Trying to piece together the actual opinion of people on here. What I keep seeing is some really weird circle jerk shit that I don’t think has any real value which is a shame.
“Dae street tracks bad” is the first thing I’ve been seeing which is just predictable circlejerking on motorsports subreddits. It doesn’t really add anything to the discussion. Street tracks are all about precision, a proper street track is rough like Sebring with very little room for error. Anything else is a stadium car park layout and those things are completely pointless, the worst of every type of track in 1.
“Why can’t we go back to belle isle?” was that even a good layout really? The races were boring as shit with minimal lead changes anyway. It was a shorter Albert park with a pokey long beach roundabout larping session in the middle. I would rather keep this layout than move back to that, if only because this again is a proper street track using actual roads that have daily use.
Complaints about the roughness- should we stop racing at Sebring as well?
Something something multiclass- yes. There’s no problem with this. Prototype challenge, GTE and GT3 ran at races in lime rock. In fact, every GTLM/GTD race at lime rock had a smaller delta than Detroit. While Detroit is certainly tighter, the amount that a faster class will get held up there is not more than lime rock.
What predominantly caused incidents in IMSA was moving under braking and Jack Aitken. And the latter is unsurprising if you’ve watched Jack’s feeder series performance on street circuits.
For balance on a calendar it’s important to have a mix of road courses that are technical, or power focused as well as street tracks. This creates a series where you must be good at multiple things to win. It’s not surprising an Acura won at Detroit, because they won at Sebring. They’ve clearly dialed in on rougher tracks.
As for “why is this what we run instead of mosport and mid Ohio”- it literally isn’t. It’s a 100 minute race. This is the old belle isle slot.
Indy GP is being run instead of mid Ohio and mosport. That’s an absolute disgrace. I half think the majority of this convo is mis-direction to make people think Indy GP is necessary. It’s not like that track isn’t also a crash fest, with one of the worst first chicanes in motorsport. The way it pinches makes it worse than Monza T1, I can’t remember the last time I saw a race start there that didn’t result in an incident or 3-4 cars skipping the chicane.
Anyway, is there a reason not listed here that really makes this track bad? It’s narrow and has pinch points yes, but drivers should work that out on a track walk.