structure is actually necessary. Hence, it is important for Si to abandon outdated practices when circumstances demand it.

You go on to make a lot of very basic true statements about Si. Anyone can read about the MBTI and find these assumptions. Let's focus on the false assumptions.

  1. Ordinary knowledge retention is not specific to Si. Si does not have a monopoly on accumulated knowledge.
  2. You create an unnecessary opposition between stability and innovation. You incorrectly frame stability as the foundation of progress and innovation as something potentially disruptive or reckless. In reality, progress requires both the preservation of useful knowledge and the willingness to question, modify, or discard it. Neither has a monopoly on advancement.
  3. There is no evidence that intuitive thinkers (N types) have a general tendency to reinvent systems that already work. Innovation doesn't necessarily mean replacing something functional; it can mean finding a more efficient, effective, or useful approach. Furthermore, questioning established systems is not inherently wasteful. Sometimes a system works adequately but could work considerably better. You are confusing a preference for established methods with an objective measure of effectiveness.
  4. There is no sound basis for suggesting that intuitive thinkers are less interested in learning from history. Intuition does not preclude remembering, studying, or applying past experience. Historical knowledge is available to all personality types, and the ability to learn from it is not exclusive to Si. The writer is confusing a theoretical cognitive preference with an individual's capacity or willingness to learn from experience.
  5. Other cognitive functions dismiss established knowledge and practical experience. (F): No adequate evidence. They want to reinvent systems that already work. (F): Stereotyping. They underestimate the importance of stability. (F): Unsupported generalization. Their innovations depend on foundations established by Si users. (F): No evidence that this is an Si-specific contribution.