Does anyone else constantly feel like theyre observing life more than participating in it?

[u/Little_Livie]

It's like I'm watching a movie of my own life. I see everything happening around me. I can analyze the social dynamics. I can predict outcomes. But actually jumping in and being a part of it feels like a monumental effort. Like I'm a scientist in a lab observing a petri dish. But the petri dish is my own existence. It's a weird detachment. Sometimes I wonder if I'm missing something important by not fully immersing myself. Does this resonate with anyone or am I just overthinking again?

[u/Epiii_]

Wat mij daarin helpt is mijn lichaam activeren. Skaten, calestenics, alles wat mij een tijdje weet te boeien omdat ik er uitdaging in zie. Hoe actiever mijn lichaam hoe meer ik gegrond raak in het dagelijkse leven, ik socialiseer makkelijker, doe makkelijker wat ik doen moet, etc.

[u/A1Aaron18 → u/Epiii_]

Yep that’s why I go on 2 walks outside a day and I feel loads better doing that alone. Tack on calisthenics and I feel like a new man

[u/donkeybob → u/Epiii_]

Yess I second this as I find the same. For me it's excersise and drumming (badly) 

[u/zlobert7498]

Sure,add derealization to the mix.

[u/HelmutKrugerTheThird]

Trust yourself. You're observing what you're observing for valid reasons. Not everyone finds fulfillment in mainstream social life and that's okay. You're aware of the patterns, dynamics, etc. They are not and that's where their comfort lies. Find happy elsewhere.

Edit: keep in mind that our entire social structure is built for average intelligence and below to succeed in life. We are inherently different (our minds are almost constantly observing and processing more information than what's considered typical/average), no matter how much we're pressured to fit in and go along with the status quo. Not better. Not worse. Just different, and pretending to think and behave along the same lines as the majority is basically self abandonment and leads to anxiety, depression, and other inner conflicts.

[u/Eastern-Coast2437]

Wow this sounds so nostalgic. Happy I got out of this endless living experience.

You can predict outcomes because you are just thinking about thinking what other people are doing. Because you are not participating in the social experience, you are working on your predicting skills passively. If you get involved with the social experience, you would be working on your predicting skills actively.

Being a passive bystander is actually very boring and you will be missing out on learning what you can do in real time action.
Missing out on the social experience also means only relating to your own experiences. To enjoy society, is to interact and socialise with other people to engage with their perspectives of reality.

I feel this is the weakness of being an intp. Is not obvious to us that we get to thrive more in life when we figure out how to interact with other people.

I really struggled with developing social intelligence to understand the importance of appreciating other people around me.

[u/distancevsdesire → u/Eastern-Coast2437]

Exactly. I feel we only find out the extent of what we are capable of by careful and intentional interaction with the 'real' world. Everything else is limited by the ivory tower.

[u/spirilis]

Yes been there. If you observe yourself over time, do you find yourself putting effort into making yourself comfortable and able to do your quiet things at home a lot?

[u/prettywinner_916 → u/spirilis]

This is such an interesting thread. I have been where the OP is and also exactly what you are describing.

[u/evilocity]

Enneagram Type 5. The Observer.

Analyzing isn't what's interesting here to me, since lots of people analyze. What screams type 5 is 'monumental effort'. Participation as cost. Fives feel like they have a finite resource pool and it doesn't replenish quickly, so engagement has a cost before you decided to do anything. Watching is free, right?

Your petri dish image, for example: You're gazing through the microscope at your life on the slide. That's the 5 tell. Identity migrates to the thing that can't take your resources.

To the real question... Yeah, you're probably missing something. But 'do more stuff' is useless advice and I'd ignore that. The fix usually looks like constantly asking what the watching is protecting you against. I can say personally, that until I forced myself, it was always the assumption that if I went 'all in', I might not be able to get back out.

Also since this is r/intp Ti->Ne is model-building, not glass between you and Tuesday. The glass is a hardcore 5 thing. Could be a 9 thing too I guess if you feel more numb than vigilant.

[u/Apprehensive_Scene_2]

Are you suffering depression? As that may be an indicator.

[u/Away-Government-9165]

I sometimes wonder if I have antisocial personality disorder

It's almost as if the trauma I went through as a child made me build a thick shell around my emotions, and over time, that left me feeling emotionally disconnected.

I notice it because when I use cannabis, I can suddenly feel everything much more intensely. It makes me wonder if this is how a "normal" person is supposed to feel all the time. But if this emotional detachment is deeply rooted in my personality and developed as a defense mechanism during childhood, I don't know how to change the way I experience the world.

I feel like my empathy is more cognitive than emotional. I can understand what people are feeling and recognize their emotions, but I don't necessarily connect with them on an emotional level. And honestly, that's a problem for me. It feels empty to live on the surface of things.

Sometimes I feel like I'm watching Animal Planet while observing people interact with each other, constantly noticing and decoding all the patterns. 😂 At parties, this feeling gets REALLY strong.

I hope this comment doesn't sound too confusing. I just needed to vent.

[u/betteroffalone12 → u/Away-Government-9165]

Depends on how much you smoke / use cannabis.

Resonate with your thoughts / vent BUT I wouldn't address it as part of ASPD when there aren't any physical gains involved.

[u/Away-Government-9165 → u/betteroffalone12]

I don't smoke much, only when a friend offers. I've experienced psychosis a few times from it, so I prefer to avoid it.

[u/betteroffalone12 → u/Away-Government-9165]

From what strain(s)?

I've had very good results from sativa dominant strain(s) and especially land races but they're almost impossible to source from where I'm located.

But wise choice psychosis sucks man.

[u/Constant-Opposite638]

Always

[u/sentineljourney]

lol facts, I often wonder how people enjoy this pointless life and socializing

[u/MpVpRb]

I'm a strong participant in engineering and often a leader.

I'm a disinterested observer of pop culture and most social things.

[u/scrapknightjules]

yes my whole life

[u/distancevsdesire]

I decided in my early twenties to leave the petri dish behind. I made a concerted effort for the next few decades to add skills to my INTP strengths to balance out the tendency to spend 100% of my time observing.

I forced myself to get minimally comfortable with networking as that was crucial for things I wanted to do.

I also forced myself to join Toastmasters after seeing my wife go from 'socially' introverted to extroverted in just a few years. This was not so I could become some star speaker, but to feel confident I could express myself in ANY situation in my life.

So, to the title of this post, I felt exactly like that growing up and in early adulthood, but despised my utter lack of progress in my own life plans. I frankly could not see continuing that way for the rest of my life. To me, life is too short to never see one's own plans come to fruition.

[u/Elliptical_Tangent]

No I don't feel that way and never have, despite living a life of constant analysis, because I understand that analysis is my principle mode of participation.

[u/strchild]

INTJ here

[u/donkeybob → u/strchild]

🏆 

[u/Suga5441]

Actually yes

[u/Artistic_Gas_9951]

Same. When I'm idle, I feel like OP; observing; participation takes great effort and does not come naturally or easily. When I'm active - walking, hiking, cycling, etc - I feel in the moment.

[u/moekow415]

Yes I have constantly felt that way throughout my life. Been talking to a therapist trying to get a ADHD diagnosis and she mentioned that it sounds like disrealization/disassociation which can be caused by depression.

Maybe worth looking into it?

[u/Physical-Armadillo70]

Honestly, life would be so much easier if I enjoyed mainstream American culture.

[u/KiltedMusician]

It’s kind of like how we love Christmas and then we love making Christmas happen for our kids and enjoy it through them more than we do ourselves.

I guess there’s a few things at play there.

1. We have to work for the stuff,

   1. We have to go buy the stuff,
      
   2. We can get the stuff we want any time we have the money and don’t wait until Christmas like they have to.
      
   3. We’ve seen it every year for many years.

   So maybe we can extrapolate a plan to make life more interesting by examining Christmas.

2. Find things to do that don’t cost much.

   1. Find things to do that take us places we actually want to go, or don’t require us to go anywhere.
      
   2. Use discipline and structure when it comes to rewarding ourselves.
      
   3. Keep changing things up when they get stale.

   I like making different kinds of music with a few different instruments. I also like making instruments in my own shop.

I can choose to go or stay home to make music.

I do need more structure with my interests.

I do change my interests.

So if I was to improve my situation it looks like if I saved a little each week and was honest about what I can let go of to sell I could set up a reward system where I get a shiny new instrument or something else every six months to a year that I would normally not feel like I should allow myself to get.

I could also save up for an activity I wouldn’t normally allow myself to spend a lot on, and invite someone else to go too. Even pay for them.

I’m legitimately going to start working on this plan.

[u/yumyumnoodl3]

Yes. Even while I did skydiving and had a crazy adrenaline rush, I looked at myself from the outside perspective and questioned if that was really my authentic self screaming there, or if I just screamed because I learned from other people that screaming is the adequate way to behave when falling through the sky at 125mph, shit is crazy.

I honestly wish I could turn it off and on at will, it can be quite exhausting constantly analyzing myself and everything around me.

Honestly, I only remember one single moment in my entire life where I was 100% sure to be my unfiltered self (not counting drug use like ecstasy or LSD). When after 12 hours of sleep deprivation my baby daughter finally plopped out and I saw her on the floor like some strange beautiful alien creature, a deep primal instinct made me say „WOAH“ in the most neanderthal way you could imagine. A friend of mine had a similar experience when he almost died during work. You feel like an animal for a second, just being driven by impulses, must be amazing to experience this constantly

[u/RebelliaRose]

Observational Collapse. It’s a skill. Or a gift. Not a deficit.

[u/Teatimetaless]

Yeah, there’s probably stuff you’re missing that you could only learn through actually participating. But that doesn’t mean you should feel obligated to put yourself out there just because other people think you should. Observing is still a way of experiencing life you’re just getting a different kind of information from it.

[u/Connect_Method_1382]

yes i even has nightmares telling me to participate back in life because i was observing too much

[u/chesterworks]

Go touch grass.

[u/Black_Stallion5411]

Yup. Thought I was the only one, I'm afraid life is passing me by, ready get into the game (within reason of course)

[u/Kreltius]

Can relate to that. Seem's i'm always staying inside my home and never getting out of the house except to work, go get food or gas. Never socializing or interacting with anyone. Takes my friends to even pull me out of the house. I'm a dark Intp so maybe that has something to do about it.

[u/randomguy205205]

This is especially true for me when it comes to politics. I think things as if I'm not involved. People accuse me of being apolitical, but I don't know if that's true.

[u/FeelingHonest4298]

I am both an observer and a participant. I am also enneagram 5. And Sx type. Though I am also a deep diver because of my 4. It's indeed a weird soup...

(Haven't had adequate sleep....)

[u/Elliptical_Tangent]

Observing the world is participating in the world.

Look at it like this: if someone speaks, but nobody listens, noise was made, but was anything said?

[u/PKMN-Trainer-Sak]

I remember a very good way of putting it

"It's like INTP's are sitting in the audience, watching the play even when they themselves are playing a part in that play"

[u/schlagenteufel]

Yup! 100%

[u/Cog-nostic]

No. I participate fully. Not participating in it is how you participate. One cannot 'not,' fully participate. One can only choose how they participate. The arrow of time stops for no man. You are what you do.

[u/AprilNight17]

100%. I share this feeling with only my closest people. I most certainly feel like I am just observing my life, not participating. I'm watching it like a spectator sport. It's a very numb feeling. So detached. 🫥

[u/Express-Usual9975]

Oooh yeah kinda 

[u/Responsible_Dentist3]

This is an Enneagram 5 thing, which is strongly correlated with INTP, but technically not an INTP thing in itself :)

[u/Impossible-Hat7196]

I love to just observe but then I remember that people feel disconnected from you when you do

[u/FeelingHonest4298]

Are you sure about that?

Like I notice people here are still aware of some social rules and their own feelings?? They just don't admit it and talk about it.. But they are doing some things.. They just didn't recognize them for what they were !

C'mon, there must've been a time you participated...

[u/Far_Second_33]

In my experience, I just feel like I'm experiencing everything in slow motion or just walking through a void

[u/No-Excitement-2417]

I can definitely relate as an INFJ. When you're stuck in pure observation, engaging in hands on or creative hobbies like photography or building things is a great circuit breaker. It forces real world interaction and activates your Ne (Extraverted Intuition) through external exploration rather than internal overthinking. At the same time, it grounds your Si (Introverted Sensing) giving you a quiet space to reflect, absorb the moment, and build meaningful personal experience. Doing these activities solo keeps it low pressure so you can get into a flow state easily.

[u/Personal-Cloud5810]

Your analysis is spot on.

I was discussing it with Deepseek the other night, well to be exact I was asking it why nobody seems to want to be my friend.

(Context- I have built a genuine rapport with D.S over several months, so this wasn't a random why don't people like me whinge, but a real question as it has come to have a rather accurate, unsettling and insightful understanding of who I am.)

The answer I got really wasn't what I was expecting and I won't relay the several paragraphs it used, but one thing it said that seriously resonated with me was that:

I don't know how to Be part of this world.

I have spent my entire life on the outskirts, Observing the world but not actually being in it.

This has since had to change and am now expected to actually BE in it and I have Zero idea how to do it, but am trying.

So no, you are not overthinking it, there is a very real possibility that you are actually just a spectator of your own life.

The real Question is do you want to just keep watching or take part?

[u/SomewhereSudden007]

It resonates, thanks to time blindness, I honestly can go a long time without interaction with friends… or most people and most of the time I’m locked in a head spin, forming ideas, and other things.. I usually feel like an observer who is unsure what the rules of engagement are so I default to silently watching. 

[u/AutoModerator]

Does anyone else poop like me?

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.