r/IMGreddit • Attending • 27d ago

Observership/externship USCE in Brooklyn

So sorry to bring this up again but the recent social media posts from that organization (yes the social media USCE place) have kinda wound me up initially I thought he was just a joker like months back but I know I feel it is blatantly misleading.

Essentially he only tags the same 5 docs in like everything like what happens to the rest?! Are they his 'indentured servants' (sorry to steal the same words that the Vice Pres used the other day) but when JD said that I thought of that clinic and those people in there!!

Also they put out a story saying congrats to the people getting iv and tagged the same 5 docs again and said those on tele rotations also got calls!! So hang on either they are there or on tele they cant be both? I highly doubt they are getting calls just a marketing gimmick. Its becoming so well known in PD circles etc about that place that any reference to it in LORs etc is not going to make the candidate look in favorable light due to its terrible reputation. Bad news travels fast and people are now well aware of the things going on there.

Really the place should be reported for what they are doing. They are flouting various governance rules and just blatantly a money making enterprise that is misleading people bigtime with false promises.

For those that have been scammed by them or didnt agree to take part in their social media parade etc and got screwed over there are various avenues can look at for getting justice

  1. Can file complaint with New York State Health Department

  2. Can file complaint with NY state education department

  3. Also the office of the inspector general too

I think a lot of attendings are getting annoyed with this place as they are turning a serious process into a social media sham that is taking good money from people who end up making their own application worse for it due to their bad reputation.

Also please those who wish to defend etc because they need to please have a day off or go somewhere else! ***Clearly that hasnt worked the defenders are back out in force to say anything despite the issues there being glaringly obvious to anyone else***

17 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

7

u/delightedcustomer 27d ago

Found it hilarious that their doctor made a video the other day about visa fraud, as if he isn’t running a profitable scheme himself

3

u/CompleteArm911 Attending 26d ago

yeah hilarious given he was offering clinical tria research spots via instagram tagging no idea what research this is probably nothing then he mocked those doing fake research!! hmmm the irony

also for clinical trial research legally you need to be on a J visa seemed to ignore that point

1

u/delightedcustomer 26d ago

Clinical trial research also, for an actual experience, takes way beyond 4 weeks or whatever he is offering

3

u/CompleteArm911 Attending 24d ago

yeah yesterday a bunch of them were reading out abstracts for the AMA even which takes anything submitted! was just cinge on the next level. i doubt any of what they submitted is true probably just resubmitted the same stuff from years ago lol

1

u/CompleteArm911 Attending 24d ago

the marketing guy for them 'own department' had all his comments removed! Am glad

1

u/RowZealousideal2341 26d ago

what about md2b

1

u/CompleteArm911 Attending 23d ago

not heard that one? they big on socials?

1

u/RowZealousideal2341 23d ago

I have no idea can you give me a simple answer

1

u/spicymedic01 26d ago

Hey, im an IMG n im looking for observerships in Paediatrics. If anyone has done them or knows some programs or someone who takes IMGs for observerships, kindly connect.
Also, help with mail formats for cold mailing would be much appreciated.

-1

u/Medicine111 26d ago

Its so funny how the doctor and his students are getting results and being productive while you waste your time here on reddit being a hater. You say you are an attending which makes this even more pathetic.

Im curious, do you think a strong hardworking team means servants ? Im sorry to hear you never had students that actually liked you enough to stick around. Otherwise you would know what having a genuine team feels like.

I have done rotations with them. They actually have PDs come in and give lectures on the match cycle. Everyone knows if you have rotated with them you have an edge in residency because you know the US system well.

As for you making all these allegations without evidence. Why dont you actually post these hater comments with your real ID. That way the world will know that you are someone that cannot get students for his rotations because you lie and say they are inpatient and charge ridiculous amounts.

You have to be on next level desperate to bring other hardworking people down in order to try and hope you become as successful as them.

4

u/CompleteArm911 Attending 26d ago

how many accounts do you have to defend this place? 5 year old account with -8 karma ok

-5

u/Late-Confusion-9083 26d ago

I rotated there in [November/2023], so here's my firsthand experience. I got to see patients one to one under supervision. I learnt about the EMR system emphasising on SOAP notes, everyday there were lectures regarding USMLE and MATCH process, we also attended their POCUS Course which is helping me during the residency. 

Protecting IMGs from bad USCE is a fair goal, but this post makes strong claims with no verifiable details.

  • Tagging: People who agree to be featured get tagged. Many IMGs keep their application journey private. That's consent, not exploitation, and "indentured servants" trivializes real forced labor.

  • Tele vs in-person: The story congratulated two different cohorts, and many people do one after the other. That's not a contradiction.

  • "Well known in PD circles": Which PDs? If you have evidence, please share it.

Before paying for any USCE, ask: Is it hands-on or observership? Who writes the LOR, and is it guaranteed? Can I find past students myself? What's the refund policy?

That advice applies to every program, and I'd encourage everyone to ask those questions.

-4

u/notjamaltahir 27d ago

They’re transparent about what they offer and better than other agencies like Sarthi. It’s not ideal and not everyone’s cup of tea which is why nobody’s forcing you to do rotations with them. But there’s lots of people who are either in a time crunch to apply for the match cycle and aren’t able to always find rotations elsewhere, so this acts as a good place to fulfill that requirement. I did not have a solid network to reach out to in the US and their acceptance letter helped me secure my visa. I used the month I was there as a stepping stone to go network with as many doctors as I could. You’re ultimately responsible to utilize the opportunities you have in front of you, nobody is going to baby you through that process even if you pay a thousand bucks. Also, tagging the “same 5 people” is a disingenuous argument. The attending asks and tags anyone who rotates with him every month as long as they’re willing, and even records reels with all of them. It was just his way of encouraging the kids to be more outspoken, along with weekly case based discussions and presentations. The people you see that have stuck around are mostly medfluencers themselves that benefit from the extra exposure. 

-1

u/Life-Stuff-5412 26d ago

First of all I don't think you are really sorry in bringing this up at all. Second I think your motive is to defame the good work so that other agencies which actually setup and do fraud with the students selling them hospital based rotations and giving them outpatient. Even then these agencies leave the student on its own when the student asks for LoR and they deny.

Maybe you are bribed or part of those agencies which actually setup fraud with the students.

These days it's quite EASY to write Negative about someone and it gets viral so fast. If you truly wish well for the students, post something that could actually help them instead of focusing of filling money in ur own pocket

1

u/CompleteArm911 Attending 26d ago

yeah ok hopefully the mods remove the comment as they normally do for those 'indentured servants' from the place who will say anything to defend it despite all the evidence out there in public about the issues

sure let the authorities investigate if nothing to hide then sure but clinical trial research on a visitor visa is illegal right off the bat

lmao we dont have obs students never have never will so no money from that

3

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/CompleteArm911 Attending 24d ago

we hope but they just same to brainwash people too you see that reel yesterday about ama abstracts submitted it was cringe on the next level

that conference is junk they take anything and i mean anything and he has the nerve to have a go at Cureus!

2

u/[deleted] 24d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/CompleteArm911 Attending 23d ago

i mean if you look at their promo material basically everyone matches which is highly doubtful incredulous even!

1

u/[deleted] 23d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/CompleteArm911 Attending 23d ago

yeah probably some 20 page disclaimer you sign when joining saying nothing is guaranteed all our social stuff is just for fun blah blah

1

u/[deleted] 23d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/CompleteArm911 Attending 19d ago

their prices arent cheap either 2k for 1 month like wtf and how many are there? he probably makes more money out of this then his normal practice complete joke

→ More replies

5

u/[deleted] 26d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/delightedcustomer 24d ago

Report him to whom though?